Cyclone Narelle: ‘compact’, dangerous and unusually predictable

Cyclone Narelle: ‘compact’, dangerous and unusually predictable

Bureau of Meteorology, Himawari-9 satellite, CC BY-SA

Tropical Cyclone Narelle is currently a very dangerous Category 5 storm, sitting off the Far North Queensland Coast some 350 kilometres northeast of Cooktown. Formed in the Coral Sea, Narelle is packing a punch, with sustained winds near the centre of 205km per hour and wind gusts to 285km per hour.

Sea surface temperatures in the northwest Coral Sea are currently 0.5–1.0°C above average, and this has fuelled the storm’s rapid intensification.

The cyclone’s centre is barrelling towards Cape York at a rapid 26km per hour, and predicted to cross the coast between the Aboriginal community of Lockhart River and Cape Melville on Friday morning. It is expected to weaken a little before it hits land and arrive as a still-dangerous Category 4 cyclone. The small inland town of Coen is also in its path.

The intensity and path of cyclones that form in the Coral Sea are usually difficult to predict. This is because they are pushed in different directions by highly changeable winds, unlike cyclones in most other tropical ocean basins.

Yet Cyclone Narelle has followed a predictable westward path, which makes this cyclone highly unusual.

Where will it go?

The Bureau of Meterology warns that tides in Princess Charlotte Bay, at the base of the narrow part of Cape York Peninsula, are likely to rise significantly above the normal high tide, with dangerous ocean flooding. Any coastal residents in this area are warned of a possible dangerous storm tide as the cyclone centre crosses the coast.

In March 1899, Cyclone Mahina hit the same general area. Cyclone Mahina is considered the deadliest tropical cyclone in Australia’s recorded history, and probably one of the most intense ever recorded globally.

After crossing eastern Cape York, Narelle will weaken rapidly to Category 2 status, before emerging over the warm waters of the Gulf of Carpentaria during the early hours of Saturday morning. Narelle is expected to intensify again as the cyclone heads steadily towards the eastern Northern Territory.

After crossing the NT as a deep tropical low, Narelle is expected to reintensify off the Kimberley coast during next week before shifting into the Indian Ocean. Fortunately, its quick-moving speed means it won’t have the time to dump lots of rain over swollen catchments across the Top End. Nonetheless, river rises are forecast as the centre moves through.

A strong and ‘compact’ cyclone

Narelle is a very compact cyclone, meaning it has a relatively small area of intense winds around its centre. The area of these destructive hurricane-force winds only extends 50km from its centre, while destructive storm force and damaging gale-force winds extend 75km and 130km, respectively.

Due to the laws of physics, smaller cyclones typically spin up faster than larger ones. Likewise, they also weaken rapidly after moving over land areas. Larger cyclones have more inertia, taking longer to spin up over warm oceans and to wind down over land masses.

When it comes to cyclone size (as measured by the area of outer strong gales), there’s no room for complacency. Australia’s most infamous cyclone – Tracy in December 1974 – only had gales extending 40–50km from the eye. But the extreme core winds hit Darwin directly. Because of this, 70–90% of the city’s buildings were damaged, 60–80% of houses were totally destroyed, and roughly 94% of all housing in the city was rendered uninhabitable. The official death toll was 66 people, with more than 145 severely injured.

As Narelle threatens communities on the Cape York Peninsula, we are reminded of another severe weather event with similar characteristics that also hit northeast Queensland.

Exactly 20 years ago, Severe Tropical Cyclone Larry struck Innisfail, 90km south of Cairns, as an intense Category 4 storm. Larry caused significant damage to Innisfail and neighbouring towns, but largely spared Cairns city. Larry caused widespread structural damage, but also wiped out most of Australia’s banana crop, leading to record high prices.

Cyclone Larry was one of very few Coral Sea cyclones that followed a predictable westward track towards the coast. Not only was its track predictable, but also how quickly it moved forward and its intensity at landfall. Such agreement among forecasting weather models is rare for the Coral Sea, that is globally recognised for its erratic cyclone behaviour.

Coral Sea cyclones

So, what makes Cyclones Larry and Narelle unusual for the Coral Sea?

To answer this question, we need to understand how winds behave around tropical cyclones. Cyclones are affected by winds at different heights in the atmosphere. These can cause them to stall if equally opposing winds meet in the region around the cyclone. In other cases, dominant winds from a particular directions will push them along on a clear path. These are called steering winds.

Cyclones are largely steered by winds in the mid levels of the troposphere — roughly 3–7km above the surface. Severe cyclones — like Narelle — are propelled along by winds at the higher end of this range, due to their deep vertical structures, meaning they are taller. Weaker cyclones have a much shallower depth in the atmosphere, so the dominant steering winds are much lower down.

