This week, a Senate committee examining Australia’s disaster resilience tabled its long-awaited report in parliament.
The 151-page report makes ten recommendations. These concern funding arrangements, mental health supports, emergency volunteering models, and the need to establish a national asset register.
Overall, the report captures a broad selection of issues in disaster management. It acknowledges the views and perspectives of many stakeholders.
However, its recommendations largely focus on volunteers involved in the immediate disaster response. This will not make Australians more resilient to disasters, because communities need long-term support to develop their capacity to bounce back. Deeper structural reform is required.
A wide-ranging inquiry
The report was titled “Boots on the ground: Raising resilience”. It was commissioned in November 2022 to inquire into Australia’s disaster preparedness, response and recovery workforce models, as well as alternatives.
The committee also had to consider the role of the Australian Defence Force, volunteer groups, not-for-profit organisations and state-based services, as well as the support required to improve Australia’s resilience and response to natural disasters.
Over almost two years, the inquiry received 174 submissions from charities, government agencies, academics, emergency services and the general public. It also conducted 17 public hearings across all states and territories.
Understanding the needs of communities
We analysed more than 150 of these submissions to the inquiry in our research last year into the role of community organisations in disasters.
Our focus was on the contributions place-based, frontline community organisations such as neighbourhood houses or centres can make to building disaster resilience.
Community organisations are both first and last responders, and play a vital but often overlooked role in disaster response, recovery and resilience-building.
We have now analysed the report to see how well it responds to issues raised in submissions. Unfortunately, we found it fails to address the vital role and needs of communities.
Firstly, the report acknowledges community sector organisations’ calls for additional resourcing and identifies funding shortcomings for their vital work in disasters. But it falls short of recommending any funding measures specifically for this sector. None of the recommendations in this report will fix the problem of persistent underfunding for frontline, place-based community services.
Secondly, it identifies the urgent need for mental health and trauma-informed approaches, and recommends the creation of a national disaster mental health hub. While investment in mental health is always welcome, more information is required to determine how this recommendation will work in practice.
Thirdly, the report lacks any recommendations to formally integrate or fund community organisations’ participation in disaster governance. This is despite evidence of the need to give community organisations a genuine seat at the table so they can share their expertise on local needs and capacities. This reflects our research, which shows community organisations still sit on the periphery of formal disaster management arrangements.
Our research: beyond ‘tinny heroes’ and ‘mud armies’
During our research, we identified common themes in the submissions. Let’s take a closer look at the top three things communities want.
1. Community organisations’ contributions are crucial, but invisible and undervalued
Community organisations play crucial long-term roles in building disaster resilience. But their efforts are often undervalued, under-recognised, and poorly defined within disaster management policy frameworks. This theme emerged time and time again.
Many submissions highlighted the frustration of communities and frontline staff at the lack of understanding in government agencies about their roles, or downplaying their local knowledge.
These submissions also highlighted the absence of formal policies to clarify the roles of community organisations in disaster preparedness, response and recovery. Most submissions called for increased funding to enable community organisations to sustain their support and to be consulted in the creation of any disaster response strategies.
2. Communities’ and first responders’ mental health is being affected
Compounding, cascading events are affecting communities’ and first responders’ mental health. Many submissions identified a need for greater mental health support. This would include trauma-informed training and care that is more coordinated, proactive and planned.
Community organisations provide person-centred, trauma-informed care to individuals in disaster response, and throughout the long tail of disaster recovery.
3. Disaster resilience is an under-realised opportunity and asset
Multiple submissions from community organisations called for a shift in thinking away from a reactive cycle of response and recovery.
The authorities need to stop treating disasters as one-off events and move towards a long-term focus on disaster preparedness.
Communities sought more resources to expand their work, including through volunteer coordination. Many operate with limited, short-term funding, and experience high staff turnover and burnout.
The work of community organisations is especially relevant given declining rates of volunteering fuelled by an ageing population, the impact of COVID, and the cost-of-living crisis. Exhausted volunteering networks cannot be expected to continue offering services without better support.
