Whiskers for warrens: why wombats have such whiskery snouts

Whiskers for warrens: why wombats have such whiskery snouts

Julian Stratenschulte/Getty

Wombat noses and whiskers don’t just make them adorable. Both are unique sensory organs essential for navigation, foraging and communication. They’re crucial to wombat survival in complex environments. The two different types of wombats are even named and classified according to their noses and whiskers.

Our recent research on wombat whiskers and noses reveals how these unique structures help wombats navigate underground and thrive in their habitats. Well-loved wombats are still full of surprises.

Understanding why wildlife species have specific anatomical features and how they use them helps scientists understand more about their place and importance in the environment. It ultimately helps us conserve these incredible species.

A wombat lies sleeping in the sand.
Wombats uses their whiskers and noses for sensing predators and finding their preferred food – grass. Ma Ping/Xinhua/Getty

The need for a nose

Wombats are found in every part of Australia, except the Northern Territory.

Like many other marsupials, female wombats have pouches. The joey lives in the pouch for several months, permanently attached to the teat and becomes independent between 18 months and two years of age. Wombats live for around 20 years but have been known to survive more than 30 in captivity, such as elderly Wain, who is about 36 years old and lives in a zoo in Japan.

A wombat’s snout, or nose, is one of its most important and recognisable features. Wombats are classified and named based on the presence or absence of a rhinarium, the hairless area around the nostrils. The two hairy-nosed wombat species lack a rhinarium, while bare-nosed wombats have one.

In other animal species, the rhinarium is important for sensing touch and temperature, and for chemical detection. Dog rhinaria are thought to be used for heat detection, while the wet rhinaria of cows are associated with many glands thought to support olfaction (detecting smells and scents).

A close up of a dog's nose.
The hairless area on a dog’s nose is thought to be used to detect heat. BSIP/Universal Images Group/Getty

Shaping our environment

Wombats are ecosystem engineers – animals that significantly shape their environment. Within their range, wombats have multiple burrows they can share. Their digging turns over the soil, providing aeration and drainage, and supporting plant growth. Their burrows also provide shelter for other species, such as possums and birds.

Mammals use whiskers – specialised hairs associated with sensory receptors – to help navigate. Whiskers are particularly important in nocturnal animals and those that dig and live in burrows, such as wombats. Receptors convert whiskers’ movement into signals sent to the brain, which allow the animal to obtain important information from their environment, such as where they are in the burrow.

Wombats also use whiskers, along with scent, to help find grass, their favourite food.

Whiskers to navigate

Hairy-nosed wombats have a broader snout compared to bare-nosed wombats, which may increase the available space for whiskers.

When we examined and compared the whiskers on southern hairy-nosed wombats with bare-nosed wombats we found southern hairy-nosed wombats had longer and thicker whiskers. There were also significantly more whiskers on the muzzle and above the eyes compared to bare-nosed wombats.

We think this might be because hairy-nosed wombats excavate larger and more complex warrens than bare-nosed wombats. They may also rely more on their whiskers to navigate or when interacting with other wombats in shared burrows.

A southern hairy-nosed wombat walks out of a den in a zoo.
An adult hairy-nosed wombat. James D. Morgan/Getty

A strong sense of smell

Like many other marsupials, wombats have a large olfactory bulb, a part of the brain associated with smelling. The size of an olfactory bulb corresponds to an animal’s ability to detect and process smells, providing further evidence of the importance of scent for wombats to help find food and detect predators.

Famously, wombats have cube-shaped poo. They often deposit their poo at burrow entrances and in unique areas such as on rocks, branches and tufts of grass. It’s likely they use their poo to mark their territory, just as rabbits do.

Like all marsupials investigated to date, wombats have a vomeronasal organ alongside their olfactory system. This is a separate smelling organ that detects pheromones, which are mostly used as chemical messages between wombats sharing a burrow. Importantly, pheromones support social interactions, including mother-young bonding and when wombats are ready to mate.

Just like cats and cattle, wombats exhibit a Flehmen response. This is when the animal curls back its upper lip, exposes its front teeth and inhales deeply. This behavioural response helps wombats process interesting smells by concentrating them in the nasal cavity.

