From Melbourne’s proposed Outer Metropolitan Ring Road to Sydney’s recently completed Westconnex, Australia’s addiction to mega roads continues despite the spectre of climate change.
The stream of projects shows Australia’s approach to urban transport is stuck in the car-obsessed past. It’s an approach at odds with state planning policies that prioritise other less-polluting transport modes, such as train and tram extensions, bike lane infrastructure and better pedestrian footpaths.
As the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has warned, roads hinder national efforts to meet climate targets. They “lock in” emissions, by establishing long-term infrastructure that commits societies to greenhouse gas emissions for decades to come.
Expanding freeway networks undermines efforts to reduce emissions and encourage cleaner transport. It points to a deep-seated flaw in Australia’s urban planning systems which must be solved.
The IPCC says roads hinder national efforts to meet climate targets. Pictured: a freeway network in LA.Visions of America/Joe Sohm/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
Here, we examine the Melbourne project in more detail.
Globally, roads account for 69% of transport emissions.James Gourley/Getty Images
Melbourne’s mega ring road
The Outer Metropolitan Ring Road would involve a 100-kilometre freeway orbiting Melbourne’s north and west. With a current price tag of A$31 billion, it would be among the most expensive road projects in an Australian city.
Rationales for the decision included that the project passes through land extensively disturbed in the past, and because sustainability implications had been considered in overarching state planning blueprints.
It is unclear whether, given the time that has lapsed, whether the project will be reconsidered for environmental approval – and if so, what level of scrutiny would be applied.
Given the project’s potential contribution to transport emissions, authorities should reverse the exemption and ensure it is subject to the highest environmental scrutiny. This is vital to ensure the public is fully aware of – and can object to – the project’s climate impacts.
Our research has previously identified such issues involving public consultation and major road projects. They include Melbourne’s East West Link and West Gate Tunnel, and Sydney’s Westconnex . In the case of Westconnex, the “public interest” was narrowly defined and inadequate in addressing climate change concerns.
A 2017 Victorian Auditor-General Report also found a power imbalance between project proponents and community participants. For instance, proponents usually had legal representation while community members did not.
What’s more, emissions reduction must be central to the policies governing Australia’s built environments, as we discuss below.
A map showing the proposed route of Melbourne’s Outer Metropolitan Ring Road.Infrastructure Australia
Climate must be key
Residents in Australia’s capital cities are largely car-dependent. More climate-friendly transport modes, such as walking and cycling, can be difficult due to long distances between destinations, and lack of supporting infrastructure such as bike paths.
The IPCC recommends minimising emissions generated in cities through:
infill development (building on unused land in urban areas)
increasing density (the number of people living in a certain area)
improving public transport
supporting walking, cycling and other “active” transport options.
State planning blueprints in Australia typically consider land use and transport together. Victoria, for example, wants more homes built in established areas, close to public transport, services and jobs. Transport plans in states such as NSW and Queensland have similar goals.
As Australian cities continue to grow, the demand for travel will also increase. But new freeway projects are not the answer – they will only make climate change worse.
Reform is needed to ensure emissions reduction is at the heart of transport investment in our cities.
Crystal Legacy receives funding from the Australian Research Council to support her research on infrastructure planning, public participation and the future of urban transport governance. She has also previously received research from the Henry Halloran Trust and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (Canada).
Anna Hurlimann received funding from the Australian Research Council Discovery Grant for research on climate change action in cities. She is a member of the Planning Institute of Australia.
Eric Keys is affiliated with the Victorian Transport Action Group.
A developer, claiming to be the first carbon-neutral property company, faces backlash from local conservationists concerned about the impact of removing 500 trees on a neighbouring national park.
Living in cities exposes people to all sorts of chemical pollutants. Many are harmful even at low concentrations. But it is hard to know what the risks and consequences might be.
The animals we share our cities with can indicate potential sources and effects of such pollution. In this way, they act as sentinels — just like the canary in the coalmine, used to alert underground miners to the presence of dangerous levels of toxic gases in the 19th century.
Our research on house sparrows in three Australian towns revealed subtle but disturbing effects of pollution on these birds.
In the mining town of Broken Hill, New South Wales, sparrows suffered from exposure to lead in areas where thousands of people live. Similarly, in Portland, Victoria and George Town, Tasmania, sparrows living near aluminium smelters were affected by the smelting byproduct fluoride. The results suggest the health and wellbeing of city people may also be at risk.
