This month, the Australian government will release its emissions-reduction target for 2035, likely to be between 65% and 75%. A 70% cut would mean reducing Australia’s emissions from about 440 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent down to 132 million tonnes.
Ahead of its release, a split has emerged over whether achieving rapid cuts to emissions in ten years will be a net cost or benefit to Australia. Last week, Australia’s top business lobby group released a report suggesting A$500 billion of investment would be needed to cut emissions 70% by 2035.
The report, by the Business Council of Australia, calls for an “ambitious” but “achievable” 2035 target on the path to net zero. But this report seems more likely to be used as ammunition by those opposing an ambitious target, because it includes costs – but no benefits. By contrast, an earlier Business Council report suggested climate action would give GDP a boost.
Cutting emissions requires both public and private investment. It can also spur on new industries. Climate change is already costing a great deal of money and will cost far more if allowed to continue unchecked.
Is climate action a net cost or benefit? To date, the most detailed analysis in both Australia and the United Kingdom give the same answer: when the escalating damage done by climate change is accounted for, climate action has vastly more benefit than cost.
The cost of action – without the benefits
The Business Council’s $500 billion estimate has already become the headline figure used in the media as an estimate of the “cost” of ambitious climate action. This is unfortunate.
The $500 billion figure refers to the estimated capital investment required to achieve a 70% reduction in greenhouse emissions.
This figure is towards the upper limit of a wide band. And while $500 billion sounds huge, it is only around 1% of Australia’s likely total GDP over the coming decade.
The Business Council report is also based on “current costs and technologies”. But many of the technologies needed to achieve net zero, such as renewable energy, electric cars and grid-scale batteries, have steadily become more efficient and affordable. These trends are unlikely to halt.
The report also omits any benefits. It did not include any longer-term considerations, such as the costs of climate inaction and climate impacts. Neither did it attempt to measure GDP benefits associated with new investment.
Cutting emissions requires investment and infrastructure. But it comes with benefits and can spur on new industries.BJP7images/Getty
Climate investment brings benefits
Iron ore magnate and green industry backer Andrew Forrest has publicly challenged the Business Council report over the missing benefits, claiming it “underplays the opportunities for our economy”.
Forrest’s company, Fortescue, has led a breakaway high-ambition group of more than 500 businesses pushing for more ambitious emissions cuts.
This group – Business for 75% – recently released modelling suggesting cutting emissions by 75% rather than 65% over the next decade would increase investment by $20 billion a year. This would lead to a net benefit. Under a 75% reduction scenario, Australia’s GDP would be $227 billion higher than under a 65% reduction. There would be more exports and more jobs.
In 2021, the Business Council released a report on achieving a net-zero economy. The more comprehensive modelling here suggested substantial net benefits. On average, each Australian would be $5,000 (in today’s dollars) better off in 2050, assuming a smooth transition to net zero. Regional Australians would be even better off.
Who should we believe?
To date, arguably the most extensive modelling of the cost of climate action in Australia is the 2008 Treasury study, led by David Gruen, who is now the Australian Statistician.
The Treasury study concluded the economic cost of climate action in Australia would reduce the growth rate of real GDP by 0.1% per year.
These costs are much less than the economic damage expected from climate change. One estimate suggests:
The cumulative loss of wealth for Australia from the impacts of climate change on agricultural and labour productivity is expected to reach $4.2 trillion by 2100.
Globally, the 2006 Stern Review in the UK remains arguably the most respected and comprehensive study.
The review found cutting emissions to limit global heating would cost around 1% of the world’s GDP a year. That’s a lot. But it’s dwarfed by the damage climate change will do if allowed to continue – an estimated 5–20% of global GDP.
Estimates of how much climate change will cost have increased since then. Slow progress in reducing emissions has made action more urgent. Fortunately, the costs of renewable energy have dropped.
Most believe pricing carbon emissions is the most efficient method. This is an example of a Pigouvian tax – measures aimed at discouraging activities that cause other people harm.
Unfortunately, carbon pricing has been seen as politically unviable in Australia after a pioneering scheme was axed in 2014, despite recent interest.
What Australia has instead is the Safeguard Mechanism, which is akin to a carbon price. It sets gradually declining limits on emissions from Australia’s highest-emitting industrial facilities, which collectively produce almost a third of Australia’s greenhouse emissions. The New Vehicle Efficiency Standard will cut emissions from cars.
If politically viable, an emissions trading scheme or carbon tax would be the best approach. It would raise revenue for the government, which could be used to reduce or replace the most inefficient taxes. While critics might call it a tax on everything, it would bring widespread benefits.
Action stations
Many Australians like to think of themselves as minnows on climate change. But this is wrong.
The long economic success of wealthy Australia comes in part from cheap domestic coal and gas, as well as current exports of coal and liquefied natural gas. Australians are some of the highest per-capita emitters of greenhouse gases.
But Australia also has world-beating potential in green industries, from solar power to critical minerals to green iron. As a largely arid nation, it is likely to be hit hard by climate change.
Business leaders can often be cautious about change. But climate change will bring large, escalating and unwelcome change. The best modelling we have suggests the benefits of acting fast on climate far outweigh the costs.
John Hawkins was formerly a senior economist at Treasury and secretary of the Senate Select Committee on Climate Policy.
Exclusive: stroke risk is 7% higher and heart failure risk increases by 27% in areas with worst level of pollution, research shows
Millions of Britons face a higher risk of stroke or heart failure because of dirty air where they live.
People living in areas of the UK with the worst levels of air pollution are 27% more likely to develop heart failure, compared with people in areas with the cleanest air, a study suggests.
