Can a bird be an illegal immigrant? How the White Australia era influenced attitudes to the bulbul

Can a bird be an illegal immigrant? How the White Australia era influenced attitudes to the bulbul

The Conversation, CC BY-NC-SA

In early January, authorities from South Australia’s Department of Primary Industries took to the streets of Adelaide on the hunt for a suspicious individual.

This individual had been spotted several times in the preceding weeks: they had red cheeks, brown wings and a black crest. It was a red-whiskered bulbul — a non-native bird, often seen around Sydney and Wollongong but not normally present in SA. Most Australians have likely never heard of a red-whiskered bulbul, much less seen one. But these birds have been living here since the First World War.

A spokesperson for the state explained why one little bird was causing such a fuss:

the red-whiskered bulbul is a high-risk pest bird that can damage SA’s vineyards and orchards by eating soft fruit, flower buds and insects, potentially reducing yields or causing crop failure

Is this bulbul really a harbinger of catastrophe for SA’s fruitgrowers? As a historian who researches introduced species in Australia, I suspect there is more at stake here than a few grapes and cherries.

Australia is a country forged through suspicion and fear of outsiders – a theme still prevalent in politics today. The bulbul first arrived here in the heyday of the White Australia Policy, and at the time, its Asian origin influenced the way Australians reacted to it. Could this history still influence attitudes towards it today?

A red-cheeked bird with a black crest and white breast sits on a tree branch.
The red-whiskered bulbul’s natural range includes much of India, southern China and Southeast Asia. But humans have brought it to places as far apart as Mauritius, Hawaii and Australia. Nafis Ameen/Creative Commons, CC BY-SA

First bulbuls were likely escapees

The red-whiskered bulbul’s “natural range” — where it lived before humans transported it elsewhere — includes much of India, southern China and Southeast Asia. But humans have brought it to places as far apart as Mauritius, Hawaii and Florida, as well as Australia.

Many of the birds Australians see every day have been introduced since the beginning of colonisation. This is true of domesticated birds such as chickens and pigeons, brought here on the First Fleet in 1788. In the 19th century, “acclimatisers” — naturalists who made it their mission to move species of animal and plant across the globe — successfully introduced several species of wild bird, such as blackbirds and common (or “Indian”) mynas.

Bulbul populations appeared almost simultaneously in both Sydney and Melbourne in the late 1910s. The bulbul was a popular pet at the time, and it’s probable these populations arose from aviary escapees. (This seems to be how the bird became established in the wild in other regions such as Florida.)

At first, the bird prompted not much more than curiosity. Some warned its penchant for fruit would lead it to becoming a pest; others praised it for eating troublesome insects such as aphids.

A.H. Chisholm, ‘Ways of the Wild’, Daily Telegraph (Sydney), 16 December, 1922, 13, https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/245786530. CC BY-ND

Bulbul scrutinised in era of xenophobia

The bulbul arrived during the zenith of the White Australia Policy, and its Asian origin meant it received extra scrutiny. As early as 1922, commentators wrote about the bird under headlines like “Another Asiatic Menace”, “Asiatic Settler” and “Immigrant Bird”. A 1926 headline in the Melbourne Herald was even more explicit: “Mr. Bulbul: Asiatic Bird That Has Beaten the Migration Laws”. Farmers and gardeners wrote to newspapers to complain of bulbuls eating their fruit, calling the birds “undesirables” and “foreigners in feathers”.

Some people thought these responses were prejudiced, and said so. One correspondent of Sydney’s Evening News called on readers to give “the bul-bul a fair go”. There was no denying that the bird was charming and had a beautiful song, even if it did eat fruit and flowers. Some commentators argued the bulbul had become “naturalised” – that it had earned a right to belong in Australia, regardless of origin.

There is something hopeful in all this. Even at a time of intense and wide-ranging racism and xenophobia, an Asian bird could still “become Australian”.

But these voices were always a minority. As the species was never protected by law, orchardists and gardeners encouraged each other to shoot and trap bulbuls whenever possible. By 1935, an employee of the Sydney Botanic Gardens was shooting up to six bulbuls a day.

