A ‘lack of ambition’ over livestock emissions targets now threatens NZ’s reputation and trade

A ‘lack of ambition’ over livestock emissions targets now threatens NZ’s reputation and trade

New Zealand's Minister of Climate Change Simon Watts Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images

The government’s decision to shrink a legislated target for cutting agricultural methane emissions is the latest in a string of announcements signalling a lack of ambition to meet climate targets.

It represents a major step backwards and could threaten New Zealand’s trade relationships.

The methane reductions mandated under the Zero Carbon Act, passed in a cross-party agreement in 2019, called for cuts in the range of 24-47% below 2017 levels by 2050. This is in line with the findings of an Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change special report that focused on what the world needs to do to keep warming at 1.5°C.

The government’s revised target aims to reduce methane emissions from farm animals by 14-24% by 2050. This means the minimum of the current range will be the highest possible ambition in the new one.

The government has also scrapped an election pledge to tax agricultural emissions, and it has pushed back a legal obligation to respond to the independent Climate Change Commission’s advice on future emissions budgets by two years.

The commission’s recommendation is to strengthen the country’s climate targets, both for long-lived greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide) and the short-lived but more potent methane because:

Evidence shows that the world is not on track to limit warming to 1.5°C, climate impacts are more severe and happening sooner than expected, and other countries are already doing more and expecting more.

For biogenic methane, the commission calls for more ambitious cuts to reach at least 35–47% by 2050. However, the government says achieving the upper end of the current range (47%) is “unrealistic” and would create “economic uncertainty, risks exacerbating land use change, and could increase food production costs”.

Pressure from the agriculture sector

The government appointed a review panel to assess how much methane emissions would need to be reduced to achieve “no additional warming” on 2017 levels – the idea being that it is enough for methane’s contribution to warming to remain at current levels.

This approach was promoted by industry lobby groups such as Groundswell but rejected by the Climate Change Commission. And it does not represent the “highest possible ambition”, as laid out in the Paris Agreement, to which New Zealand is a signatory.

It also goes against the 1.5°C goal, entrenched in New Zealand’s legislation and recently upheld by a landmark ruling by the International Court of Justice, which found even countries that leave the Paris Agreement are not exempt from international legal requirements to act in a manner consistent with 1.5°C.

Our trading partners are unlikely to smile on this lack of ambition. The New Zealand-European Union Free Trade Agreement includes the obligation to “refrain from any action or omission that materially defeats the object and purpose of the Paris Agreement”. It also includes the provision that parties may take “appropriate measures” in the event of such acts or omissions.

On top of the weaker ambition on methane reductions, the government recently reopened the country to oil and gas prospecting, removed a subsidy for electric vehicles, and disestablished a fund meant to help decarbonise industry. All moves are counter to the free trade agreement with the EU.

Despite the changes to the 2050 methane target, the 2030 target to reduce agricultural methane emissions by 10% has not changed. However, this will be harder to achieve as no price will be put on agricultural emissions, and the revised 2050 target takes the pressure off farmers.

The revised methane target represents a challenge for other sectors. The Climate Change Commission’s analysis shows that for every percentage point decrease in the ambition of the methane target, up to 44 million tonnes of carbon emissions would need to be offset. This would be either through more offshore credits, more tree plantings, or emissions cuts in other sectors such as transport or energy.

Partnerships and technology

To back the new target, the government says it is investing to speed up the development and rollout of methane-cutting tools. These include innovations such as the EcoPond, which cuts emissions from effluent ponds by more than 90%.

However, emissions from effluent ponds represent only about 10% of New Zealand’s total agricultural emissions because only dairy farms use them. Other possible solutions – including advances in breeding genetics and methane inhibitors – show promise but are not guaranteed to be rolled out in the near future.

Meanwhile, the climate is changing rapidly. We must do all we can to slow warming and avoid impacts from extremes and crossed tipping points.

Yes, cutting carbon dioxide emissions remains a priority, and we must get to zero emissions as soon as possible. But methane emissions are the next most important, and cuts should translate quickly into reductions in atmospheric concentrations (because of the short lifetime of methane), providing a cooling effect in the short to medium term.

The government’s announcement came on the eve of a major international conference on climate change adaptation taking place in New Zealand. This meeting is providing clear evidence of the effects of climate change in New Zealand and across the Pacific and the world, today.

We can currently adapt to climate change pressures, in most places, most of the time. But every tenth of a degree of warming makes that adaptation harder, and at some point we will no longer be able to do so.

There is urgency around reducing emissions of all greenhouse gases, in every sector and every country. New Zealand’s weakened methane target raises the risk of unmanageable consequences from climate change.

The Conversation

James Renwick was a Climate Change Commissioner from 2019 to 2024 but no longer has any affiliations. He was a lead author with the IPCC from 2001 to 2021 but is not involved with the latest assessment report.

Australian bird of the year enters final countdown as top 10 finalists vie to win 2025 poll

Voting closes at 6am on Wednesday as Australian magpie fails to make list of final contenders

The final day of voting for the 2025 Australian bird of the year has arrived, with more than 250,000 votes received so far and an official top 10.

