Tesla’s self-driving mode is coming to Australia amid controversy – but it won’t create true driverless cars

Tesla’s self-driving mode is coming to Australia amid controversy – but it won’t create true driverless cars

NurPhoto/Getty

Tesla is expected to soon turn on its “Full Self-Driving (Supervised)” (FSD) mode in Australia and New Zealand.

Is a future of driverless cars upon us? Not exactly – it’s essentially more advanced driver assistance. Legally, Tesla drivers using this mode must be ready to take control and pay attention at all times. Calling it “full self-driving” is questionable.

The move comes amid scrutiny. This week, a video showed a Tesla navigating roads in Melbourne’s CBD without the driver’s hands on the wheel. Authorities warned these trials had not been approved.

It’s a reminder of how contested “self-driving” remains. While the technology is advancing rapidly, there are still real concerns over regulations, technological readiness, safety and public trust.

Is it legal?

Tesla’s FSD mode is not truly driverless. Technically, it’s classified as an advanced driver assistance system. On the recognised five-level list of increasingly automated cars, where 5 is fully automated, FSD is a Level 2.

At this level, the driver has to remain attentive and ready to take proper control. Legally, this means Tesla’s FSD would be treated the same way as other vehicles with advanced driver-assist systems. Tesla cars with FSD running would be compliant with Australian regulations and legal to use with human oversight.

At higher levels of automation (Levels 3-5), the car takes on the whole driving task without constant supervision, which would be considered “automated driving”. Level 3 cars exist in limited markets overseas. Level 4 cars are being used in fleet-based robotaxi trials but not sold to consumers. Level 5 cars offering true autonomy, anywhere, anytime don’t yet exist.

At present, cars with Level 3 automation and above are not compliant with Australian regulations and can’t operate without special permits for trials and testing. They have strict conditions on safety, insurance, data sharing and geographic restrictions.

This is why the Tesla video in Melbourne video triggered pushback – it gave the impression of a higher level of automation than legally permitted without a trial permit.

What can FSD actually do?

Tesla is taking a phased approach to enable FSD for eligible vehicles in Australia.

In this mode, the car can change lanes, navigate interchanges, recognise stop signs and automatically bring the car to a stop. It can even handle Melbourne’s famous hook turns.

But the system has hard limits. The driver must be ready to step in at any moment. The system can make errors in complex or unpredictable settings.

Overseas, Tesla is promoting a new supervised feature – autosteer on city streets – which would go beyond automated highway driving into more complex residential and city roads with roundabouts, traffic lights and pedestrians. But this feature remains “upcoming” in Australia.

Tesla’s approach to self-driving remains controversial. To sense their surroundings, the vehicles rely mainly on cameras and artificial intelligence. Critics argue this leaves the system more vulnerable to errors. Other self-driving car developers such as Waymo have added LiDAR and radar sensors to boost safety in case other sensors fail.

Tesla’s branding of FSD as a step towards full autonomy is misleading. In reality, it’s closer to a diligent learner driver than a professional chauffeur. It can read the road, but still needs close supervision.

The long road to autonomy

Tesla’s push into autonomy is partly about capturing market share in the fast-emerging robotaxi industry.

Tesla CEO Elon Musk has promised Tesla cars will one day be able to be monetised in a shared robotaxi fleet.

In June, the first Tesla Robotaxi went live in limited areas of Austin, Texas. But these vehicles are not truly driverless – a human safety monitor must be on board.

Globally, Tesla is one of many companies vying for a share of the robotaxi market. Trials are expanding quickly. Waymo is leading the race with paid driverless rides in several cities in the United States. Its Jaguar cars are Level 4 autonomous, able to drive unsupervised but only in a set area.

Meanwhile, Baidu, WeRide and Pony.ai are scaling up in China, their domestic market, as well as the Gulf region, including Dubai, Abu Dhabi and Riyadh.

a taxi driving with no driver, no one at steering wheel. photo from inside the car looking out.
In the race for the robotaxi market, Waymo is ahead. Pictured: a Waymo Jaguar I-PACE robotaxi in Los Angeles in 2024. Los Angeles Times/Getty

True self-driving cars are a way off

What if a self-driving consumer car causes a crash? For a Level 2 car, supervising human drivers remain responsible.

But if a true self-driving car caused a crash, liability could fall on the manufacturer or even the software developer. Regulators are working to resolve this legal grey area.

Even as Tesla pushes towards self-driving, the company faces a class action from thousands of Australian drivers over alleged “phantom braking” where the cars suddenly brake for no apparent reason, risking rear-end crashes.

Tesla says its system can be affected by obstructed cameras and drivers are always responsible for maintaining control.

This echoes a wider debate: how safe must autonomous systems be before they can replace human drivers? Human error is a major cause of road crashes. But glitches such as phantom braking undermine confidence and public trust, especially when lives are at stake.

In the US, federal authorities are investigating crashes linked to Tesla’s driver-assist systems. California’s regulator has accused Tesla of misleading advertising, and senators have pressed for tougher oversight of Tesla’s marketing.

Despite progress, fundamental breakthroughs are still required to handle rare but high-risk scenarios, such as pedestrians behaving unexpectedly.

