Fertilising arable land with human waste leaves array of toxins that could re-enter food chain, study finds
More than 520 chemicals have been found in English soils, including pharmaceutical products and toxins that were banned decades ago, because of the practice of spreading human waste to fertilise arable land.
Research by scientists at the University of Leeds, published as a preprint in the Journal of Hazardous Materials, found a worrying array of chemicals in English soils. Close to half (46.4%) of the pharmaceutical substances detected had not been reported in previous global monitoring campaigns.
The rumble of thunderstorms across the country this week is a noisy reminder that summer is arriving – and with it, the mix of heat, humidity and unstable air that fuels these bursts of wild weather.
Strolling to the Meteorological Society of New Zealand’s annual conference in Hamilton this morning, I could sense this atmospheric shift about me.
These early storms sit in a transition zone, where strong daytime heating combines with lingering spring volatility. Put the ingredients together and thunderstorms can form readily.
The influence of La Niña, now present in the tropical Pacific, can also provide northern parts of the country with background conditions that make for heightened mugginess, heavy downpours and thunderstorm activity.
This ocean heat is likely to last through summer, with the potential to boost evaporation and humidity, and add energy to the lower atmosphere. When weather systems arrive from the north, that extra moisture can drive heavier rain and more vigorous convection.
These conditions may point to a greater risk of significant rain events later in summer, especially for the North Island, with a normal or slightly elevated chance of ex-tropical cyclone interactions.
In short: expect more heat, more humidity and occasional bursts of very heavy rain.
So how do thunderstorms like this week’s fit into the mix – and what does a warming climate mean for them?
How thunderstorms build their power
Thunderstorms form when warm, moist air rises into cooler layers above.
As the air ascends, water vapour condenses into cloud droplets, releasing heat that adds buoyancy and lifts the air further. This fuels a strong up-and-down circulation inside the storm.
Within this turbulent environment, electrical charges separate. Collisions between droplets, ice particles and graupel (soft hail) build positive charges near the top of the cloud and negative charges near the base.
When the atmosphere can no longer insulate that imbalance, lightning discharges. The air around the lightning channel is heated to tens of thousands of degrees – hotter than the surface of the Sun – and the rapid expansion generates the shock wave we hear as thunder.
As impressive as this latest event has been – Metservice has counted more than 3,600 lightning strikes since midnight, of which nearly 730 reached the ground – New Zealand’s thunderstorms are usually small by global standards, often measuring just a kilometre across.
Most are single convective cells, though they can occasionally line up into squall lines that bring intense local rain, strong winds and small tornadoes. Lightning deaths are extremely rare here.
Climate change means more active weather
According to the World Meteorological Organisation, 2025 is likely to finish up as the world’s second or third warmest on record, with record greenhouse gas concentrations continuing to drive severe heatwaves, melt glaciers and warm oceans.
A warmer climate also means more energy and moisture in the atmosphere, making it easier for thunderstorms and heavy rain to develop when conditions allow.
Air holds about 7% more water vapour for every degree of warming, and when that moisture condenses, it releases heat that strengthens the storm’s updrafts. That draws in even more warm, moist air from below, allowing rainfall totals to exceed the 7% rule of thumb, especially in short, intense bursts.
NIWA (now part of Earth Sciences New Zealand) has estimated that every degree of warming leads to a median 13.5% increase in hourly rainfall in a one-in-50-year event.
Atmospheric rivers – long, narrow plumes of tropical moisture – are also expected to become more frequent and intense in a warmer climate and already drive many of our heaviest downpours.
This signal translates directly into losses: nearly a third of the damage from New Zealand’s 12 most costly flood events between 2007 and 2017 – about NZ$140 million – was directly attributed to climate change.
Yet, how a warming planet is likely to affect the frequency of thunderstorms themselves is still uncertain. International studies suggest increases in some regions, but the processes are complex and not yet well understood for New Zealand.
The broader picture, however, is straightforward: warmer seas and a warmer atmosphere mean more moisture, more energy in the system, and possibly more instability in the atmosphere. When thunderstorms do form, they have more to work with.
Weather systems like this week’s will come and go, but the wider, long-term trend is something we all need to be concerned about.
We are tipping the odds toward more intense downpours – and the challenge now is acting quickly enough to spare future generations a much warmer, wetter world.
James Renwick receives climate research funding from the NZ MInistry for Business, Innovation & Employment.
You might know Australia’s dietary guidelines from the famous infographics showing the types and quantities of foods we should eat to have a healthy diet.
Last updated 12 years ago, the National Health and Medical Research Council is now revising them to consider not only how food affects our health but also how sustainable our foods are. At least 37 other countries have already added sustainability to their dietary guidelines.
Many countries use global load indicators to assess the environmental impact of specific foods, based on the planetary boundaries within which humanity can safely operate. While useful to compare between countries, these indicators don’t match Australia’s environmental risks and priorities.
