New Zealand’s earlier efforts to safeguard marine or coastal environments, particularly as marine reserves and marine protected areas, typically focused on shallow ecosystems, largely because that is where most data exists.
But following the passing of the Hauraki Gulf Marine Protection Act last year, it was good to see many deep rocky reefs among the 12 new high protection areas (HPAs).
These areas prohibit recreational and commercial fishing while allowing certain customary practices in ways that reduce or eliminate extractive activities, helping ecosystems recover and rebuild.
This is important because deeper reefs often host protected species and this recognises the need to protect these habitats.
As our new research shows, even just 50 metres of depth can separate entirely different marine communities.
In this study at the Poor Knights Islands Marine Reserve off northeastern Aotearoa New Zealand, we examined sponge assemblages – a major component of temperate rocky reefs – from 5 to 65 metres in depth.
Sponges play an important role in filtering water, recycling nutrients and creating habitat for other organisms. They are also sensitive to environmental change, including marine heatwaves.
Reefs do not simply continue unchanged with greater depth. In fact, deeper communities in the “mesophotic” zone, typically found at 30–150 metres of depth, can host very distinct species that never occur in the shallows.
If conservation efforts don’t recognise this, we may be leaving a significant portion of marine biodiversity unprotected.
Different communities at depth
Our results were striking. Sponge assemblages were strongly structured by depth.
Most species were depth specialists, found either in shallow reefs less than 30 metres deep or in deeper mesophotic zones, but not both.
Across all sites we surveyed, we identified 64 sponge species or operational taxonomic units. Only 18 occurred across multiple depths spanning both shallow and mesophotic zones. In other words, less than a third of species had distributions broad enough to potentially link the two zones.
Differences between depths were driven mainly by species replacement, not by shallow communities simply becoming poorer versions of deeper ones. This means mesophotic reefs are not just extensions of shallow reefs. They are ecologically distinct systems.
Shallow depths tend to support sponge assemblages dominated by encrusting and low-lying species such as those shown in the images from A to D, while upper mesophotic depths are dominated by species with mounding, tubular and golf ball forms (E to G). Meanwhile, middle mesophotic depths host assemblages made up of many branching sponges (H-J).James Bell, CC BY-NC-ND
Are deep reefs climate refuges?
For years, scientists have debated whether deeper reefs might serve as refuges during disturbances such as marine heatwaves, which can disproportionately affect shallower ecosystems.
The idea, known as the deep reef refugia hypothesis, suggests deeper populations could survive warming events and later reseed damaged shallow reefs.
There is some evidence this can occur for certain species. In our study, a small subset of depth generalist sponges occurred consistently across both zones. These species may have the potential to benefit if deeper habitats avoid disturbances that impact shallower waters.
But our findings suggest this refuge effect may apply only to a minority of species. Most sponges had narrow depth ranges. If shallow populations decline, deeper reefs will not automatically act as a backup for entire assemblages.
This challenges the common assumption that deeper reefs can safeguard shallow biodiversity at an ecosystem level.
Why this matters
Marine protected areas in shallow, accessible habitats are easier to survey, monitor and manage. But biodiversity does not stop at 30 metres.
If deeper reefs host distinct communities, then protecting only the shallows leaves much of that biodiversity exposed to fishing pressure and other anthropogenic impacts.
Our assessment of the current network of 44 marine reserves in New Zealand shows the majority contain areas of rocky reef, but only half have reefs below 50 metres.
Importantly, these include New Zealand’s larger offshore reserves (the Kermadec Islands, Auckland Islands, Bounty Islands, Campbell Island and Antipodes Island), which means the total protected area deeper than 50 metres comes to an impressive 16,294 square kilometres (about the size of the Auckland region).
However, these offshore marine reserves extend far deeper than the mesophotic zone and only a fraction of this area is rocky reef. When discounting the larger offshore reserves, the total area covered by marine reserves deeper than 50 metres is only 394 square kilometres, less than 1% of New Zealand’s territorial seas.
Distribution of all New Zealand marine reserves. Yellow stars indicate marine reserves containing seabed at depths of 50 metres or greater (mesophotic zone), and orange circles indicate reserves shallower than 50 metres.Bathymetric data from GEBCO global gridded bathymetry dataset; marine reserve boundary data from Land Information New Zealand, CC BY-NC-ND
This has direct implications for marine spatial planning in Aotearoa New Zealand and globally.
Our research suggests ensuring the protection of both deep and shallow areas in the same geographical regions is essential if we want to safeguard the full spectrum of reef biodiversity. Protecting shallow reefs alone will not automatically protect deeper mesophotic species or vice versa.
Mesophotic reefs are often out of sight and out of mind. They lie beyond most recreational diving depths and are less studied than their shallow counterparts. Yet they can host rich sponge assemblages and other invertebrate communities that contribute significantly to ecosystem functioning.
They are also not immune to change. Ocean warming, shifting currents and sedimentation can all influence deeper habitats. While depth may buffer some disturbances, it does not guarantee protection.
Our findings add to a growing body of evidence that temperate mesophotic ecosystems should be managed as distinct ecological entities. They are not simply deeper versions of shallow reefs, nor are they universal refuges.
As climate change intensifies and marine heatwaves become more frequent, conservation planning must consider how biodiversity is structured across depth. This means designing protected areas that encompass entire reef profiles, from the surface to the limits of light penetration.
James J Bell receives funding from the Department of Conservation, the Greater Wellington Regional Council, Centerport, The George Mason Charitable Trust and The Royal Society of New Zealand Marsden Fund. He is also supported by a Royal Society of New Zealand Mana T??rangi Distinguished Researcher Fellowship.