A missed opportunity
With memories of devastating fires and floods fresh in the minds of many Australians, the Senate inquiry came at an opportune time.
Australia is also expected to experience worsening disasters as climate change accelerates, so it has never been more important to strengthen our resilience.
While the senate committee’s report is welcome, its recommendations are far narrower than the themes and issues contained within it.
It’s disappointing that once again, voices of those who have engaged in the process are not adequately reflected in recommendations that would deliver policy change. The community sector is stretched beyond its limits and experiencing consultation fatigue.
Unfortunately there is little here for place-based community organisations on the frontline as they approach the next disaster.
Despite the narrow recommendations, there is still an opportunity for the government response to address broader issues canvassed in the report. It is never too late to invest in community organisations and this will deliver long-term benefits for Australians as climate change intensifies.
The authors wish to acknowledge law Professor Rowena Maguire and human rights expert Associate Professor Bridget Lewis for their contributions to this article.
Monica Taylor has previously worked for Community Legal Centres Queensland and the Queensland Council of Social Service, two peak bodies in Queensland supporting the community legal and social service sector.
Much of the climate conversation in Australia to date has centred on actions to limit global warming, recognising that each increment of warming contributes to worsening climate extremes.
In a recently released book, Living Hot: Surviving and Thriving on a Heating Planet, authors Clive Hamilton and George Wilkenfeld argue while emissions reduction should continue, Australia should refocus its efforts on “adaptation”, or building resilience to the effects of climate change.
Certainly, Australia cannot ignore adaptation. Extreme weather, driven by climate change, repeatedly batters much of the country – and some areas get little reprieve between natural disasters.
But Australia’s emissions-reduction efforts must continue in haste, at large scale. Real change is possible. It will require everything, everywhere, all at once.
Mixed progress
The world is on track to warm by almost 3°C on pre-industrial levels, unless current national pledges to reduce emissions are ramped up.
Climate change is already leading to more intense and frequent extreme weather events in Australia’s global region, the Asia-Pacific.
However, the region’s progress on climate action has been mixed at best. As such, many countries are seeking to adapt to their “new normal”.
Indonesia, for example, is moving its capital city from sinking Jakarta to the new city of Nusantara – partly as a climate adaptation measure.
Of the world’s high-income nations, Australia is one of the most vulnerable in a warmer world. We must focus on both cutting our emissions, and fundamentally rethinking how we live.
Mitigation and adaptation: two sides of a coin
When we prioritise both cutting emissions and adapting to climate change, twin benefits can flow.
Research by our organisation, Climateworks Centre, shows how this applies to conserving ocean ecosystems around Indonesia, the largest archipelago-nation in the world.
Mangroves, with their strong root systems, help protect coastal communities and lands from extreme weather events. They can also provide significant long-term “sinks”, or storage, for carbon.
Protecting these important ocean ecosystems can bolster Indonesia’s climate resilience and avoid more carbon entering the atmosphere. It’s a win-win for both adaptation and mitigation.
Similarly in Australia, the choices we make around land use can help us both mitigate and adapt to climate change. This understanding underpins the world-leading “Land Use Trade-offs” model, originally developed by CSIRO.
Climateworks and Deakin University released a new version of the model in 2023. It maps the best way to use and manage land in Australia to meet climate targets, agricultural demand and biodiversity goals.
For example, well-designed solar arrays can produce clean energy and increase livestock productivity, by sheltering sheep and protecting pasture.
Technology is outpacing expectations
Hamilton and Wilkenfeld argue humanity relies on a technology-only approach to climate action at our own peril.
There is truth here. However, technological advances to date cannot be understated. In fact, many renewable technologies have consistently outpaced our expectations – such as affordable solar, batteries, electric vehicles and LED lights.
There is also great potential for technology to lower emissions in Australia’s heavy industry.