The primary function of a nose is to act as an opening to allow air to flow in and out of the lungs. But noses also cool or warm, and moisten the air entering the body.

The nasal cavity is therefore moist and covered in mucous, and other secretions, which reduce bacteria and viruses from entering the lungs and causing infections and disease.

Close-up of male African lion showing the Flehmen response, which looks like a snarl.
Close-up of male African lion showing the Flehmen response, which is used to seek out smells. Arterra/Getty

Surviving on a whisker and a prayer

Australia’s beloved wombats have evolved many features that let them thrive and act as ecosystem engineers.

Our research shows how important their snouts and whiskers are in supporting their lives, from identifying burrow mates and predators to finding food and navigating complex burrow systems in the dark. Without this, wombats would not survive.

Wombats are under pressure on multiple fronts, including being killed on roads and suffering from sarcoptic mange, a parasitic skin infection.

The more we know about these creatures, the better equipped we are to help them thrive.

The Conversation

Julie is an Associate Editor at Australian Mammalogy, a member of the Australian Mammal Society, and a Director on the Board of The Wombat Foundation.

Protected areas in the Hauraki Gulf nearly triple under a new law – but it comes with a catch

Protected areas in the Hauraki Gulf nearly triple under a new law – but it comes with a catch

Getty Images

A new law that almost triples the protected area in the Hauraki Gulf T?kapa Moana – New Zealand’s largest marine park at more than 1.2 million hectares, surrounding Auckland and the Coromandel peninsula – is something to be celebrated.

But it comes with compromises, and it is especially disappointing that some forms of commercial fishing will continue in some areas.

This week, parliament passed the Hauraki Gulf/T?kapa Moana Marine Protection Bill into law. It increases areas under some form of protection from 6% to 18% by extending two existing marine reserves and adding 12 high protection areas and five seafloor protection areas.

These new areas add to the diversity of habitats under protection, including under-represented soft sediment ecosystems, and provide new opportunities for customary management. While fishing will be restricted in 18% of the gulf, there is a carve-out for commercial ring-net fishing in high protection areas.

This diminishes their status as protected areas and makes it more difficult for New Zealand to fulfil its promise under the Global Biodiversity Framework to protect 30% of the marine environment by 2030.

We should also recognise this is only a starting point in restoring the mauri (life force) of the gulf. Animals that live in the gulf’s water column remain vulnerable, and given the rate of environmental change in New Zealand’s waters, we need to fast-track the conservation process.

Levels of protection

The new legislation has three forms of protection.

Marine reserves are complete no-take zones. High protection areas (HPAs) allow for restoration activities and provide for customary practices of tangata whenua. Seafloor protection areas (SPAs) protect habitats on the seabed, but they allow for activities that don’t damage them, such as non-bottom fishing.

All three forms of protection share a common theme in restricting large-scale seafloor disturbances from bottom trawling and dredging, large-scale removal of non-living material such as sand, and dumping or discharge of waste.

The protection of the seafloor is critical to preserving the many benefits we gain from its ecosystems, including carbon storage, the processing of excess nutrients, provision of food for fish, and nursery habitats.

HPAs value M?ori management and support the restoration of nature and culture. This opens up opportunities to undertake active restoration to accelerate passive recovery. Such activities may include large-scale kina (sea urchin) removal and re-seeding of shellfish populations.

Many of the HPAs are alongside areas where significant restorative efforts are happening on land. This acknowledges land-sea connections and these areas will hopefully become successful examples of what integrated management can achieve.

Lessons from NZ’s oldest marine reserve

The Cape Rodney-Okakari Point (Goat Island) Marine Reserve at Leigh became New Zealand’s first legislated marine reserve 50 years ago.

This reserve, on the north-east coast of the Hauraki Gulf, will quadruple in size under the new law. It has taught us many lessons about how coastal reef ecosystems are affected by human activity and how marine reserves benefit people, including fishers.

For example, we know that marine reserves maintain populations of predators, such as large lobsters and snapper, which stop sea urchins from becoming too abundant and over-grazing coastal kelp forests.