Conservationists have called for an audit of potentially thousands of methane-leaking coal boreholes in Queensland, as one expert says New South Wales also has an unknown number of potentially leaking holes.
Research revealed last week that two abandoned exploratory coal boreholes were leaking methane at a rate comparable to 10,000 vehicles.
Trees were planted almost 100 years ago at the entrance to a tiny New South Wales town to recognise locals who served in WWI, but residents say a proposed wind farm could “butcher” the living memorial.
For wildlife, not all trees are equal. Large old trees have many horizontal and dead limbs for perching, and many fissures or hollows for sheltering. By contrast, younger trees have far fewer such features or lack them entirely. More than 300 species of Australian mammals, birds, reptiles and amphibians rely on on habitat structures in older trees.
Pygmy possums use small hollows that take around 100 years to form. Black cockatoos need larger hollows that might take 200 years, and bigger birds such as powerful owls need still older hollows. Many species also need dead branches, peeling bark and other features found only in older trees.
Birds and animals can’t wait centuries for new hollows to form. In response, land managers are experimenting with veteranisation, where younger trees are artificially given the features of older trees. If done carefully, veteranisation may have promise.
Younger trees of 100 years or more (L) can be physically large but have no horizontal branches birds need for perching. Older trees (200-300 years) have many more such branches. In this figure, the old tree is about 500 years old.Deep Design Lab, CC BY-NC-ND
Making young trees older
Artificially ageing trees isn’t new. The ancient practice of pollarding trees to promote growth also encourages hollow formation.
But there’s new interest in exploring veteranisation to boost habitat, either by damaging trees or adding structures or supports.
Most commonly, veteranisation is done by damaging younger trees to encourage decay. Using chainsaws to cut off a limb can open up the dead heartwood inside a tree to wood-rotting fungi, which can deepen smaller hollows.
Veteranisation can also involve adding structures resembling natural hollows or cavities. Nesting boxes are well known, but animals can avoid artificial-looking structures, find them too hot or struggle to climb smooth walls. Our research has found innovative shapes and materials and other approaches can avoid this. Mimicking natural complexity can trick wildlife into using younger trees.
Large old trees offer not only perching branches, but hollows and cavities in many sizes, shapes, positions and orientations. In this figure, purple indicates areas with large hollows, yellow medium and orange small.Deep Design Lab, CC BY-NC-ND
Removing limbs, causing damage
In Europe, managers have tried cutting off the crown of the tree, breaking or pruning branches, scorching surfaces with fire, ringbarking limbs, using “coronet” cuts to trap water, drilling holes to expose internal decay and bruising stems. Swedish researchers found these techniques increased decay and created more microhabitats but didn’t affect formation of large dead branches.
Our research suggests another possibility: constructing artificial perches able to stand on their own or attach to younger trees.
We should think of these human-made features as long-lasting habitat rather than a temporary tweak. They should be carefully designed, safely installed, maintained as needed and their use monitored. At the end of their life, they should be retired and an equivalent type of habitat installed or grown.
Another approach is to preserve existing veteran trees by propping and bracing branches likely to fall.
Techniques worth exploring?
To date, Australian trials have recorded feathertail gliders, sugar gliders, brown antechinuses, long?eared bats, white?throated treecreepers and other species using features created by both damaging and feature-adding techniques. Fungi, mosses and microorganisms can also benefit.
Many other species could benefit, including hollow?nesting and perching birds, bats, arboreal marsupials and the saproxylic beetles which eat dead and decaying wood.
It will take more research to find out which techniques work best. Approaches such as topping aren’t very effective in speeding up hollow development, while other approaches can attract unwanted species or shorten the lives of damaged trees.
Similarly, some fissures close soon after their creation, while modifications such as inoculation with tree-rotting fungi don’t work well in producing these features.
Applying veteranisation in Australia will require adaptation. Bushfires can pose a threat to trees temporarily weakened by veteranisation or augmented by artificial structures. Eucalypts have distinct wood chemistry allowing them to repair wounds and resist rot.
Overall, we should think of veteranisation as a supplement rather than substitute for large old trees.
This is because artificial features aren’t the same as natural. The communities of fungi and invertebrates that live on tree surfaces, in cracks and within hollows can differ from their natural counterparts.
Large old trees offer far more habitat in the form of hollows, cavities and horizontal branches than younger. Pictured: an ancient Antarctic beech in Queensland.Oliver Strewe/Getty
Protect large old trees first
It can be alluring to come across new ideas such as veteranisation. But the thrill of the new can make it hard to see the situation clearly.
For land managers, the priorities are clear. Protect every remaining large old tree and ensure younger trees can grow old safely.
If this is done, it may be worth experimenting with veteranisation to mimic old trees in areas where there are shortages. Testing will be essential. Run trials, make adjustments to find improvements, share data openly about what works and what doesn’t, and make advanced methods available to everyone.
Tree-damaging methods are worth exploring, but they should not be our first choice. It doesn’t seem right to damage young trees to make up for the damage humans have done to their ancestors.
Acknowledgements: We thank Darren Le Roux for his research informing this article’s figures.
Stanislav Roudavski receives funding from the Australian Research Council and ACT Parks and Conservation.
Alexander Holland receives funding from the Australian Research Council and ACT Parks and Conservation.
Philip Gibbons receives funding from Riverview Projects Pty Ltd, the New South Wales Natural Resources Commission, the New South Wales Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water and the Australian Capital Territory Environment, Planning and Sustainable Development Directorate.