In the case of Narelle (and Larry), a persistent, deep subtropical ridge of high pressure over eastern Australia and the Coral Sea is acting like a conveyor belt, directing the steering winds around the cyclone centre from east to west. This pattern is predicted to continue into next week, which will eventually push Narelle into the Indian Ocean.

There’s another attribute of fast-moving cyclones that is relevant here. In the Southern Hemisphere, all cyclones rotate clockwise due to the Coriolis Force. Narelle’s fast-forward speed means areas south of the eye of the cyclone will experience more severe onshore storm conditions.

The Conversation

Steve Turton has previously received funding from the Australian and Queensland Governments.

Island council considers total ban on all new pet cats

Kangaroo Island Council is considering banning the introduction of all cats to the island, in a move the mayor is calling the “last cat policy”. If successful, the ban would make the South Australian island one of the world’s biggest inhabited islands to be free of cats. 
 

‘Disaster inertia’: why must NZ keep relearning the same lessons from extreme events?

‘Disaster inertia’: why must NZ keep relearning the same lessons from extreme events?

Fiona Goodall/Getty Images

In the aftermath of another summer of weather disasters, there were headlines about a “growing gap” between recovery efforts and preparation for climate change impacts.

There were calls for a rethink of how New Zealand approaches natural hazards and for decision-makers to learn from the lives and homes lost in landslides and floods.

If this sounds all too familiar, it is because the country has become locked in a state of “disaster inertia” – one that has existed for longer than we might think.

Our analysis of New Zealand’s post-disaster reviews over the past decade shows the same problems – some dating back to 1986 – have been repeatedly identified but rarely translated into meaningful policy reform.

Successive warnings from the scientific community about the country’s exposure to extreme weather similarly go unheeded.

With each disaster, we found the country’s response and recovery system reacts in a largely ad hoc way. The capacity and finances of local authorities, which are often already grappling with major infrastructure deficits, are strained as they lurch from one event to the next.

Put simply, New Zealand keeps patching up damage while failing to address its systemic issues – leaving lives, livelihoods and property increasingly at risk as climate impacts intensify.

How disaster inertia shows up in practice

Our review highlighted several concerning trends.

Climate change adaptation efforts are often channelled into engineered protection such as seawalls and levees. But this focus can crowd out land-use planning tools that reduce risk more fundamentally – by keeping development away from exposed areas or enabling planned, staged relocation of homes and infrastructure over time.

The current approach can also create a “levee effect”, encouraging more development behind the protections. This increases flood risk when those protections inevitably fail, and it delays urgently needed avoidance measures.

It may be true that “building back better” – rebuilding damaged homes and infrastructure to higher resilience standards after a disaster – can sometimes improve resilience.

But it often comes at higher cost and with increased residual risk – the danger that remains even after any affordable protections are built – if communities remain in place.

There is also a strong social and political premium placed on rapidly “getting back to normal”, even where that normal is a state of vulnerability, and the “new normal” means increasing frequency and intensity of change.

Another recurring problem comes with the high opportunity costs that follow disasters.

When government funding is inconsistent and piecemeal, local authorities often use scarce resources to rebuild in place and restore what was lost, rather than addressing the underlying drivers of risk through land-use planning. This reinforces institutional inertia and stifles preventive adaptation.

Elsewhere in our analysis, we found that unclear roles between agencies to be persistent problem. While the recommendations of the reviews we assessed could differ depending on the hazard, most were vague about how responsibilities should be allocated in future.

A chance to break the cycle

National stocktakes estimate that around 750,000 New Zealanders and half a million buildings – worth more than $145 billion – are located near rivers and along coasts already exposed to extreme flooding.

As these pressures grow in the years ahead, it is clear from our review that a coherent framework for disaster risk reduction is urgently needed. This must include clear responsibilities, sustainable funding and close integration with adaptation policy.

Action should not be delayed while waiting for better data in the hope it will prompt individuals and councils to respond more effectively. Much of the data needed already exists, but must be coordinated and standardised now.

Progress must begin with strengthening resilience systems, providing sustainable adaptation funding and avoiding risk, with planning for relocation where necessary.

Local authorities are in desperate need of stronger legislation to support action on climate risk reduction and preparedness.

New Zealand has an opportunity to address these issues through current legislative reforms.

These include the Emergency Management Bill, which will replace the Civil Defence Emergency Management Act and clarify roles and responsibilities across the emergency management system.

The Planning Bill, now before parliament, is intended to replace the Resource Management Act and improve how land use, development and natural hazards are managed. Amendments to the Climate Change Response Act have also been signalled to support the implementation of a national climate adaptation framework.

If these reforms fail to align around preemptive risk reduction, communities will face growing damage to homes and livelihoods without insurance or the means to relocate.

The Conversation

Judy Lawrence receives funding from the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment's Accelerating Adaptation to Climate Change fund and serves as a commissioner with the Climate Change Commission.

Rob Bell is managing director of climate adaptation consultancy Bell Adapt Ltd.

Benjamin D Tombs does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.