As the escalating US-Israel war on Iran drives a global fuel supply crisis, New Zealand is eyeing two major – and very different – projects aimed at bolstering its long-term energy security.
While one risks deepening the country’s reliance on the very fossil fuel systems now in turmoil, the other offers a more sustainable alternative.
In February, the government announced plans to develop a liquid natural gas (LNG) import terminal, likely in Taranaki, under its fast-track process.
This would replace New Zealand’s dwindling natural gas supplies, act as a backstop for dry-year electricity shortages and help stabilise power prices.
But it has now been reported that ministers may now be reconsidering the project, as surging global gas prices due to the Middle East conflict undermine its economic case.
Once a government-led initiative, the project is now being steered by a private consortium chaired by former Meridian Energy chief executive and Transpower chairperson Keith Turner.
It would store excess water in a high storage lake when it is plentiful and release it to generate electricity when the hydro lakes are dry, acting as a “battery” to shore up intermittent renewable electricity.
As New Zealand seeks to establish a resilient energy system for the decades ahead, while meeting its climate change commitments, the contrast between these two schemes is hard to ignore.
The follies of fossil fuels
The latest oil shock is forcing countries to confront the fragility of global fuel supply chains – and the risks of relying on them.
At the same time, the urgency of cutting fossil fuel use has become existentially important, as rising global temperatures drive more frequent storms, floods, wildfires and sea-level rise.
Only 4% of New Zealand’s emissions come from its largely renewable electricity system, while 34% come from transport and industrial heat. Electrifying these sectors would cut both emissions and reliance on imported fuels, helping align with the Paris Agreement’s goal of limiting global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.
But electrification will increase demand for renewable electricity. And because wind and solar are variable, the system still needs backup when renewable generation is too low.
Two projects, two paths
Under the government’s terminal proposal, LNG would be imported to shore up dwindling gas supplies, with domestic production having declined over the past decade.
But the proposal cuts against both climate and cost goals. Although gas is meant to produce lower emissions than coal, transporting it around the world can result in higher total greenhouse gas emissions than coal, while leaving New Zealand exposed to volatile international markets.
That concern was echoed in a government-commissioned report by Frontier Economics, which found LNG imports for dry-year risk made “no economic sense”.
LNG is a costly way to generate electricity: around NZ$200–$250 per megawatt-hour (MWh) of power produced, without the cost of the terminal. By comparison, the fully loaded cost of domestic gas-fired power is roughly $125/MWh.
The terminal itself is expected to cost more than $1 billion, with those costs likely passed on to consumers through a levy. Subsidising the terminal risks undermining the commercial viability of cheaper renewable options.
In addition to this, opening an expensive LNG “portal” could incentivise new gas-reliant industries, locking in demand for this imported fossil fuel for decades.
By contrast, pumped hydro is a renewable alternative for shoring up intermittent electricity supply.
In a very dry winter, New Zealand can be short of around 5 terawatt-hours (TWh) of water for electricity generation – or about 12% of total annual demand.
The proposed Lake Onslow project is also not without its drawbacks. One is that it would raise the existing lake by around 20 to 50 metres.
This would have impacts on wetlands and native fish species, and environmental groups have noted the trade-off between local environmental effects and the wider climate benefits.
Bridging the gap
The Onslow scheme will take at least four years to build. But in the meantime, New Zealand has other firming options available to help bridge the gap.
Geothermal generation could be maximised, the Huntly power station can run on wood pellets, and coal and diesel generation could be retained as temporary backup during dry or high demand periods.
The main hydro lakes could also be given slightly more range, and electrified coal boilers could be retained for occasional use.
Demand response – where electricity use is reduced or shifted at peak times – is already being used in New Zealand. But this could be expanded, with large industries cutting output or households reducing demand, such as turning off hot water heating during the brief evening peaks.
Access to vehicle-to-grid battery systems could also be accelerated with government support.
If the crises facing our climate and fuel supplies point to a single message, it’s that energy resilience lies in reducing dependence on imported fossil fuels.
New Zealand has an opportunity to do so by incentivising electrification, facilitating temporary electricity firming, halting plans for the LNG terminal and pushing ahead with the Lake Onslow proposal.
Jen Purdie has received MBIE funding in the past for work around energy and climate, and consults with various energy companies from time to time.
Until recently, the number of citizen scientists in Australia was estimated at between 100,000 and 130,000 people.
But this is a major underestimate. My survey of about 20 key organisations suggests there are likely more than a million in Australia.
There are only a limited number of professional (paid) scientists. But anyone with a smartphone can log observations, and professional scientists increasingly work alongside citizen scientists to collect and analyse valuable conservation data.
Science lives far beyond the lab, and it’s not just done by scientists.
In this series, we spotlight the world of citizen science – its benefits, discoveries and how you can participate.
