To help save NZ’s native species, we must move past the extinction blame game

To help save NZ’s native species, we must move past the extinction blame game

Werner Forman/Getty Images

Each time another study about human-driven species extinction hits the news in Aotearoa New Zealand, a familiar pattern unfolds in online comment sections.

As researchers in this field, we have seen how quickly new findings about biodiversity loss are overshadowed by a debate over who is responsible.

We have repeatedly encountered blunt statements such as “why should M?ori have a say?” linked to arguments that M?ori caused species declines.

Given the long dominance of European colonial perspectives in natural history and archaeology, it is perhaps unsurprising that such claims provoke strong responses.

Some M?ori counter with statements such as “we didn’t cause moa extinction, we were the first conservationists”.

We have seen arguments that treasured species such as kuri (Polynesian dogs) would not have been allowed to go feral, and that the extinction of the Waitaha penguin was due to competition for nesting sites with hoiho yellow-eyed penguin, despite evidence to the contrary.

Such responses reflect frustration with research – and at times media coverage – framed in ways that appear to assign blame without sufficient context.

One news article on the translocation of takah? onto Ng?i Tahu land, for example, linked the species’ “decline” to land confiscations, despite evidence of a more complex history.

This isn’t a phenomenon unique to New Zealand. The causes of ecosystem modificationn on Rapanui (Easter Island) and megafauna extinction in Australia have been hotly debated. In Australia, responsibility has been variously attributed to human activity, climate change, or some combination of the two.

Ultimately, this blame game does little to advance understanding.

In Aotearoa, moving beyond it is essential if m?tauranga (M?ori knowledge systems) is to inform evidence-based kaitiakitanga (guardianship and stewardship) and the conservation of taonga (treasured) species.

Placing extinction in context

Throughout history, human expansion has often been followed by waves of extinction.

This is especially apparent in the Pacific, where island species – often slow-breeding and long-lived – have been especially vulnerable. Hunting for food, habitat clearance and the introduction of predators such as rats and dogs tipped ecosystems out of balance.

Eventually, a new balance was reached with humans as part of the ecosystem and the development of or modification of existing tikanga (customs).

Polynesians brought to Aotearoa kiore (Pacific rat), kuri and a suite of plants such as taro and kumara. With few available protein sources – there were no chickens or pigs – these earliest settlers relied heavily on hunting, particularly in southern Aotearoa where Polynesian horticulture was not viable.

Many species could not withstand even low levels of hunting, especially when combined with predation from introduced animals. People needed to eat, plain and simple.

Modelling suggests that for moa hunting to have been sustainable, more than half of the South Island would have needed to remain a “no-take” zone – and there is little reason to think the moa’s fate would have differed had Europeans arrived first.

Why language and inclusion matter

Effective science communication places findings in context and avoids language that overreaches the evidence or assigns unsupported blame.

A case in point was a recent study that described soot from human-induced forest fires in ice core samples retrieved in Antarctica and linked it to “M?ori arrival in New Zealand”.

Some M?ori saw the framing as suggesting responsibility for pollution in a region often perceived as pristine. There was considerable push back by New Zealand scientists, including M?ori palaeoecologist Rewi Newnham, who showed the soot could have come from fires in Australia or South America around the same time.

It highlighted the problem of talking “about M?ori without M?ori” – and the importance of including Indigenous perspectives to ensure balanced interpretation of results.

We have seen similar tensions arise in discussions about rats. Pest eradication initiatives often treat all three rat species in Aotearoa as interchangeable, overlooking the distinct history of kiore.

While kiore undoubtedly contributed to ecological change, they were also a valued food source, seasonal indicator and taonga carried across the Pacific with intention and care.

Grouping kiore with Norway and ship rats oversimplifies that history and risks reinforcing the same binary thinking that underpins the extinction blame debate.

When nuance is stripped from species histories, our understanding of M?ori relationships with animals are flattened. And opportunities are lost to learn from complex traditions of coexistence and management that could inform conservation today.

Moving forward with m?tauranga

Society would do well to heed the whakatauk? (traditional proverb) kia whakat?muri te haere whakamua – to “walk backwards into the future with our eyes fixed on the past”.

Lessons from both M?ori and P?keh? histories can help inform evidence-based kaitiakitanga, conservation management and sustainable mahinga kai (customary food gathering).

The knowledge gained from palaeontological and archaeological research should be viewed as an opportunity to give back knowledge to M?ori lost due to colonialism, such as how Polynesians adapted to Aotearoa’s dynamic environment and evolved into M?ori.

Within many M?ori narratives of the natural world lie detailed ecological insights, shaped by generations of close relationship and observation.

These stories reflect deep understandings of population dynamics, seasonality and balance – knowledge grounded in lived experience and careful attention to place.

Reengaging with these ways of knowing alongside contemporary science offers more than historical understanding. It opens pathways toward more adaptive, relational and enduring forms of conservation in a rapidly changing world, such as is being done in the East Otago Taiapuri and between Manaaki Whenua Landcare Research and the T?hoe Tuawhenua Trust.

Throwing blame about human impacts in the past is unproductive.

It is knowledge such as m?tauranga, developed over centuries in Aotearoa and over millennia in other Indigenous cultures, alongside established conservation tools, that is needed to tackle Aotearoa’s ongoing biodiversity crisis.

The Conversation

Nic Rawlence receives funding from the Royal Society Te Ap?rangi Marsden Fund.

Kane Fleury works for T?hura Otago Museum which is a publicly funded trust.

