Death and devastation: why a rare equatorial cyclone and other storms have hit southern Asia so hard

Death and devastation: why a rare equatorial cyclone and other storms have hit southern Asia so hard

Rezan Soleh/AFP via Getty Images

More than 900 people are dead, thousands more missing and millions affected by a band of cyclones and extreme monsoonal weather across southern Asia. Torrential rain has triggered the worst flooding in decades, accompanied by landslides. Indonesia, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Vietnam and Malaysia have been hit hardest. The death toll is likely to rise significantly.

Normally, cyclones don’t form close to the equator. But Cyclone Senyar formed just north of the equator in the Malacca Strait. It triggered lethal flooding in Sumatra and peninsular Malaysia last week.

It wasn’t alone. Other tropical cyclones formed along a zone of converging trade winds north of the equator. Typhoon Koto caused severe flash floods and landslides in the Philippines before weakening as it neared Vietnam. Tropical Cyclone Ditwah devastated Sri Lanka. One reason Sumatra was hit by such severe flooding was due to the unusual interaction between Typhoon Koto and Cyclone Senyar, which has now weakened.

The near-simultaneous emergence of these intense storms isn’t unheard of, and equatorial cyclones are rare but known. But the devastation is extraordinary. Sri Lankan President Anura Kumara Dissanayake described the floods as the “most challenging natural disaster” in the country’s history. Is there a climate link? We don’t know yet, but we do know climate change is projected to trigger fewer cyclones overall, but with higher intensity.

Why are cyclones rare near the equator?

Cyclones, typhoons and hurricanes are different names for the same strong, spinning tropical storms. These storms form over large expanses of warm water – but not usually on the equatorial seas.

This is because there’s not enough Coriolis force from Earth’s rotation at the equator to spin storms into their classic cyclonic structure.

The closest cyclone to the equator was the 2001 Tropical Storm Vamei which formed at just 1.4°N. Cyclone Senyar formed at 3.8°N.

While tropical cyclones can form in any month, they’re more common between July and October in the northwest Pacific and North Indian oceans. Cyclone Senyar and Typhoon Koto formed in the Northwest Pacific Basin, which has the largest, most frequent and most intense tropical cyclones in the world. Several devastating typhoons have hit the Philippines and parts of southern China this year.

One reason these cyclones have caused widespread damage is because they have hit countries where cyclones are rare, such as Indonesia and Malaysia.

Tropical cyclones are often smaller and much less common in the North Indian Ocean, including the Bay of Bengal and Arabian Sea. But Cyclone Ditwar tracked directly down Sri Lanka’s east coast, magnifying the damage.

Is there a climate link?

As the world’s oceans and atmosphere warm at an accelerating rate due to the rise in greenhouse gases from burning fossil fuels, tropical cyclones are expected to become more intense.

This is because cyclones get their energy from warm oceans. The warmer the ocean, the more fuel for the storm.

The warming atmosphere is supercharging the global water cycle, and peak rainfall rates are increasing. When more rain falls in a short time, flash flooding becomes more likely.

We can’t immediately say climate change made these storms worse, as it takes time to pinpoint any link.

What does this mean for Australia’s cyclone season?

Many Australians will wonder whether these devastating cyclones across Asia are a warning for northern Australia’s monsoon season.

The wet season has started with a bang in northern Australia, after Severe Tropical Cyclone Fina caused damage and disruption across the Top End and Kimberley last week. It was very early for a cyclone in the south Pacific and Indian oceans, as the season runs November to May.

Last week also saw the most damaging spring storms in more than a decade in southeast Queensland and northern New South Wales. Giant hail and destructive winds did major damage, costing one insurer an estimated A$350 million.

This doesn’t mean a bad cyclone season is guaranteed. It’s not possible to predict individual tropical cyclone events far in advance.

All indicators point to a mixed wet season across the north this year, with below-average rainfall across much of the northwest and average to above-average rainfall across the northeast.

Australia’s Bureau of Meteorology has just declared a La Niña in the Pacific. La Niña typically bring cooler, wetter weather to northern Australia and a stronger monsoon and higher risk of cyclones. This La Niña is likely to be relatively weak and short-lived, which is why rainfall predictions are largely average.

Across most of the Coral Sea, sea surface temperatures are up to 2°C above normal. This unusual warmth increases the risk of cyclone formation as well as more intense monsoonal rains and flooding in coming months.

In the south, there’s increased risk of heatwaves and bushfires, with a very hot summer forecast across most of Australia.

The Bureau of Meteorology recently ended seasonal cyclone forecasts as it’s no longer possible to do so reliably. Until now, meteorologists have used historic data to reasonably accurately model the total number of cyclones in a season. But the climate is now changing so fast it’s no longer possible to do this. As rescue attempts continue in many countries in the region, it’s clear we are now entering uncharted territory.