In 2022, an initiative co-convened by Climateworks found 70 million tonnes of emissions reduction was possible in just five industrial regions of Australia – representing an 88% reduction – if timely, effective action was taken. This action also sets Australia up to make good on its superpower ambition, as a producer of green steel and hydrogen.
Living Hot highlights the immense increase required in Australia’s renewable energy supply if everything currently powered by fossil fuels is to be powered by clean sources. We agree. Australia’s electricity and grid needs are far bigger than we have planned for to date.
This pressure on the grid can be reduced, however. We could use energy far more efficiently in our homes, businesses and industries.
And in some cases, these changes bring multiple benefits. Well-designed homes are cooler in summer and warmer in winter. They are also cheaper to run, more resilient to climate-driven extremes and use less energy.
Regional cooperation is key
The authors of Living Hot argue nothing Australia does “can appreciably change the climate Australians will live through in 2050 and beyond”.
In isolation, this could well be the case. But Australia can have a significant impact on global efforts to tackle climate change, if it respond to calls from our region to cooperate meaningfully on emissions reduction.
Over the last two decades, emissions in the Southeast Asian region have grown nearly 5% a year as nations in the region rapidly industrialise.
Left unchecked, this emissions-intensive growth risks pushing global warming past thresholds crucial for stabilising Earth’s climate.
Australia and our region can provide many of the minerals and materials needed in the transition to clean energy. To achieve this, Australia should work collaboratively with our Indo-Pacific neighbours, such as helping them acquire the specialised skills needed to decarbonise.
Looking to COP31
Australia is bidding to host the 2026 United Nations climate conference, COP31, in partnership with our Pacific neighbours.
If we succeed, it would provide a once-in-a-generation opportunity to champion the urgency of both ambitious climate mitigation and adaptation in our region.
For the Pacific, climate adaptation is existential. Tuvalu is maintaining its identity, even though its land could disappear in mere decades. But in Southeast Asia, the greater challenge, and economic opportunities, remain in mitigating emissions.
Dramatic emissions reduction – enough to slow, and eventually stop global warming – will give nations longer to adapt.
Australia has a lot to lose in the face of climate change, but also a lot to gain. We are one of the sunniest and windiest places on the planet, with a vast landmass and rich reserves of critical minerals needed in the energy transition.
A more certain, safer future for all is within our grasp. It requires both going as hard as possible on reducing emissions, and adapting to the changes ahead.
Anna Malos does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article. Climateworks Centre, part of Monash University, receives philanthropic funding and grants for its work.
Luke Brown does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Western Australian wildflowers draw the crowdsRobert A. Davis, Author provided
Have you ever liked or shared a social media post about nature? It could have been a photo of a rare orchid or an unusual bird. Or you might share a stunning photo of an “undiscovered” natural place.
It feels good to do so. You’re sharing something beautiful, an antidote to negativity. But not even this simple act is problem-free.
Social media have become a huge force. It’s come with many positives for nature, such as greater visibility and interest in citizen science and public knowledge about the species we share the planet with. Australia’s largest citizen science project, the Aussie Bird Count, collected reports of 3.6 million birds in backyards in one week, for example, making good use of social media.
There is, unfortunately, a dark side to this effortless sharing of information. It is possible to love species to death, as our new research has found.
How? Viral photos of undisturbed natural beauty can lead thousands of people to head there. As more people arrive, they begin destroying what they loved seeing on screen.
And then there’s the competitiveness among photographers and content-makers hoping to gain influence or visibility by posting natural content. Unethical techniques are common, such as playing the calls of rare bird species to lure them out for a photo.
Social media do not directly cause damage, of course. But the desire for positive feedback, visibility or income can be very strong incentives to act badly.
Can social media really damage species?
The critically endangered blue-crowned laughingthrush now lives in only one province in China. Its wild population is now around 300.
So many people went to find and photograph this rare bird that the laughingthrush was forced to change how it nested to avoid flashlights and the sound of camera shutters.
Or consider bird call playback. For scientists, playing a bird’s calls is a vital tool. You can use calls to entice seabird colonies back to former nesting grounds or to monitor threatened or hard-to-spot species.