Citizen science isn’t new. Perhaps the best-known citizen scientist was Charles Darwin, who neglected to finish his medical degree in favour of studying corals. Later, the prolific letter writer built a network of passionate naturalists and collected their observations to gather evidence for his theory of evolution.
But what is new is how easy it is to get involved – and how many people are now lending their time and skills to the cause. It opens up the possibility of science by the people, for the people.
Citizen scientists can sample local waterways and lakes to find invertebrates – and gauge ecosystem health.Australian Citizen Science Association, CC BY-NC-SA
How are citizen scientists contributing?
Melburnians may know the name Ferdinand von Mueller as the first director of the city’s Botanic Gardens. But Mueller started as a passionate botanist who migrated from Germany in 1847, determined to catalogue every plant species in Australia.
After years collecting samples, Mueller realised the task was too big. So he, like Darwin, set about building a network of passionate collectors. Over the next 40 years, more than 1,500 amateur botanists sent him samples. This helped Mueller catalogue hundreds of species new to Western science and produce the first comprehensive surveys of the continent’s vascular plants. Former Chief Scientist Alan Finkel believes Mueller effectively planted citizen science in this country.
Since then, citizen scientists have contributed significantly to science. In 1870, Victorian farmers identified the giant Gippsland earthworm and sent it to professional scientists for confirmation. In 1973, a central Queensland fencing contractor rediscovered the bridled nailtail wallaby (presumed extinct), while a Daintree grazier rediscovered the unique idiot fruit tree – which had not been formally recognised – after its fruit poisoned his cows.
In 1994, bushwalker and amateur botanist David Noble was exploring a remote canyon in the Wollemi National Park west of Sydney when he found the last remaining stand of a tree long thought extinct. The Wollemi pine (Wollemia nobilis) dates back to when dinosaurs roamed Earth.
Even now, passionate citizen scientists are still making new discoveries. In his free time, Jürgen Otto hunts for peacock spiders around Australia. He and his collaborators have named 64 species of the tiny, colourful spiders famed for their courtship displays. This year, Jan Pope and her daughter Sophie Kalkowski-Pope found a huge and unusual coral meadow in the Great Barrier Reef.
So what, exactly, is citizen science?
A good definition is “public participation and collaboration in scientific research with the aim to increase scientific knowledge”.
Key to this are core principles, such as active involvement of citizens in scientific endeavours that generate new knowledge and genuine scientific outcomes.
Earlier generations might have called citizen scientists “amateur naturalists”. The term citizen science became popular for its less binary framing. Some people prefer “community science”.
As Jingili man and zoologist Joe Sambono has observed, Indigenous science shouldn’t be set in opposition to Western science, given science is Latin for “to know”:
all groups of humans […] have recognised patterns, verified through repetition, made inferences and predictions and developed branches of knowledge that helped them to make sense of the world around them and their place within it.
Indigenous science is grounded in continuous, trans-generational, place-based observation built over tens of thousands of years. Cultural burning uses weather, fuel and ecological indicators to gently burn Country while supporting biodiversity, while seasonal calendars tied to flowering plants and wildlife movements shaped practical decisions about when to collect bush tucker, travel and care for Country.
In our experience, enduring insights emerge from the overlapping space between Indigenous, citizen and mainstream science.
Getting involved
Citizen science can be as simple as a keen birder posting sightings of a rare orange bellied parrot to eBird or a fisher posting a sighting of a bull shark to iNaturalist where citizen and professional scientists can see it.
It took six years (2008–14) for Australian citizen scientists to collectively contribute 10,000 species observations on iNaturalist. Now, more than 10,000 are posted every day.
Citizen science can be done solo with a smartphone – or as part of a group working with professional scientists. Here, citizen scientists undertake a bioblitz in Cooloola, Queensland.Michelle Neil, CC BY-NC-ND
From a movement of volunteers to a trusted resource
When this flood of data began, some scientists were sceptical. Could it be trusted?
As time has passed, standardised data collection and guidance from professional scientists have built trust in the data.
In an era of misinformation and declining trust in institutions, citizen science offers people a chance to engage directly with evidence and the natural world.
To date, little funding goes towards making the most of what citizen scientists can offer. Nationally, the government will spend A$15 billion on science this fiscal year. Of this, we estimate less than $10 million will go to citizen science.
What could citizen scientists do next?
Much more is possible. The million Australians involved in these projects are active in the world and interested in helping protect nature. These attributes mean they could take a large role in tackling climate change – especially at local and regional scales – by observing changes, working on projects to reduce emissions, and helping communities adapt to climate change.
To paraphrase the famous anthropologist and citizen scientist Margaret Mead: “Never doubt that a small group of citizen (scientists) can change the world – in fact it is the only thing that ever has.”
Stephanie von Gavel and Dr Annie Lane contributed to this article. They are the chair and immediate past chair of the Australian Citizen Science Association.