Unlike many other countries, locally produced food represents around 90% of what Australians eat. The environmental footprint of these foods is shaped almost entirely by the country’s unique landscapes, climates and farming systems.
Our recent research suggests forthcoming guidelines need to take local conditions into account. If global load indicators are the sole way to measure impact, the guidelines won’t capture Australia’s specific environmental challenges in producing food.
Local indicators matter
Global load indicators include greenhouse gas emissions, how much land is used per kilo of food, water use, land and water pollution and biodiversity loss.
This is how we get common figures such as the statistic that it takes 1,670 litres of water to produce 1 kilogram of rice.
While global measures are useful in comparing between countries and products, they don’t always match local environmental risks and priorities.
For example, using 1,670L of water to produce a kilo of rice in the contested and controlled Murray Darling Basin will have a different impact compared to using the same volume in Western Australia’s Kununurra irrigation system, where water is more abundant and has fewer alternative uses. Growing a kilo of rice in Italy will differ again.
If we want dietary guidelines to encourage real improvements on farm and in rural landscapes, environmental indicators must reflect the challenges rural stakeholders actually face.
Consumer preferences have already shifted several food production systems. Rising demand for free-range eggs and grass-fed beef has changed how farmers operate. It’s important to get this right.
One size does not fit all
Australia’s agricultural lands are diverse.
By area, more than 80% of our farmland falls in the rangelands. Here, cattle and sheep graze with minimal human intervention on vast tropical savannas, woodlands, shrublands and grasslands. Low rainfall and poor soils mean livestock are kept at low densities. Other food production options haven’t proved viable.
If we used global load indicators, food from rangelands would be assessed as having a high environmental impact due to large land use, lots of potentially polluting nutrients (dung and urine) and use of rainfall to grow forage vegetation.
But the main environmental issues for Australia’s rangelands are different, including methane emissions from livestock, land degradation, invasive weeds such as buffel grass and biodiversity loss.
Australian food production systems are diverse. Rangelands and natural pasture account for the largest area, followed by mixed crop-livestock zones (in light blue and yellow).Author provided, CC BY-NC-ND
Australia’s next largest area of agriculture is mixed crop and livestock, found in regions such as the Mallee in Victoria and Western Australia’s Wheatbelt. Most crops and 40% of livestock are produced in these areas, characterised by reliable rainfall patterns and low to medium rainfall of around 250–450 millimetres a year.
Farming here can make soils more acid due to high levels of nitrogen from fertilisers, alongside issues such as dryland salinity, erosion, biodiversity loss and greenhouse gas emissions. These issues have degraded some land so much it can’t sustain farming.
For these two types of agriculture, local indicators work better.
By contrast, the intensive and productive irrigated farms of the Murray–Darling Basin have environmental impacts more aligned to global indicators. Environmental issues here include greenhouse gases, competition for land and water use, nutrient pollution (primarily fertilisers) and biodiversity loss.
Good for your health – and the environment?
While previous Australian studies have assessed the environmental footprint of different foods or focused on a narrow description of environmental impact derived from overseas studies, these haven’t accounted for local environmental priorities or trade-offs.
Trade-offs are common. For instance, plant-based diets may result in lower greenhouse gas emissions but can increase pressure on soil health and biodiversity, as crops are commonly grown as monocultures with high fertiliser and pesticide use.
Common Australian diets mixing plant and animal foods can have a lower impact on biodiversity and soil health but higher greenhouse gas emissions, as mixed diets entail a more diverse range of cultivated plants and animals but rely more on methane-producing livestock.
Recognising and balancing these trade-offs will be essential if Australia’s updated dietary guidelines are to support healthy people and a healthy environment.
What’s next?
Ideally, Australia’s updated dietary guidelines will capture the unique pressures and challenges of producing food locally. This won’t be easy, given impacts will vary across different foods, regions and production systems. But the tools are already available.
Farm software can track every aspect of the production in a local environmental context, making it possible to predict impacts on the natural capital of individual farms – if agreements to share and aggregate data can be negotiated.
Gathering these data will allow local environmental indicators to be embedded in dietary guidelines. If this is done, it will become possible to link recommended diets to sustainability reporting. Farms, retailers and banks are increasingly required to report sustainability metrics, which can be linked to foods.
That means Australians could see the environmental credentials of their food on the labels, based not on global averages – but on how the specific farm is doing.
David Masters has previously received research funding from research and development corporations including Meat and Livestock Australia. He is a member of the National Health and Medical Research Council's Sustainability Working Group. The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors alone and do not represent the views of NHMRC or the working group.
David Lemon receives funding from the National Farmers' Federation.
Dianne Mayberry has received funding from research and development corporations including Meat and Livestock Australia and the Grains Research and Development Corporation.
Sonja Dominik works for CSIRO Agriculture and Food. She has previously received funding from the National Farmers' Federation and research and development corporations.
If someone mentions criminal gangs, you might think of drug trafficking or financial crime. But one of the most persistent illegal trades in the world flies largely under the radar: wildlife smuggling.