Much ado about nothing?

Today, bulbuls still thrive around Greater Sydney, their range stretching north to Newcastle and south to Nowra. But Melburnians rarely see them, according to publicly accessible data on the Birdata and Ebird platforms. Perhaps they have been muscled out by growing numbers of aggressive and adaptable native birds such as noisy miners and pied currawongs.

Like the recent visitor to Adelaide, bulbuls have been spotted occasionally in SA since the 1940s, but decades can pass without a single bulbul being seen in the state. Whether or not bulbuls someday form a viable population in SA remains to be seen. But if they did, would it really be so bad?

We know that some non-native birds, like starlings, cause immense problems for farmers and do compete with native birds for nesting sites. However, there is very little peer-reviewed research on the red-whiskered bulbul in Australia. In 2014, ecologist Matthew Mo wrote there was no evidence that competition between bulbuls and native birds is “ecologically significant”. Even the evidence for its impact on fruit crops and role in spreading weeds remains scant. At best, we have a deficiency of research. At worst, we’re getting worked up about a relatively harmless bird, just because it’s not native.

White Australians of the interwar period let their xenophobic attitudes towards Asian humans distort their view of an Asian bird. I’m not arguing those worried about the bulbul today are doing so because they are personally racist. But today’s anxieties about the bulbul do seem acute, given the lack of any hard evidence. After all, native birds can do enormous damage to fruit crops, too.

In many cases, we’re right to be concerned about the ecological and agricultural impacts of non-native wildlife — I’m not here to defend rabbits, brumbies or feral cats. But that doesn’t mean every introduced species is a catastrophe waiting to happen. The story of the bulbul in Australia should give us pause. During more than a century on this continent it has been, at worst, a minor nuisance. When the intensity of our emotions does not match the evidence, we need to ask ourselves why.

The Conversation

Simon Farley does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

UK to cut climate finance to poor countries by a fifth despite promising more help

Exclusive: Campaigners say proposed cut from £11.9bn over past five years to £9bn over next five years will cost lives and livelihoods

The UK plans to slash its aid to poor countries stricken by the climate crisis by more than a fifth, the Guardian has learned, despite promises to increase assistance and warnings from campaigners that the move will cost lives and livelihoods.

Ministers plan to cut climate finance for the developing world from £11.6bn over the past five years to £9bn in the next five. In real terms, accounting for inflation, this would represent a cut of about 40% in spending power since 2021, when the £11.6bn budget was agreed.

Continue reading…

Flawed economic models mean climate crisis could crash global economy, experts warn

States and financial bodies using modelling that ignores shocks from extreme weather and climate tipping points

Flawed economic models mean the accelerating impact of the climate crisis could lead to a global financial crash, experts warn.

Recovery would be far harder than after the 2008 financial crash, they said, as “we can’t bail out the Earth like we did the banks”.

Continue reading…

One family’s ocean paddle almost ended in tragedy. It reminds us coastal weather is notoriously changeable

One family’s ocean paddle almost ended in tragedy. It reminds us coastal weather is notoriously changeable

Fernando Garcia/Unsplash

The extraordinary rescue this week in Geographe Bay, Western Australia has been described as heroic. A 13-year-old boy swam four hours to shore in rough seas after his family was swept far from the beach. This boy’s bravery in raising the alarm is to be commended.

For the public, it’s useful to consider how the family found itself in this predicament. The boy’s mother told the ABC the weather conditions had rapidly changed. This is similar to other recent marine rescues.

According to the boy’s mother, conditions were calm when she and her three children set out on inflatable paddle boards and a kayak. But in a short time, strong winds and waves pushed them steadily out to sea, leaving them clinging to a board about 14 kilometres from shore.

How does weather change so quickly at sea – and why does it catch even careful people by surprise?


Read more: The ocean can look deceptively calm – until it isn’t. Here’s what ‘hazardous surf’ really means


Why ‘good’ weather can change rapidly

Coastal weather is notoriously dynamic. Unlike conditions on land, which are shaped by friction from terrain, the atmosphere over the ocean can change rapidly as wind systems move unobstructed across large distances.