A large snapper swimming above flat rocky seabed at Leigh Marine Reserve.
In the protected waters of the Goat Island marine reserve, snapper can grow big and populate other areas across the Hauraki Gulf. Getty Images

The ability to protect large snapper has also demonstrated that size matters in fish reproduction. The marine reserve contributes disproportionately to the snapper population across a large part of the gulf. If this is scaled with the new protection area, it should lead to a more productive fishery that will benefit all.

The expansion of the Cape Rodney-Okarkai Point Marine Reserve and the Te Whanganui-A-Hei Marine Reserve at Hahei will open up new opportunities for learning about connections between reef and soft-sediment habitats and how they influence biodiversity.

Fast-tracking marine conservation

Overfishing, pollution, climate change and invasive species mean marine ecosystems are changing rapidly. Management responses must do so as well.

Successive State of the Gulf Reports have documented the continued decline of its ecosystems. This new legislation builds on decades of efforts to protect the gulf. It follows the 2016 Sea Change/Tai Timu Tai Pari marine spatial plan and the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park Act 2000 which provided special recognition for the gulf but no additional protection.

During times of rapid environmental change, we need strong connections between science, policy and management. Otherwise, we’re at risk of missing the connections and processes responsible for ecological tipping points.

This new law must not be the end to marine protection and restoration of the Hauraki Gulf. Early European settlers reported an abundance
of fish, invertebrates, whales and dolphins and we are a long way from these historical baselines.

The new measures protect from some important forms of stress, namely overfishing and seafloor disturbance, but there are many others that continue to affect the gulf, including those that begin on land. Unless we work to substantially reduce the flow of sediment, nutrients and microplastics into the gulf, recovery will be slow.

We also need to remember what these new measures do not protect: the fish, marine mammals and seabirds that live or move through the water column or depend on it.

Our research and experience so far highlights the need to apply systems thinking to the management of marine environments. This means recognising and accounting for the dependencies between the ecological health and economic and social wealth of the Hauraki Gulf.

The Conversation

Conrad Pilditch receives funding from the Department of Conservation, MBIE, regional councils and PROs. He is affiliated with the Mussel Reef Restoration Trust, the Whangateau Catchment Collective and New Zealand Marine Sciences Society.

Simon Francis Thrush receives funding from MBIE and philanthropy. He is affiliated with the Royal Society New Zealand, NZ Marine Sciences Society and Whangateau Harbour Care.

Snowy 2.0 cost blowouts might be OK if the scheme stored power more cheaply than batteries. But it won’t

Snowy 2.0 cost blowouts might be OK if the scheme stored power more cheaply than batteries. But it won’t

Two years ago, Snowy Hydro announced a reset for its troubled Snowy 2.0 giant pumped hydro project amid cost blowouts. The supposed final cost was A$12 billion.

Last week, Snowy Hydro acknowledged this figure was no longer viable after a cost reassessment.

I estimate the final cost will be well over $20 billion, excluding new transmission lines – more than ten times higher than the original estimate of $2 billion.

As costs have climbed, Snowy 2.0 has lost supporters. The remaining defenders include former prime minister Malcolm Turnbull, who signed off on the project, the federal Energy Minister Chris Bowen and we know of one academic engineer but there may be more.

The question has always been whether this scheme is worthwhile. Despite repeated cost increases, its few defenders continue to argue that Snowy 2.0 offers much cheaper storage per kilowatt-hour than a battery would deliver. In this argument, the cost of Snowy 2.0 is set against the energy storage potential and then compared to the cost of installing chemical batteries to deliver the same storage.

This defence is simple but wrong.

Moving water

Storing energy such as in pumped hydro schemes and electro-chemical batteries is necessary to decarbonise electricity supply, as they make it possible for surplus renewable energy to be stored and used later.

Snowy 2.0 is a major new pumped hydro project that will become part of the existing Snowy Hydro scheme. It can be thought of as a “water battery”.

In the Snowy 2.0 scheme, water is pumped uphill from the Talbingo lower reservoir to the Tantangara upper reservoir when energy is cheap, and then runs back downhill through turbines to produce power when prices rise and more power is needed.

Talbingo in turn gets most of its water from Eucumbene Dam via the existing Tumut 1 and Tumut 2 generators.