Manaia Pearmain-Fenton is a council member of Te Aka Toro (the New Zealand Ecological Society), and is employed by the University of Otago.

5 top tips for the perfect compost – according to science

5 top tips for the perfect compost – according to science

As a young boy, I had to contend with my grandfather’s compost heap. It was a veritable Vesuvius of foul-smelling, putrescible plant waste, a metre high and hidden behind a privet hedge.

We had placed all the weedy waste in it a year before. As we started the annual spring gardening day, the first area we had to clear was the now weed-covered and unsightly compost heap.

By the time we had cleared the weeds sprouting from it, half the day and most of our energy was gone.

We were doing everything wrong. But it’s not too late for you. You can learn from our mistakes.

Making compost is a cornerstone of sustainable gardening, yet few of us understand the great science behind it.

It all comes down to understanding the requirements of the bacteria and fungi that do most of the decomposing and the processes of cellular respiration. Here’s how to work with them, not against them.

Your compost’s little helpers

For the most part, plant material is broken down by bacteria and fungi, aided by worms, other soil organisms and microbiota.

However, there are different types of bacteria and fungi, and the rates they break down organic matter vary enormously.

Some will completely break down plant material into clean, high-grade compost in just six to eight weeks.

Others, as my grandfather and I saw, could not complete the job in a year or more.

That’s in large part due to the big differences between anaerobic and aerobic respiration.

What’s the difference?

Respiration doesn’t just mean breathing. Biologically, is the metabolic process by which cells break down the energy stored in organic molecules (such as sugar and fats) to release energy.

There are two types of respiration:

  • aerobic respiration, which occurs when oxygen is available, and
  • anaerobic respiration, which occurs when there is little or no oxygen available.

In our cells and those of larger plants and animals, both forms of respiration can take place.

But in some micro-organisms, only anaerobic respiration is possible.

Anaerobic respiration is an ancient metabolism that evolved early in the development of life on Earth, well before larger multi-cellular organisms existed.

The processes involved in anaerobic respiration are relatively inefficient. Its chemical reactions result in the incomplete breakdown of the food and plant waste; very little energy and heat are produced along the way.

For composting, that’s a problem.

It means the plant material breaks down very slowly. Worse, the temperature is so low that weedy contaminants can survive and germinate.

This explains why my grandfather’s compost heap failed to decompose after a year, grew so many weeds and was a slimy, smelly mess. The conditions inside the heap were anaerobic from the start.

We ended up being very good at spreading weeds around his garden.

Aerobic is better

Aerobic respiration, which evolved when oxygen was more readily available on Earth, consists of many linked chemical reactions that cause plant material to completely break down.

It produces almost 20 times more energy than anaerobic respiration and generates much more heat.

This high level efficiency produces a more rapid metabolism, which quickly breaks down plant material and the heat generated kills most of the weedy contaminants in the plant litter.

This results in lovely, clean compost.

So the key to good composting is to ensure conditions are right for aerobic respiration and for crucial aerobic bacteria and fungi.

It’s vital to provide oxygen.

My top tips are:

  1. if you have a compost heap, ensure it is wide, long and low (which ensures a high surface area to volume ratio), and introduce air by dragging a hoe or rake through it
  2. if you use a compost tumbler or container, then rotate or stir it often
  3. keep the compost moist (but not wet) over the dry summer months
  4. keep your compost warm over colder months by ensuring it gets some winter sunlight
  5. add some “browns”, such as dry leaves, or shredded cardboard or paper; the carbon-rich browns, added to the high-nitrogen green waste, gives a better carbon to nitrogen ratio and results in better compost.

If your compost is happy, the heat will be high enough to kill most pest eggs and parasites, and may even kill worms.

Don’t add worms to aerobic compost unless you have a worm-friendly composting system; you may end up committing wormicide. Let worms enter the compost naturally.

Rarely, heat from aerobic compost can damage thin-barked trees. So if you’re spreading it around the garden, keep it 20-50mm from the trunks of your trees.

Compost systems and heaps need not be unsightly if you follow the rules for clean and rapid composting.

Aerobic composting is rapid and is neither smelly nor slimy.

The bacteria and fungi that generate your compost efficiently need air, moisture and warmth to be their best selves.

If you resolve to provide the right conditions, you are not only recycling efficiently but getting a product every good gardener wants and needs.

The Conversation

Gregory Moore does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Countries can rewild borders to deter invasions, says EU environment chief

Jessika Roswall cites Poland and Finland, which have made border areas near Russia or its allies ‘more hostile’ to cross

Countries should look to rewild their land borders as a deterrence to invasion and build up other geographical defences to attack, Europe’s environment chief has said.

Jessika Roswall, the EU’s commissioner for the environment, water resilience and a competitive circular economy, said nature should be used to improve national security. “Investing in nature and using nature as a natural border control is necessary, and actually increases biodiversity. It’s a win-win,” she said.

Continue reading…

Large tortoiseshell butterfly confirmed no longer extinct in UK

Early spring sightings show colourful insect is a resident species for first time in decades, says conservation charity

The large tortoiseshell – an elusive and enigmatic butterfly that became extinct in Britain in the last century – is a UK resident species once again, with a flurry of early spring sightings.

Britain’s list of native butterflies has increased to 60 with the return of the insect after individuals emerged from hibernation in woodlands in Kent, Sussex, Hampshire, Dorset, Cornwall and the Isle of Wight.

Continue reading…