The Conversation

Steve Turton has previously received funding from the Australian and Queensland governments.

Are UN climate summits a waste of time? No, but they are in dire need of reform

Are UN climate summits a waste of time? No, but they are in dire need of reform

The United Nations’ global climate summit has finished for another year. Some progress was made in Brazil on climate finance and adaptation. But efforts to end reliance on fossil fuels were stymied by – you guessed it – fossil fuel powers.

It left many observers with a question: is this really the best we can do? Nearly every country (except the United States) joined the COP30 summit in the Brazilian city of Belém. The meeting showed the best and the worst of multilateralism – when countries try to address global problems beyond the capacity of an individual nation.

On one hand, COP30 managed to draw world leaders to the heart of the Amazonian rainforest to highlight the global issue of deforestation. And it maintained political momentum on climate action despite an unprecedented year of geopolitical turbulence, wars, finance cuts and UN job losses.

But the protracted climate negotiations failed to acknowledge the main drivers of climate change in the final text, including fossil fuels. And the UN’s decision-making process broke down on the final day of the summit. Many countries objected to the opaque and undemocratic way Brazil pushed through the final decision text.

A decade on from the Paris Agreement, there’s a growing sense climate summits are disconnected from real-world climate action. This begs the question: are the UN climate negotiations still fit for purpose? Or do they need to be reformed?

Consensus is too slow

Unlike most UN meetings, climate negotiations don’t use a majority voting rule, where the proposal with the most votes wins. Instead, decisions are always adopted by consensus. Every nation has to agree. This is a historical quirk that has been in place since COP1, where members of the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) successfully argued that all UNFCCC decisions should be taken only by consensus.

Focusing on consensus has arguably led to slower, more incremental progress on global climate action. There’s a long history of climate summit decisions being abandoned, watered down or delayed because of a handful of objections.

This means climate summits reflect the lowest common denominator. Decisions must be acceptable to every single country, including countries deeply dependent on revenue from fossil fuel exports.

The reliance on consensus led to political drama at the COP30 closing plenary. Some African and Latin American countries, and the European Union, raised objections after Brazil rattled through the adoption of watered-down COP decisions without allowing other countries to intervene.

The introduction of a majority voting rule in the UN climate negotiations – a common practice across the UN – could effectively unblock this situation and drive meaningful political change on climate.

Refocus on implementation

Over the past ten years, government representatives have negotiated the Paris Agreement rulebook. COP30 finalised the only remaining work on global carbon markets and how to measure global progress on adaptation.

With the rules now fully established, climate summits have shifted into the implementation phase. At COP30, this manifested as a flurry of new climate initiatives and coalitions, such as the launch of a new fund to end deforestation, commitments to tax luxury travel, and efforts by a group of countries to speed up the phase-out of fossil fuels.

These are a sign governments are moving away from negotiating global consensus statements and instead progressing climate action in smaller “coalitions of the willing”. Future climate summits might need to redesign their format so they are less focused on negotiating international rules and more geared towards implementation. This would provide a chance for improved collaboration, accountability and the tracking of progress.

Clamping down on vested interests

A third area ripe for reform is the presence of vested interests. Fossil fuel industry lobbyists freely participate at COPs and have a long history of undermining ambition. By one account, COP30 saw the participation of 1,600 fossil fuel lobbyists. Previous Australian governments have promoted fossil fuel companies such as Santos at climate summits.

Media reports have revealed how the COP28 and COP29 presidencies of the United Arab Emirates and Azerbaijan leveraged their roles to facilitate oil and gas deals, while COP30 relied on a PR firm that also works for oil and gas company Shell.

A step towards reform was taken in September when the UN climate secretariat announced new voluntary disclosure requirements for people attending the climate talks. Additional reforms could include mandatory disclosure requirements, clear rules for managing conflicts of interest and a code of conduct with transparency criteria.

The best we have

Many proposals have been put forward for improving how COPs work, from streamlining the bloated negotiation agendas to providing clearer expectations on the role of COP presidencies. These proposals recognise the many flaws of the global climate summits and point to the need for a major overhaul.

But this does not mean we should get rid of COPs altogether. They remain a crucial tool for driving political decision-making and international collaboration on the largest global challenge of our time. For example, new figures released by the UNFCCC at the start of COP30 showed that the global emissions curve is beginning to bend downwards for the first time, while a scenario without the Paris Agreement in place saw emissions continue to rise by 20–48% in the next ten years.

The global transformation of energy systems and economies is a deeply political process and requires an ongoing political platform. Importantly, COPs are also the only political space where the smallest island countries carry the same weight as the most powerful economies.

Despite being messy and complicated affairs, COPs will remain necessary for years to come.

The Conversation

Arthur Wyns has received funding from the University of Melbourne, the World Health Organization, and the World Bank.