The poll will close at 6am sharp on Wednesday 15 October and the bird with the most votes will be crowned the Guardian/BirdLife Australia Australian bird of the year for 2025.

Tawny frogmouth

Baudin’s black cockatoo

Gang-gang cockatoo

Willie wagtail

Bush stone-curlew

Southern emu-wren

Laughing kookaburra

Little penguin

Spotted pardalote

Wedge-tailed eagle

Continue reading…

It took just 60 years for the red fox, one of Australia’s most devastating predators, to colonise the continent | Sean Tomlinson and Damien Fordham for the Conversation

The rapid spread of the invasive species offers clues to how we might prevent future extinctions of native animals

To a newly arrived red fox, the abundant rolling grasslands and swamps of Wadawurrung Country, around what is now called Port Phillip Bay in Victoria, must have seemed like a predator’s paradise.

This landscape was filled with small native marsupials and birds, and free of European wolves or bears that usually kept fox numbers in check.

Continue reading…

It took just 60 years for red foxes to colonise Australia from Victoria to the Pilbara

It took just 60 years for red foxes to colonise Australia from Victoria to the Pilbara

Auscape/Getty

To a newly-arrived red fox, the abundant rolling grasslands and swamps of Wadawurrung Country, around what is now called Port Phillip Bay, must have seemed like a predator’s paradise.

This landscape was filled with small native marsupials and birds, and free of European wolves or bears that usually kept fox numbers in check.

The first red foxes, (Vulpes vulpes), to arrive in Australia were deliberately released by European colonialists in 1870 in three Victorian locations – Werribee, Corio (near Geelong) and Ballarat. They were introduced for the “noble” sport of fox hunting.

Small native animals became easy prey for foxes because they did not evolve with these predators and did not know to avoid them.

Red fox numbers ballooned and they spread rapidly. How fast? Our new research shows it took just 60 years for one of Australia’s most devastating invasive predators to colonise the continent. These days, foxes can be found everywhere except the tropical north and Tasmania.

Their rapid spread offers clues to how we might prevent future extinctions of native animals from foxes, and map the infiltration of Australia by other invasive species.

Mapping the spread

To model the arrival and spread of foxes across Australia, we relied on hundreds of historical “first-sighting” records collected from library, local government and state archives.

First sightings of foxes were particularly newsworthy at the end of the 19th and beginning of the 20th century in Australia. This is because of the threats that
foxes posed to sheep and poultry.

We ran thousands of model simulations reconstructing the arrival and spread of foxes across Australia. We played out likely scenarios of fox survival, reproduction and dispersal based on what we know about their behaviour today.

We then compared these simulated patterns of population growth and expansion against inferences of demographic change from these historical records. Our best models were able to closely reconstruct the timing of arrival of foxes in places and regions as well as their current day population sizes.

Our modelling demonstrated foxes populated Australia at incredible speed. Between 1870 and 1895, they had spread across the southeastern corner of Australia. Then they spread more slowly to the north and west directions in arid regions. By 1940, however, they had reached the remote northwest.

A map of Australia with a coloured section at the bottom that shows the spread of foxes over time.
This map shows how the red fox only took 60 years to spread across the whole Australian continent. Supplied, CC BY-NC-ND

Flourishing foxes

Foxes mate in winter, with females giving birth to four to five cubs. By autumn, the young foxes are on their own. They can travel up to 300 kilometres in search of new territory.

As omnivores, they eat everything from small mammals such as rodents and rabbits to birds, insects and plants. In their native range from Europe to the Middle East foxes have been suppressed by predators like bears and wolves, but in Australia, fox numbers have soared.

Unfortunately, the suppression of dingoes across Australia following European colonisation is at least partly to blame for the explosion in fox numbers because there are not sufficient densities of dingoes control foxes.

Foxes flourish in areas modified by humans. We show that their populations are densest around urban centres, and they do well after land is cleared for agriculture. Population growth rates of foxes in agricultural regions increased notably in the 1950s, as a result of large-scale agricultural expansion
following World War II.

This research also showed that in arid areas, population cycles of foxes follow a “boom and bust” cycle, while their numbers seem more stable in agricultural landscapes.

A small native bilby, a grey and white marsupial, sits on a patch of red sand.
Small marsupials like the native bilby would have been prey for foxes as their population spread over the country. Jenny Evans/Getty

Driving extinction

European red foxes and domestic cats brought to Australia kill about 300 million native animals in Australia every year and remain the major driver of past and current extinctions.

Australia’s fox population is about 1.7 million, and the Invasive Species Council estimates as many as 16 mammal species have become extinct mainly or partly because of foxes. This is about 40% of total extinctions since European arrival.

Our new research provides important insights into which native species have been threatened for the longest period of time, identifying areas that were potentially important refuges from foxes.