Artist impression of a self-driving car from 1960s, man and woman sitting in a three wheeled car.
Self-driving cars have been imagined for decades, such as this 1961 artist’s impression of a futuristic three-wheeled self-driving car. Hulton Archive/Getty

The road ahead

Cars with advanced driver-assist can recognise objects and follow rules. But unexpected things can happen.

True autonomy demands the ability to interpret complex and ambiguous human behaviour.

Until then, the driver must remain firmly in charge.

The Conversation

Hussein Dia receives funding from the Australian Research Council, the iMOVE Australia Cooperative Research Centre, Transport for New South Wales, Queensland Department of Transport and Main Roads, Victorian Department of Transport and Planning, and Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications and the Arts.

Sydney Water failed to properly test before declaring ‘no known Pfas hotspots’ in catchments, inquiry finds

More attention needs to be given to rapidly evolving issue of contamination of waterways with ‘forever chemicals’, committee’s chair says

Sydney Water did not perform “an appropriate level of due diligence” before claiming there were no known Pfas hotspots within its drinking water catchments, a state parliamentary committee has found.

The New South Wales upper house committee tabled its 16 findings and 32 recommendations on Thursday following an inquiry triggered by reporting in the Sydney Morning Herald that detected elevated levels of some “forever chemicals” in parts of Sydney’s drinking water catchment.

Continue reading…

Cheap power to the people could shift the dial for renewables in the regions

Cheap power to the people could shift the dial for renewables in the regions

Martin Ollman/Getty Images

Australia’s energy story is at a turning point. Demand for electricity is rising rapidly as homes, industries, and transport systems electrify. The nation is also under pressure to cut emissions from its energy sector and elsewhere.

At the same time, some people don’t want renewable energy projects built in their area. So how do we meet all these challenges, and deliver energy that is cleaner, cheaper and more reliable than what we have today?

Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen has proposed one idea, urging renewable developers to provide cheap power to local communities in a bid to win support for projects such as wind and solar farms.

The idea has merit. Communities that host energy projects often don’t receive any meaningful benefit. Yet they bear the brunt of the projects, such as changes to the local landscape and social divisions. Cheap renewable electricity to local households could make the energy transition fairer – and faster.

Giving locals their share

Under the federal government’s target, Australia would reach 82% renewables in the energy mix by 2030.

But getting there means overcoming opposition in some areas to hosting renewables projects. The opposition includes fears over environmental impacts and loss of farmland, and perceptions that the community wasn’t adequately consulted.

Research shows providing communities with direct financial benefits can help win locals over. When people feel like partners rather than bystanders, opposition can decline and projects are more likely to succeed.

Cheap electricity is one of those financial benefits. Developers can offer households near renewable projects access to discounted power, generated locally, instead of paying the same retail rates as other areas.

The federal government has recognised the potential of this idea. As reported in The Australian, Chris Bowen said:

I’ve said to a lot of companies, ultimately, you’ve got to be thinking about energy discounts for people in the regions.

How ‘cheap power’ works

The principle is straightforward. Energy generated locally first serves nearby homes and businesses, which are charged a discounted rate. Any surplus power is exported to the wider grid, to customers paying general retail rates.

The discount ensures locals receive direct, tangible benefits for hosting the renewable energy project. It also reflects the fact that the electricity has not been transmitted over a long distance. Transmission costs can otherwise inflate energy bills.

Local-first energy systems also enhance resilience. During extreme events – such as bushfires, storms or blackouts – local generation and battery storage can maintain supply when the broader network is compromised. This can be a game-changer in regional Australia, where the grid is often weaker and outages can take a long time to fix.

Benefit-sharing also has wider implications. By keeping energy spending local, communities retain more money in their own economies. This creates opportunities for small businesses and local services to flourish.

Signs pointing to various towns amid an orange haze
During bushfires, local energy generation and battery storage can maintain supply when the broader network is compromised. Brett Hemmings/Getty Images

Looking abroad

A number of successful overseas models offer a way forward.

In the United Kingdom, some wind farm developers offer nearby households discounted energy bills.

Some villages in Germany, such as Feldheim, operate community-owned renewable projects that supply low-cost energy directly to residents, bypassing traditional retailers.

In Denmark, residents can co-own turbines and receive both cheaper energy and dividends. This strengthens local investment in the energy system.

The Danish model inspired Hepburn Wind in Victoria, Australia. This wind farm is co-owned by more than 2,000 members, most of them local.

And renewables developers in the United States frequently create community benefit funds, supporting schools, sports facilities and local infrastructure.

Getting renewables right

All Australians should care about keeping the energy transition on track. Our electricity demand is expected to skyrocket out to 2050. Meanwhile, ageing coal plants are retiring and increasingly unreliable – and gas prices are volatile, leading to higher costs for consumers.

And of course, tackling climate change by reducing emissions is in everyone’s interests.

Renewable energy solves multiple challenges at once. It provides affordable electricity and reduces emissions. When combined with energy storage, it provides reliable electricity supply.

Australia’s energy transition is also an opportunity to reshape regional economies and empower communities.

Done well, renewable energy projects can improve trust between locals and developers. They can also deliver affordable power, new revenue streams and stronger community resilience.

The Conversation

Mehdi Seyedmahmoudian does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.