The illegal wildlife trade drains plants and animals from their ecosystems and fuels organised crime. Australia is now considered a global hotspot for reptile smuggling. Enforcement agencies scramble to answer the most basic question — has an animal been taken from the wild? In courtrooms, that question often determines whether a prosecution succeeds or falls apart.
Our latest research suggests there might be a way to determine where an animal came from with scientific confidence. By examining the chemical traces inside a turtle’s claw, we can tell whether the animal grew up in the wild or in captivity. The claw is a small piece of tissue, but it carries an environmental signature that’s surprisingly difficult to fake. And this is potentially transformative for smuggling law enforcement.
Four endangered turtle species from Asia — their claws could reveal the true origins of traded animals.Author supplied, CC BY-ND
It allows us to measure the ratios of different isotopes (atoms with the same number of protons but different numbers of neutrons) in bones or teeth. Using scientific knowledge about how these isotopes occur in nature, we can trace them to their source. Animals absorb those chemical markers through what they eat and drink.
Keratin — the material that forms hair, nails, feathers and claws — preserves this chemical history especially well. Because it grows slowly, it records the conditions an animal has lived in over many months. For turtles, claws are an ideal window into their past. This technique could be used in other animals too.
Wild turtles forage widely, eating insects, plants and crustaceans. They move through landscapes like wetlands and billabongs, which have their own chemical imprint. In comparison, captive turtles are generally fed a narrow diet of pellets or farmed fish, and drink treated water. Those differences show up in the isotopes of carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen and other elements in their claw keratin.
so for other animals could we use their claws too?
When the chemical signatures are plotted on a graph, captive (blue) and wild turtles fall into clearly separated groups — a pattern strong enough to classify an animal’s origin from a single claw trimming.Author supplied, CC BY-ND
Admissible in court?
Any forensic method has to be reliable. Courts expect a sound scientific method, reproducible results, and a clear chain of custody — proof that the sample tested is the same one taken from the seized turtle.
Stable isotope analysis already meets the first two requirements. It’s a mature field grounded in decades of peer-reviewed research. The equipment used — isotope-ratio mass spectrometers — is standard in many research and forensic labs. Our testing methods have been documented in detail so the test can be reproduced anywhere the right equipment exists.
The legal side is equally important. A claw trimming is easy for wildlife officers to collect, label and preserve without harming the animal. In a courtroom, isotope results could sit alongside DNA evidence, seizure records and expert testimony, providing a clearer picture of where an animal actually came from.
Australians tend to think of wildlife trafficking as something that happens elsewhere — African ivory, South-East Asian pangolins, South American parrots. But Australia is now considered a global hotspot for reptile smuggling.
Official data show the number of live animals seized by the Australian government has tripled since 2017. And researchers emphasise that seizure records capture only a small fraction of the real trade. Global analyses suggest seizures may represent less than 10% of all illegal wildlife trafficking, meaning most animals smuggled from Australia are never detected at the border.
Australian reptiles – including freshwater turtles – are highly sought in the international pet trade. A recent analysis found 170 Australian reptile and amphibian species for sale overseas, particularly in Asian markets. Australian authorities note native reptiles are highly prized in the Hong Kong illicit pet trade, and attract far higher prices than locally.
A large adult pig-nose turtle in poor conditions in a Hong Kong pet store.Ricky Spencer, CC BY-ND
Prosecutions are rare
Hong Kong is a major destination and transit hub for smuggled wildlife. One case involved 658 pig-nosed turtle hatchlings (a species native to northern Australia and New Guinea) worth about HK$500,000 (A$100,000) seized from a traveller’s luggage.
Despite this, prosecutions in Australia are rare. Globally, smugglers often insist their animals were legally bred — a claim that is almost impossible to challenge without scientific evidence. This is precisely the gap isotope forensics can fill. A claw sample that reveals a wild origin undermines the “captive-bred” defence and gives prosecutors a stronger case.
This matters for another reason. Australia invests heavily in turtle conservation, such as nest protection, wetland restoration and community science networks like 1 Million Turtles. When breeding adults are poached from rehabilitated habitats, these efforts are undermined. A tool that can trace animals back to the wild strengthens enforcement and conservation.
Where to next?
Australia’s laws are strong, and permits are required for any movement of native reptiles. The problem is proving origin once animals leave the country. A stable-isotope database would let authorities overseas show that animals sold as “captive-bred” were actually removed from Australian environments. Funding could come from the federal environment portfolio, ideally in partnership with forensic laboratories and academic institutions that already have the equipment.
What has been missing is the link between field ecology and courtroom evidence. A turtle’s claw, it turns out, may provide this. In a trade that has depended on secrecy and false paperwork, a chemical signature that cannot easily be altered may give authorities a fighting chance.
Wildlife crime is notoriously difficult to prove. For species that take decades to reach maturity, losing even a few adults to illegal trade can erase years of conservation gains. But a technique that reveals an animal’s true provenance has the potential to reshape enforcement in Australia and beyond.
The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.