When fish are taken from our oceans faster than they can reproduce, their population numbers decline. This over-fishing upsets marine ecosystems. It’s also bad for human populations that rely on fish for protein in their diets.
To manage fishing areas sustainably, we need accurate data on how many fish exist and how abundant they will be in future. Fisheries scientists use complex mathematical models to determine this.
We studied 230 fisheries around the world. We found populations of many overfished species are in far worse condition than has been reported, and the sustainability of fisheries was overstated. Urgent action is needed to ensure our oceans are not fished below their capacity to recover.
Alarming findings
A sustainable fishing operation would ensure the numbers of fish caught does not outstrip the capacity of a fish population to reproduce. In cases where an area has been overfished, stocks should be given time to rebuild.
To determine appropriate catch rates, computer models are used to assess fish stocks. The models are fed data such as fish biology, catch history, and rates of fish breeding, growth and death.
Our investigation tested how accurate estimates of fish stocks actually are. It involved examining data from 230 of the world’s largest fisheries, spanning 128 fish species. They include fishing areas off Australia, New Zealand, the United States, Europe, the United Kingdom, Canada, Argentina and South Africa.
We focused on the depletion in the “biomass”, or total weight, of fish stocks. When fish catch falls to below 10% of its biomass when fishing began, the fish stock is widely said to have collapsed.
For each fish stock, we took data that provided the best estimate of stock depletion at a given year in the past. The data was produced by scientists and reported to fisheries managers and databases.
We compared this historical data to updated modelling produced years later. The updated data was the most recent assessment of that fish stock, but was also “backdated” to the same year as the historical data. The more recent estimates should be more accurate because they are based on data collected over a longer period, and after improvements in the modelling process.
So what did we find? The earlier stock assessments were often too optimistic about the number of fish in the ocean.
For sustainably fished stocks, the earlier estimates were generally accurate. But for stocks that were overfished, most earlier data turned out to be substantially overestimated. In many cases, fish stocks were regarded at the time to be recovering when they were in fact declining.
Among over-fished stocks, we estimated the number of collapsed stocks was likely 85% larger than currently recognised.
How has this discrepancy come about? The models used to make stock assessments are complex and involve many inputs. This can lead to uncertain or inaccurate results – a problem that accumulates each time a value is entered into the model.
As I outline below, the consequences can be devastating.
The case of the jackass morwong
The jackass morwong (also known as deep sea perch) is found off southern Australia and New Zealand. In 2009, models estimated the total stock size for south-eastern Australia at 4,680 tonnes – 22% of the 21,200 tonnes that existed when fishing began. This estimate informed decisions by fisheries managers about how many fish could sustainably be caught in future years.
But modelling in 2014 indicated stock size in 2009 was more likely to have been 3,330 tonnes, and the initial stock size was probably about 28,800 tonnes. That means in 2009, stocks were likely to have depleted to 12% of original levels, not 22%.
The inaccurate estimates mean the “total allowable fish catch” set by the Australian Fisheries Management Authority for jackass morwong is likely to have been unsustainable. Fishing continued with little constraint and the morwong population continued to decline for a decade.
By 2022, however, the declining fish numbers were clear. That year, the authority announced five ocean areas would close to trawl fishers, in a bid to protect the jackass morwong and other fish species. The federal government also allocated about A$24 million to buy back fishing vessel permits.
This probably could have been avoided if accurate stock models had been applied and the full extent of depletion recognised a decade earlier.
Numbers of jackass morwong have plummeted.Graham Edgar, CC BY
Fundamental change is needed
Our research shows the global problem of overfishing is far worse than currently recognised. So what should be done?
Clearly, scientists should try to improve the accuracy of models used to assess fish stocks.
And management of fisheries should be far more cautious, to protect fish stocks around the world. This is vital for sustainable fisheries, healthy oceans, and our own food security.
Graham Edgar does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Oil firms, petrostates, airlines and carmakers ‘doubling down’ on sector that is popular with young people
Oil companies, petrostates, airlines and carmakers are among the big polluters bombarding the esports industry with adverts, a study has found.
Esports, short for electronic sports, are competitive video games watched by spectators, with multiplayer games such as League of Legends and Defense of the Ancients 2 attracting peak viewer figures in the millions.
Multi-billion-dollar transport projects create headlines, and politicians love to bask in the glow of a successfully completed project such as Sydney’s new Metro. This service will change many people’s lives for the better.
In stark contrast with the shiny new Metro stations, the bus network is suffering from under-investment. Our survey of thousands of suburban bus stops, conducted with advocacy group Sweltering Cities, found many lack shelter, seating, signage and even stable surfaces.
Fixing Sydney’s busted bus stops might not grab headlines, but it will greatly improve access to our public transport network. It will also provide comfort and dignity for the many people who rely on buses. Sydneysiders make more than 600,000 bus trips every weekday.