In southern WA, afternoon sea breezes are a key factor, such as the Fremantle Doctor. On warm days, air rises over land and draws cooler air in from the ocean. These sea breezes can strengthen rapidly in the late afternoon or early evening, sometimes increasing by around 10 knots or more over a few hours.

In Geographe Bay, about 220 kilometres south of Perth, a strengthening afternoon south-westerly sea breeze could plausibly drive a light inflatable craft away from shore. Owing to the orientation of the Quindalup–Dunsborough coastline, prevailing summer sea breezes strike the coast obliquely, creating cross-shore drift that can steadily increase the distance from land once paddlers lose their ability to make headway.

Sudden wind shifts can also occur when cold fronts approach. Even if a front is hours away, pressure changes ahead of it can cause winds to freshen unexpectedly, particularly later in the day.

Two paddleboards on calm water.
Paddleboarding has become extremely popular as ocean craft become more affordable. Oxk/Unsplash, CC BY-ND

Winds, waves and currents

Wind alone is dangerous enough, but when combined with waves and currents it can dramatically reduce a person’s ability to return to shore, even with a craft.

Strong winds striking the coast obliquely create surface drift, pushing lightweight vessels – such as inflatable paddleboards and kayaks – steadily offshore. At the same time, wind-driven waves increase drag, making paddling or swimming far more exhausting.

Ocean currents compound the problem. Even modest currents of 1–2 knots can exceed a swimmer’s sustainable speed over long distances. Against waves and wind, fatigue sets in quickly, increasing the risk of panic, hypothermia and drowning.

Research consistently shows people overestimate their ability to swim or paddle against environmental forces. Once offshore drift begins, the distance to shore can increase much faster than people realise.

Inflatables – a boon and a potential bane

Inflatable craft, such as stand-up paddle boards, are increasingly popular as they’re often cheap, portable and easy to use.

But they’re also particularly vulnerable to wind, even light breezes.

Because inflatables sit high on the water and have little mass, they act like sails. Even moderate winds can overpower a paddler’s strength, especially when conditions deteriorate. Marine safety agencies repeatedly warn inflatables should only be used close to shore, in light winds, and with constant attention to changing conditions.

In coastal Australia, large-scale wind changes often unfold over hours, but conditions on the water can feel dramatically worse within minutes once waves build and fatigue sets in. The weather can shift from benign to hazardous within minutes, particularly in the afternoon and early evening.

This is why marine forecasts often emphasise timing, not just wind strength.

A forecast of “10–15 knots increasing to 20 knots in the afternoon” may sound manageable. But for paddlers and swimmers, that increase can mark the difference between control and crisis.

Clouds developing, rising wind, whitecap waves forming further offshore and a sudden drop in temperature are all warning signs that conditions are changing, and a cold front is approaching.

What to do if caught out

First, stay calm. Staying with the craft, such as the inflatable paddle board, is imperative. It provides flotation and – crucially for rescue – visibility. If you have a life jacket, you should keep it on.

If you don’t have a flotation device, you should float on your back. Remember, Float to Survive. Floating on your back, keeping limbs relaxed, and pacing your effort can extend survival time significantly.

If you must swim, swimming diagonally across waves or with the waves, rather than directly against them, may help reduce exhaustion. Crucially, raise the alarm as soon as possible. Early notification gives rescue crews a far greater chance of success.

How to avoid this situation

Prevention remains the most effective safety strategy.

Before heading out, check marine forecasts – not just general weather apps – and pay close attention to wind strength, direction and timing. Avoid inflatables when winds are forecast to increase later in the day.

Always wear a life jacket, even in calm conditions, and carry a waterproof communication device if possible.

Stay close to shore, set clear limits on how far you’ll go, and be prepared to turn back early. Always let other people know you’re heading out to sea, even if you plan on staying very close to shore.

The Geographe Bay rescue had a remarkable outcome, thanks to the extraordinary courage and determination of the young boy. But it also highlights a sobering reality: the ocean doesn’t need to be stormy to become dangerous. Sometimes, it just needs the weather to change – and it often does, faster than we expect.

The Conversation

Samuel Cornell does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.