It’s very easy for birdwatchers and photographers to misuse this power by using bird ID apps and a speaker to draw out rare species. It might seem harmless, but drawing shy woodland birds out into the open risks predation, or can entice a mother off her nest. Playing calls can also make birds aggressive, change important behaviours, or disrupt their breeding.
Many people want to take photos of the blue-crowned laughingthrush. But the pressure of human interest puts these rare birds on edge – and can even affect their breeding.Vine.Photographic/Shutterstock
Baiting, drones, poaching and trampling
The list of bad behaviours goes on and on.
Wildlife photographers are known to use baiting to get their photo – putting out food sources (natural or artificial), scent lures and decoys to boost their chances. But when baiting is done routinely, it changes animal behaviour. Baiting by tourist operators who offering swimming with sharks has led to reduced gene flow, changed shark metabolism and increased aggression.
Drone photography, too, comes with problems. Drones terrify many species of wildlife, causing them to break cover, try to escape or to become aggressive. In Western Australia, for instance, an osprey suffered injuries after a photographer flew their drone into it.
Then there are the world’s rare or fragile plants. Social media give us beautiful images of wildflower meadows and rainforests. But when we collectively go and see these places, we risk trampling them. Unlike animals, plants can’t run away.
Take orchids, a family of flowering plants with many human admirers. During the 18th century, “orchidelerium” gripped Europe. Rich people paid orchid hunters to roam the globe and collect rare species.
In our time, orchids face a different threat – social-media-driven visitors. Orchids are very particular – they rely on specific fungal partners. But this makes them highly vulnerable if their habitat changes. One study found that of 442 vulnerable orchid species, 40% were at risk from tourism and recreation.
Sharing locations is a big part of the problem. Even if you deliberately don’t make reference to where you took the photo, the GPS co-ordinates are often embedded in a photo’s metadata.
In 2010, a new species of slipper orchid (Paphiopedilum canhii) was discovered in Vietnam. Photos with location information were posted online. Just six months after discovery, more than 99% of all known individuals had been collected. The orchid is now extinct in the wild.
What should be done?
Broadly, we need to talk about the need to make ethical choices in how we present nature on social media.
But there is a specific group who can help – the admins of large social media groups devoted to, say, wild orchids, birdwatching or scuba diving. Admins have significant influence over what can be posted in their groups. Better moderation can go a long way.
Site admins can make expectations clear in their codes of conduct. They could, for instance, ban photos of rare orchids until after the flowering season, or put a blanket ban on posts with locations, as well as explain how photos can have embedded location data.
Park and land managers have other tools, such as banning drones from specific areas and making it harder to access environmentally sensitive areas. There’s a very good reason, for instance, why the location of wild populations of Wollemi pines is a secret.
Many of us won’t have given much thought about how social media can damage the natural world. But it is a real problem – and it won’t go away by itself.
Dr Belinda Davis from Western Australia’s Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions contributed to this article.
The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
The deep complexities of climate change raise a myriad of challenges for humanity – not least of which is how best to respond. Should we throw ourselves into slashing carbon emissions and stabilising Earth’s climate as soon as possible? Or accept our fate and go into survival mode?
A recently published book tackles this question. In Living Hot: Surviving and Thriving on a Heating Planet, public ethicist Clive Hamilton and energy expert George Wilkenfeld urge Australia to get serious about climate adaptation.
Many of the pair’s arguments make perfect sense. The path to decarbonisation is challenging, and progress has been far too slow. And of course, the world has already heated far too much and more damage is already locked in – so adapting is vital.
However, I disagree with the central thesis of the book: that humanity cannot adapt adequately to climate change if we keep trying so hard to reduce emissions. This is not an either-or proposition: we must do both.
Not a zero-sum game
Climate mitigation refers to efforts to reduce the amount of heat-trapping greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Adaptation involves adjusting our lives to cope with life on a hotter planet – such as higher seas and more extreme weather.