Anxiety: aversion to the human gaze
Sparrows have lived alongside people for thousands of years. In that time they have picked up useful skills, such as feeding off food scraps, while avoiding harm.
Most people are familiar with the sight of a sparrow boldly feeding from leftover food at a café, even indoors. If the birds are ignored they often feed within arm’s length. But as soon as someone looks directly at them, they fly away and become very wary.
This is one of the sparrow’s super skills, allowing them to thrive in the urban environment. People mostly ignore them and cause them no harm. But if a person is focused on them, they respond as if they suspect something bad might happen.
Sensitivity to the human gaze is well studied in human psychology. It has also been shown in urban gulls that steal food in Europe.
People all over the world are familiar with the sight of bold sparrows hoping for crumbs at cafés.Burak, pexels, CC BY
Sparrows have small home ranges (about 300 metres). We established enclosed feeding stations at four sites across the city. We also tagged each bird and measured the amount of lead in their blood.
Then we erected boards with a photograph of a man either looking directly at the feeding station, or to the side. We presented different pictures over several days. Our results showed a clear distinction between responses to the images.
Sparrows flocked to the feeding stations. But they took much longer to visit the feeder when the man in the picture appeared to be looking at them. Those living in areas with high lead levels were especially sensitive to the direction of gaze.
Video recordings of sparrows revealed those with high levels of lead in their blood were more anxious. They spent more time looking up and checking for predators than sparrows in areas where lead pollution levels were relatively low.
Our research showed sparrows living in contaminated areas of Broken Hill were more anxious. This would help reduce the risk of being caught by a predator. But there are downsides to being an anxious sparrow, not least because less time is spent feeding.
Another common consequence of lead poisoning is impaired mobility. When we analysed video recordings of sparrow escape flight, we found sparrows with high blood lead levels were slower to take off. Every second counts when being attacked by a sparrowhawk or cat.
In the gaze sensitivity experiment, sparrows were more scared of the picture of the man looking straight at them than the one looking away.Chik, H. et. al. (2025) Animal Behaviour, CC BY
Longevity: checking chromosomes for ageing
The length of the “telomeres” — caps that prevent chromosomes from damage — has proven to be a good marker of how long an individual will live.
When we measured telomere length in the sparrows across Broken Hill, we discovered sparrows with higher levels of lead in their blood had shorter telomeres. Generally, birds with shorter telomeres die at a younger age.
Previous studies of humans exposed to lead through industrial occupations also found telomere shortening.
Fluoride is a major byproduct of aluminium smelting. After fluoride is emitted into the air it falls back to Earth where it can contaminate land, water and plants. So animals may breathe it in, drink contaminated water or eat contaminated food. Fluoride then accumulates in the animal’s bones and teeth.
Earlier studies found high exposure to fluoride deposited around the Portland aluminium smelter caused bone lesions in nearby kangaroos and dental problems in koalas.
We found sparrows living up to 10km from these smelters had unnaturally high fluoride levels in their bones.
Excess fluoride uptake changes the balance of the essential bone minerals, calcium and phosphorus. These minerals play an important role in bone structure. Changes in their composition could compromise bone strength, with implications for activities such as flight.
Sparrows are living alongside people in urban environments all over the world.Hoyoun Lee, Unsplash, CC BY
Heed the lessons
Pollution affects virtually all aspects of life — from how organisms behave to how they age and grow. The health of the environment, animals and people are tightly intertwined.
We should heed the lessons of sentinels such as the sparrow, and reduce pollution at the source. This will benefit urban ecosystems and, in turn, the health and wellbeing of humans.
Simon Griffith receives funding from The Australian Research Council
Mark Patrick Taylor has received funding from The Australian Research Council. He has also previously received funding from New South Wales Environment Protection Authority (EPA) for research into environmental lead and human health implications at Broken Hill, NSW. He was also a former full-time employee of EPA Victoria, appointed to the statutory role of Chief Environmental Scientist.
Max M Gillings is involved in research affiliated with and funded by EPA Victoria.
About 5% of common Australian wild birds including kookaburras and lorikeets could have undergone a “sex reversal” where their genetic sex does not match their reproductive organs, according to a new study.
The study is thought to be the first to find widespread sex reversal across multiple wild bird species, but the cause of the phenomenon is not yet known.