Manon Broadribb does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Where are you at most risk when a flood or bushfire strikes? You might think it’s at home. But in reality, the most dangerous time is when you leave and jump in your car. Many flood and bushfire deaths are linked to vehicles, often driven by people evacuating late.
One of the clearest examples comes from the 2009 Black Saturday bushfires in Victoria, in which 173 people lost their lives; 35 of those deaths occurred during evacuation, with many on the road.
What is going through people’s minds as they try to escape? We don’t have to guess – many self-recorded evacuation videos are publicly posted on social media. We analysed hundreds of these videos from around the globe to get a better understanding of how people end up in these dangerous situations.
We found many people either evacuated late after realising the situation was more dangerous than they first thought, or drove back to defend their property. They thought they were doing the right thing in trying to flee to safety – only to find the roads were far more dangerous than they expected.
A father and son drive into an increasingly dangerous fire situation and start praying for help.
How risky are roads during bushfires?
When disasters escalate rapidly, the decision to leave can become one of the most crucial moments people face.
Between 2010 and 2020, bushfire deaths in Australia often occurred on the road rather than at the fire front. An analysis found 33 of 65 bushfire deaths during this period were vehicle-related, many during late evacuations.
More recently, an ABC program documented survivor accounts from Black Saturday, including firefighters, people who defended their properties and those who took to the road in the final minutes.
One firefighter’s account, in particular, captures how quickly conditions can change on the road. At first, nothing about the drive appeared unusual.
when I drove up over the top of the hill down into Kinglake, there was nothing untoward. It was just a normal hot day […] a bit of smoke around.
But within minutes, the road environment changed completely.
so I do a U-turn, and there was a wall of smoke. I’m thinking, where did that come from? All of a sudden, […] You can’t see. It was pitch black. As we’re driving, the sides of the roads were igniting.
The risk of conditions changing is not confined to a single event or location. It is a recurring and ongoing feature of bushfire emergencies in Australia.
A father sings to his daughter to comfort her as they drive through a bushfire.
How dangerous are roads during floods?
Floods present a different kind of threat, but the risks on the road can be just as severe.
In Australia, nearly half of all flood fatalities are associated with vehicles, most commonly when people attempt to drive through flooded roads, crossings, or causeways.
This is not unique to Australia. A study of flood fatalities in Texas, covering the period from 1959 to 2009, shows around 80% of flood deaths with known circumstances were vehicle-related.
These deaths often occur when drivers underestimate water depth or flow speed, assume the road ahead is still passable, or follow other vehicles into floodwater. This can quickly lead to vehicles stalling, being swept away, or trapping occupants in fast-moving water.
A school bus is swept away by floodwater in Texas, US.
What people experience inside a vehicle
To gain a first-person view of what actually unfolds on the road in these situations, we analysed hundreds of self-recorded evacuation videos.
On bushfire-affected roads, conversations inside vehicles revealed uncertainty as conditions changed quickly. Many drivers showed fear and stress – some prayed, while others tried to stay calm for their families.
Videos show people caught in intense heat and heavy smoke, struggling with poor visibility and concern over falling trees or bursting tyres. Some said they were struggling to breathe while others decided to stop or turn around.
Conditions appeared hazardous even for firefighters. Conversations between drivers and passengers often reflected the complexity of the environment and a lack of certainty about what to do.
Some drivers could not make it through and were forced to escape.
Importantly, these flood and fire videos only represented those who managed to escape and survive.
A video of people driving through fires in California, where the drivers are distressed and can hear tyres popping.
The best way to stay safe
In our analysis of these flood and fire videos, we found a recurring theme – surprise. People found themselves in a very different situation to the one they imagined when they began driving.
Driving on roads affected by floods and fires is risky, and the situation can escalate very quickly. Flash flooding is aptly named: torrential rain can trigger floods in just minutes. Bushfires, too, can intensify quickly
The clearest advice remains to avoid these situations altogether by evacuating early. But if you do find yourself in a vehicle on a fire-affected road, existing Country Fire Authority guidance can make a critical difference to survival.
Stop when it’s no longer safe to continue, park well off the road and away from vegetation if possible. Stay inside the car with windows and doors closed, turn off vents and air conditioning, get below window level and protect yourself from radiant heat using woollen blankets or clothing.
In floods, if rising water traps your vehicle, get out early and move to higher ground. As a last resort, climb onto the roof.
Ultimately, the safest option is to avoid hazardous driving wherever possible. Because once you’re on the road, it may already be too late.
The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Tasmania’s health department and environment watchdog questioned the scientific rigour behind an application to use the antibiotic florfenicol in salmon farms, including a lack of evidence about its impact on humans, documents show.
Panama joins smaller nations in dropping support for policy aimed at cutting maritime emissions
US “bullying” over a proposed carbon levy on shipping appears to be paying off, experts have said, after Panama reversed its support for the measure.
In a leaked document seen by the Guardian, the key maritime state has co-sponsored a proposal to the International Maritime Organization that would in effect cancel the carbon levy and undermine attempts to cut greenhouse gas emissions.
Falling volcanic ash has for years been viewed as a nuisance. But a Sicilian project has discovered its agricultural potential and wants to spread the word
In the Sicilian town of Giarre overlooking Mount Etna, Andrea Passanisi, a tropical and citrus fruits producer, uses an unusual fertiliser on his 100-hectare (247-acre) stretch of land: volcano ash.
Like hundreds of farmers and citizens of rural towns perched on the slopes of Europe’s highest and most active volcano, the 41-year-old’s family has had to deal with the nuisance of falling volcanic ash for generations. But it is only in recent years that the quantity of ash has become so excessive that it required an alternative approach.