The adaptable simulation models we used to track fox expansion can be used for other invasive species that haven’t yet infiltrated all of Australia, such as cane toads. We hope these models will help us map the spread of other invasive species such as cats, and potentially curb Australia’s decline in native wildlife.

The Conversation

Sean Tomlinson receives funding from the Australian Research Council.

Damien Fordham receives funding from the Australian Research Council.

Reform of NZ’s protected lands is overdue – but the public should decide about economic activities

Reform of NZ’s protected lands is overdue – but the public should decide about economic activities

Getty Images

The government’s proposed reforms of the rules governing public conservation land aim to dismantle any potential obstacle to “unleashing economic growth” in protected areas.

Currently, about a third of New Zealand’s land is under protection. This ranges from national parks (11.6%) to stewardship areas (9.4%) and conservation parks (5.7%). Twelve other designations make up the rest.

Some commercial activities are permitted – including guided walks, aircraft-based sightseeing, ski fields and animal grazing – and approved by the Department of Conservation as “concessions”.

The proposed changes to the Conservation Act include a review of land designation. The government could delist or swap up to 60% of the current area under protection.

Conservation Minister Tama Potaka said he can’t indicate which designations or locations would be delisted. Nor can he say what percentage of conservation lands would be affected – and where – because changes will be driven by demand for land.

The minister only committed to leaving untouched the designations that are difficult to change: national parks, wilderness areas, reserves and world heritage sites.

The question of whether more economic benefits can be obtained from protected areas is legitimate. New Zealand does need a radical reform of its conservation areas and legislation. There is potential for better social and economic outcomes.

But the proposal consolidates ministerial discretion to unprecedented levels and the government follows a misguided fast-track approach to permitting economic activities such as mining. This could take native biodiversity into dangerous territory.

Outdated conservation laws

New Zealand holds tight to an outdated approach known as “fortress conservation”. This limits commercial opportunities to specific areas, mostly concentrated around established facilities (roads, hotels) and the edges of designated lands. Even when regulating other activities such as energy generation or agriculture, the idea has been to “sacrifice” some spaces and keep as much land as possible “locked up”.

A key reason was that people didn’t know enough about the ecological values of the land. As a proxy, lawmakers relied on the subjective concepts of wilderness values and intrinsic values to justify strict protections over most lands.

Insufficient scientific input meant authorities have relied on “ecologically blind” zoning frameworks, such as a planning tool known as the recreation opportunity spectrum. This divides lands according to recreational opportunities and visitor needs.

But there is a better path forward – one that allows public decision making and honours international commitments, while achieving better ecological and economic benefits.

Towards regulations informed by science

This alternative approach is grounded in three key principles.

First, it uses gap analysis to identify which ecosystems and species are underprotected.

Second, it relies on regulations shaped by ecological knowledge and conservation priorities.

Third, it applies the principles of proportionality and precaution, meaning that regulatory responses should match the severity, reversibility and likelihood of environmental harm. Currently, New Zealand’s regulatory framework does not reflect this.

New Zealand has signed the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. This means at least 30% of conservation lands must be representative of most, if not all, native ecosystems by 2030.

At present, coastal, lowland and dryland ecosystems are under-represented. In contrast, alpine and montane environments, are represented way above the recommended threshold (20% of the remaining cover for that ecosystem).

If up to 60% of conservation lands were to be swapped or delisted without prioritising representativeness, vulnerability and rarity, the ecological losses may be immense and irreversible.

Rethinking protection categories

My research develops a broader reform approach. It also reflects growing international consensus on the need for science-informed conservation planning.

I argue New Zealand should set up region-specific and nationwide fora, such as citizen assemblies or consensus conferences. Conversations should focus on specific topics, informed by scientists and iwi.

Vulnerable or under-represented ecosystems currently require stronger protection. Deliberations should indicate which activities should be limited or excluded to better protect such areas.

We must also consider vulnerability to climate change. Scientists expect that ecosystems may migrate outside protected areas.

Consensus should be built around what qualifies as a “significantly over-represented” native ecosystem. Where ecosystems are already well protected and resilient, the public should discuss whether re-designation, land exchanges or even disposals may be appropriate.

If lands are retained, consensus should be sought on the economic uses that can maintain ecological health. If the public doesn’t support land delisting or swaps, alternative strategies must be developed to improve ecological representativeness. Sustainable funding mechanisms should also be identified to support these efforts.

The Department of Conservation should work with independent scientists and iwi to develop a new zoning framework to guide commercial concessions and recreational access. This framework should capture the principles highlighted above.

When applied to each area, it should also enable the mapping of the ecological values feasible to protect. This would help select bespoke regulatory options. In turn, it would balance biodiversity and economic outcomes for each context.

Guidance for these steps should be incorporated in a new national strategy, aligned with domestic goals such as the biodiversity strategy and international commitments.

New Zealand has the expertise for smart reforms. New Zealanders have the passion for nature and patience required to engage in deliberations. But will politicians have the wisdom to avoid a totally unnecessary mutilation of conservation lands, for undefined biodiversity gains?

The Conversation

Valentina Dinica does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.