Extreme heat and rain are becoming more frequent with climate change. This makes the task of providing bus riders with adequate shelter even more urgent.
But, for passengers, bus stops are public places in their neighbourhood. If they lack basic amenity such as shade, seating, signage and smooth surfaces, they become the “weakest link in the journey chain”, either discouraging or preventing people from using bus services. Transport researchers are increasingly recognising the importance of bus stop infrastructure for making buses accessible – especially for riders who have mobility or health issues.
In cities such as Atlanta and New York in the United States, organised groups of bus riders are agitating for improvements. They not only want to improve access, but also to combat the indignity of waiting for buses in places that offer them no care or protection.
Sydney’s busted bus stops
Buses are a vital element of metropolitan Sydney’s public transport. Some 37% of public transport trips in New South Wales are by bus.
This bus stop in Mount Druitt is one of many that leave a lot to be desired.Author provided, Sweltering Cities
But Sydney’s network of more than 20,000 bus stops leaves a lot to be desired. Their sorry state has led to a community campaign for improvements.
As part of Sweltering Cities’ “Busted Bus Stops” campaign, community members and University of Sydney urban geography students conducted a “bus stop census”. We documented the amenities at more than 2,500 bus stops in Sydney. Using a combination of Google Street View and in-person field visits, we mapped the stops with shelters or shade structures, seats and signage.
We focused our attention especially on the hottest suburbs in the west. It can be over 9°C hotter here than in the city’s east. Extremely hot days are also more frequent.
Exposure to extreme heat can have a range of harmful health effects. Some groups like children and older people are especially vulnerable.
At this bus stop in Fairfield West, the temperature in the sun hit 63.5°C in January 2023.Author provided, Sweltering Cities
What did the survey find?
Analysing this data, the Busted Bus Stops report revealed glaring problems and inequalities. For instance:
more than 60% of 105 bus stops mapped in the new growth area around Schofields in the north-west had no shelter, shade or seating
almost 70% of 596 bus stops mapped in and around Penrith, where temperatures have reached over 50°C in summer, had no shelter, shade or seating
in comparison, in the inner-west suburbs of Strathfield, Ashfield and Summer Hill, over 65% of 101 bus stops mapped had seating and shade or shelter.
Not surprisingly, passengers raised bus stop amenity as a key issue during consultations for the NSW government’s 2023 Bus Industry Taskforce report. Many Sydneysiders will be familiar with the experiences passengers shared – such as seeking shelter from the sun or rain by moving away from an unsheltered bus stop, only to then have the bus you are waiting for cruise right past.
Upgrades aren’t glamorous but make a huge difference
Reflecting the neglect of bus stops, Transport for NSW does not take responsibility for providing bus stop shelters, seating or surface works. Indeed, when we started our research, we asked Transport for NSW if they could share data about bus stop shelters and were told they didn’t collect it.
Responsibility for bus stop amenity falls mostly on cash-strapped local councils. This leads to unequal provision across the city.
Local councils in wealthy areas have more resources to provide bus shelters. They are also in a better position to strike deals with outdoor advertising companies to provide street furniture like bus stops.
Lower-income and hotter areas where good shelters are most needed are left behind. This is the case in Western Sydney’s 2770 postcode suburbs of Willmot, Lethbridge Park, Bidwill and Tregear. Residents there are calling for improvements to bus amenities and services.
Willmot residents would love to have a sheltered seat to wait for infrequent buses when it’s hot or raining.Author provided, BaptistCare HopeStreet
These problems can be fixed. The City of Los Angeles recently started a major upgrade project to install 3,000 shelters and 450 shade structures at bus stops across the city over the next ten years. Priority locations are being identified through analysis of ridership data, along with equity and heat indexes. The goal is for 75% of all passengers to board buses from locations with a shelter.
It’s time for the NSW government to follow LA’s lead and launch a city-wide program of upgrades for Sydney’s neglected bus stops.
Investing in bus stops might be less glamorous than new mega-projects. But it’s a lot cheaper.
And, just like the new Metro, it would make a huge difference to the everyday lives of millions of Sydneysiders – especially the young, the old and others who are most vulnerable to heat and depend on buses because they don’t drive.
No funding is reported for this research. Kurt Iveson has received funding in the past from the Australian Research Council, the City of Sydney, and the Henry Halloran Trust. He is actively involved in the Sydney Alliance – a coalition of unions, faith organisations and community organisations working for a fairer and more sustainable Sydney.
In a senate inquiry report, the Greens and high-profile crossbencher David Pocock have called for an investigation into the federal government’s $1.5 billion commitment to the Middle Arm Industrial Precinct and recommended funds be directed away from supporting fossil fuel projects.