NZ now has a narrow window to stop the Asian yellow-legged hornet – here’s how everyone can help

NZ now has a narrow window to stop the Asian yellow-legged hornet – here’s how everyone can help

Jonathan Raa/Getty Images

The first Asian yellow-legged hornets observed in Auckland in winter were two old and slow males. Many people were concerned and worried. Now, at the end of spring, what we’ve seen is a potential nightmare.

Over recent weeks, the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) response team has discovered around two dozen spring queens and small nests across the suburb of Glenfield.

Unless New Zealand rapidly scales up its search effort, we could soon be confronting an incursion far tougher and costlier to stamp out. Or worse, we could end up with this pest as a permanent resident.

Overseas, nest densities can exceed 12 per square kilometre. These nests can produce as many as 500 new queens in autumn.

If our current incursion stemmed from a single nest that produced hundreds of queens, the two dozen queens and small nests detected this spring may be only a small fraction of what is actually out there.

An incursion of such a scale would spell particular trouble for our honey bees, which can make up as much as 70% of this hornet’s diet. In parts of Europe where the species has established itself, they have wiped out 30% to 80% of hives.

People are at risk, too. Those who approach nests too closely risk severe stings known to cause intense pain, rapid swelling and, in some cases, life-threatening allergic reactions. People have died after being stung by these hornets.

In dollar terms, the cost to countries – in control and lost productivity – can be in the tens of millions. Is New Zealand doing enough while it still can?

We need more boots on the ground

New queens are still being found in Auckland, and the capture rate is increasing. That could be due to better monitoring, bigger nests or more eyes on the ground.

Whatever the reason, the increasing captures are a major concern. The more we search, the more hornets we find. That trend must reverse.

The ideal scenario is for teams to spend days – and weeks – searching without finding anything new. Only then could we be confident hornet populations are being effectively controlled. Clearly, we are not there yet.

MPI teams are spending long hours searching on the ground and have increased staff numbers. They are doing an excellent job and deserve real credit. But it is clear more searchers are needed.

This would allow coverage of a much wider area, and there is debate about how far the search zone should extend.

An Asian hornet (right) hunting honeybees as they emerge from the hive. Jean-Bernard Nadeau/Science Photo Library, CC BY-NC-ND

MPI has focused on detection areas of 200 metres around each nest, supported by traps out to five kilometres, in line with international experience and guidance. But other evidence and opinion from Europe suggest this may not be enough.

Year-to-year observations show new nests can appear kilometres from previous sites, while worst-case early invasion spread rates have been estimated at around 30 kilometres a year, accelerating to 75 to 112 kilometres each year once populations become established.

If these European patterns apply even partially to New Zealand, the search radius must expand dramatically, requiring many more people in the field and a careful watch from the public in the wider region around Auckland.

Eradication is the goal

The only successful eradication of the yellow-legged hornet occurred on Majorca, off the coast of Spain. The programme ran for six years across an area of about 35 by 25 kilometres.

Success depended on a mix of citizen reports, active nest searching by volunteers and government staff, and mechanical nest removal. After three years of finding and destroying nests, Majorca recorded three consecutive years with no detections.

This shows eradication is achievable over a substantial area.

New Zealand also has an advantage with toxic bait such as Vespex, which is locally designed for invasive wasp control and has been shown to be safe for use near beehives.

We’ve seen Vespex knock down wasps by more than 97% in thousands of hectares of New Zealand forest. While its effectiveness against this hornet is not yet fully known, it has potential to be a powerful tool.

For it to work, foraging worker hornets must collect the bait. January and February are likely to be the best months in which to deploy it – when nests are large enough to produce active foragers but before they begin generating new queens and males.

Later in summer, we’ll need to be prepared to find and control any remaining nests. Those can be high and hidden in tree tops, requiring equipment to lift people high into the canopy, and long poles to spray pesticides into nests.

With a ramped-up search effort and using all available tools, including Vespex, the Majorca experience suggests eradication here is realistic.

The priority now is to maximise the search effort, map the true boundary of the infestation and destroy nests before they produce new queens and males.


Everyone can play their part by staying alert and reporting online any suspected sightings, or by phoning 0800 809 966. Beekeepers can find MPI’s surveillance guide and an easy-to-build trap design on its website.


The Conversation

Phil Lester serves on the Technical Advisory Group for the Ministry for Primary Industries' hornet response.

EPA urged to ban spraying of antibiotics on US food crops amid resistance fears

Use of 8m pounds of antibiotics and antifungals a year leads to superbugs and damages human health, lawsuit claims

A new legal petition filed by a dozen public health and farm worker groups demands the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) stop allowing farms to spray antibiotics on food crops in the US because they are probably causing superbugs to flourish and sickening farm workers.

The agricultural industry sprays about 8m pounds of antibiotic and antifungal pesticides on US food crops annually, many of which are banned in other countries.

Continue reading…