Much of Living Hot is devoted to outlining the barriers and limits to Australia’s mitigation task.
However, I find other parts of the book problematic.
Hamilton and Wilkenfeld argue that hopes of returning to a safe climate are “wishful thinking”. They say Australia has been too slow on climate action and has wasted its chance of becoming a renewable energy superpower. They believe attempts to “electrify everything” – replacing our coal- and gas-powered economy with renewable energy, and electric vehicles and appliances – will likely fail.
Overall, the pair believe while Australia should still strive to meet its international obligations to reduce emissions, our primary focus should now be on planning to live on an overheated planet. Or in their words: “our only choice now is to focus on adaptation”.
I have several issues with this argument. First, it’s broadly accepted in the academic literature that reducing emissions is vital if adaptation is to be successful. As the old adage goes, prevention is better than cure.
Second, Hamilton and Wilkenfeld devote a large portion of the book to outlining the problems with mitigation, but apply a far less critical lens to the many barriers and limits to adaptation.
Transforming society to adapt to climate change will be no easy task. The book does note some complexities involved in, say, retrofitting homes to make them more resilient to disasters, or relocating flood-prone communities. It touches on the futility of building river levees and seawalls, and the general challenges of building community consensus for change.
But to me, this part of the analysis feels underdone. Exactly how will we get Australians on board with adaptation actions such as pre-emptively relocating entire regions, when we have barely embraced far easier changes, such as eating less meat?
Hamilton and Wilkenfeld argue the challenges inherent in mitigation – such as cost and political resistance, or our slowness to act – are essentially now insurmountable. Yet this same logic is not applied to the adaptation discussion.
All this leaves me wondering why Hamilton and Wilkenfeld didn’t argue for a two-pronged approach: full-throttle emissions reduction coupled with transformative adaptation.
Hamilton himself has done much in the past to raise public awareness of the need to heed the science and cut emissions. By approaching mitigation and adaptation hand-in-hand, we could harness community concern about climate change to kickstart and bolster adaptation actions.
Australians are increasingly climate-literate. It seems far-fetched to imagine people would accept the argument that mitigation has essentially failed and we must now accept catastrophic heating.
Despondency is not ‘natural’
At the end of Living Hot, Hamilton and Wilkenfeld discuss the “personal oddesey” of researching and writing the book. They write:
Making ourselves peer into the abyss of an Australian society struggling to cope with an unending series of extreme events meant reconfiguring our picture of what the future will be like.
Yet I disagree when Hamilton and Wilkenfeld write it is “natural to be despondent when thinking about climate change”.
Yes, feeling disillusioned about climate crisis is common, and valid. So too is feeling overwhelmed, cynical, horrified, depressed, confused, isolated or angry.
But as my research has shown, feelings of climate distress are not “natural”. They arise from emotional violence inflicted on us by political systems that know a public that feels disillusioned, overwhelmed and burnt-out is less likely to fight the expansion of fossil-fuelled capitalism.
Others do not have this luxury. Those on the frontlines of the climate crisis – young people, Pacific Islanders, disaster survivors, First Nations peoples, and others vulnerable to climate change – cannot give up. Many already live with the catastrophic impacts of global warming, or will still be alive when the worst effects are felt. They do not call for us to lower our mitigation ambitions. They keep fighting.
As part of a recent collaborative research project, I spoke to wildlife carers about their efforts to care for animals during the Black Summer bushfires. These people went to extreme lengths – compromising their finances, physical and mental health – to save or care for as many animals as they could.
Of course, the number of animals they were able to save pales in comparison to three billion displaced or incinerated. Still, these people didn’t quit.
It’s in these acts of perseverance, in the face of seemingly insurmountable challenges, where we can truly find hope.
Blanche Verlie received funding from the Australian Commonwealth Government via a Bushfire Recovery Grant from the Department of Industry, Science, Energy and Resources under grant number GA223763 for the wildlife carer research discussed in this article. Blanche is on the Board of Directors of Climate for Change.