Adam Smith is a member of the Australian Citizen Science Association
Gregory Andrews is affiliated with the Canberra Writers Festival and Lyrebird Dreaming Pty Ltd..
Steve Turton is an elected member of the national committee of the Australian Citizen Science Association. He has received funding from the Australian government.
Fuel has become a precious, and increasingly expensive, commodity.
The ongoing Middle East conflict has effectively closed the Strait of Hormuz, cutting off 20% of the world’s oil supplies. This, coupled with tit-for-tat attacks on key energy infrastructure across the region, has sent fuel prices soaring.
In Australia, petrol and diesel bowsers have already started running dry. And the country’s leading motoring organisation is now urging drivers to fill up with E10 fuel, in an effort to conserve our national fuel supplies.
So what exactly is E10? And could it help ease the current fuel crisis?
Remind me, what’s E10?
E10 is a type of fuel made from a mixture of regular unleaded petrol and ethanol. Ethanol is a highly flammable liquid produced when sugars from plants, such as corn or sugarcane, are fermented into ethyl alcohol or ethanol.
To make a batch of E10, you combine nine parts petrol with one part ethanol. So the “E” stands for ethanol and the “10” indicates how much of it is in the blend. Given ethanol costs less than regular petrol, E10 is generally cheaper than other fuel types.
E10 fuel contains 3% less energy than other low-grade petrols. This means if you swap regular unleaded for E10, you’d need about 3% more E10 to travel the same distance. So while E10 is often cheaper at the bowser, it’s likely any savings will be balanced out by the need to fill up more often.
Both ethanol and regular unleaded petrol can be ignited. So blending these two liquids to make E10 produces a fuel that is compatible with modern combustion engines.
However, the inclusion of ethanol increases the octane rating of the fuel. The octane rating is based on how quickly a fuel ignites in a standard combustion engine. So the higher the octane rating, the more stable the fuel and the less likely it is to damage engine cylinders and rods.
But if you have an older car, it may be best to avoid using E10. This is because engines built before 2000 are generally incompatible with this type of fuel. Ethanol can degrade older seals and fuel lines, which are often made of plastic and rubber not designed for exposure to ethanol. Importantly, E10 is not suitable for use in petrol carburettors. These devices, which pump a mixture of fuel and air into combustion engines, are only found in older cars.
So the idea that E10 damages cars likely comes from its effect on older vehicles. But for cars with engines made after 2000, E10 is generally safe to use.
Research suggests the combustion of E10 could reduce greenhouse gas emissions by up to 5%, depending on how the ethanol is produced.
Crops such as sugarcane, commonly used in Brazilian and some Australian ethanol, absorb significant amounts of carbon dioxide as they grow. This can help offset the emissions produced from the combustion of E10. In contrast, corn-based ethanol, which is mostly found in the US, has a negligible impact on carbon dioxide emissions. Sitting in the middle is ethanol made from wheat. Research suggests this kind of ethanol may slightly reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Over the past 14 years, demand for E10 fuel has declined by about 44%. But this trend could turn around, as the prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz forces governments around the world to consider alternatives to diesel and regular petrol.
For countries which import most of their crude oil and refined petroleum products, encouraging the production and use of E10 may slightly reduce the strain on domestic fuel supplies. This is because adding up to 10% ethanol increases how much regular petrol is available. However, this assumes residents have engines that are compatible with lower-grade fuels. And it would only be useful if countries can produce their own ethanol, instead of relying on imported ethanol.
In Australia, we import the vast majority of our diesel. This makes us extremely vulnerable to fuel shocks, including the crisis we’re currently experiencing. We meet about 20% of our national fuel demand with domestic supplies. However, only a portion of that fuel is produced in the form of unleaded petrol which is suitable for E10 blending.
Australia produces nearly all of the ethanol we consume domestically, in any given year. This includes ethanol used in E10 fuel. Increasing our domestic ethanol production, involving both our agricultural and manufacturing sectors, could help conserve a small percentage of our national petrol supplies. This is because the E10 blending process must happen at the point of refining, so we can only add ethanol to the petrol we produce in Australia.
If every Australian switched to using E10, this would save roughly 2% of the 20% of petrol we produce domestically. Every saving matters in a global fuel crisis. However, our current reliance on fossil fuels such as coal and gas limits the potential benefits of switching to E10.
So if you do switch from diesel or petrol to E10, you may see a slight reduction in your fuel costs and emissions. However, this decision is unlikely to take much pressure off our limited fuel supplies. For that we need effective policy and, ultimately, a swift end to the current Middle East conflict.
Zachary Aman has consulted with multiple oil and gas companies including Woodside, Chevron, Shell, and INPEX. He has received funding from oil and gas companies as well as the Australian Research Council. He is an Affiliate Faculty at the Colorado School of Mines.
Authorities say motorists are repeatedly ignoring warnings not to drive in floodwaters in WA’s north in the wake of Cyclone Narelle, with 20 people having to be rescued.