So far, so good. But there are three practical complications:

  • Talbingo is the upper reservoir for the 1,800 megawatt Tumut 3 pumped-hydro station, which means it needs to be kept near full so Tumut 3 is available to produce at maximum capacity and efficiency

  • Talbingo is only two-thirds the capacity of Tantangara and hence can’t accommodate all its water as is the case for a typical pumped hydro system

  • the downstream pondage for Tumut 3 (Jounama) is just one-sixth the capacity of Talbingo. So, depending on the water level in Jounama, Snowy 2.0 and Tumut 3 power generation has to be limited so as not to unintentionally lose water.

The end result is that if water is to be kept within the Talbingo/Jounama system and not lost be being released down the Blowering dam, filling Tantagara and then releasing it is heavily constrained by other elements of the system.

That’s not all. If Tantangara was full and Snowy 2.0 generated flat out for seven days, virtually all the water emptied from Tantangara would be lost downstream of Jounama and would then need to be replenished.

Whenever Snowy 2.0 is generating flat out, the Tumut 3 generator would also need to be generating to make use of the flowing water. But this would flood the power market, driving prices down and hence reducing the income needed to recover Snowy 2.0’s investment.

As a result, Snowy Hydro has no incentive to operate Snowy 2.0 in this way, and will almost certainly withhold its full capacity from the market just as it does now with Tumut 3.

Pumping water uphill

Snowy 2.0 faces economic constraints as well.

It takes energy to pump water uphill from Talbingo to Tantangara. Pumping will only be done when electricity prices are cheap, which will usually be for a few hours each sunny day when price are low. And it will only make sense to fill Talbingo from Eucumbene Dam by releasing water through Tumut 1 and 2 into Talbingo when prices are high.

The result: cost-effectively filling Tantangara will take many months.

Now let’s look at the demand for Snowy 2.0’s service. Defenders claim its ability to discharge power for a week is an advantage. But since Australia’s National Electricity Market began in 1998, there’s never been a period when the extremely high prices needed to make Snowy 2.0 worthwhile have been sustained for more than a few hours continuously.

If the energy market ever sees sustained, multi-day periods of extremely high prices, the market response will be to quickly build gas or diesel generators and add more batteries. Both are inexpensive, representing a tiny fraction of Snowy 2.0’s cost per kilowatt of added capacity. Greenhouse gas impacts would be inconsequential, given the generators would be very rarely used.

As a result, the vast bulk of Snowy 2.0’s storage capacity will sit unused in Tantangara because it is so difficult to cost-effectively fill Tantangara and there’s unlikely ever to be the demand to fully discharge it.

Chemical batteries are outcompeting water batteries

Now compare Snowy 2.0’s operational and technical constraints with those of electro-chemical batteries. These batteries go from charging to discharging in a fraction of a second. They do not have any of the operational and economic complexities of situating a new pumped hydro generator in an extremely complex cascade hydro system.

As a result, a kWh of battery storage capacity is likely to be used much more frequently than a kWh of Snowy 2.0 capacity. Grid batteries typically discharge their full capacity at least once per day and often many times a day. Snowy 2.0 is unlikely to ever discharge its full capacity.

So, while batteries may cost more to install upfront, they will be used much more intensively and so their higher costs absorbed over much higher volumes, so that their average costs are lower. It’s the same economic logic seen in the choice between trains versus buses versus cars – trains are usually cheaper per passenger-kilometre when heavily used, but much more expensive if near empty.

This is why battery storage is booming in Australia and many other countries. Private investors are piling in, typically with little or no public subsidy.

In the eight years Snowy 2.0 has been under construction, the battery equivalent of Snowy 2.0’s power capacity is already operational in the National Electricity Market. This will double in a year, and then double again in another year based on capacity contracted under the Capacity Investment scheme.

Despite enormous political will and vast amounts of taxpayer funds, pumped hydro schemes are struggling in Australia – just as they are in other countries.

With massively complex geology and mind-bogglingly complex operational and economic constraints, Snowy 2.0 is by far the least attractive of Australia’s pumped hydro possibilities.

How could the Australian government and Snowy Hydro have got it so wrong?

The Conversation

Bruce Mountain does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.