Channel Seven’s Spotlight digging for dirt on clean energy ignores fundamental facts and basic journalistic standards | Temperature Check

Program portrayed efforts to wean Australia off fossil fuels as morally bankrupt, trashing rainforests and enslaving Australia to China

Children sieve mud, workers drop down claustrophobic hand-cut mine shafts, men grimace while others carve out rock with chisels in bare feet to recover cobalt “for our renewable green dream”.

These were the dramatic scenes from the Democratic Republic of Congo in a “special investigation” from Channel Seven’s Spotlight program, aired in prime-time on Sunday evening.

Continue reading…

Foreign companies are making billions off Australia’s gas. It’s time that changed

Foreign companies are making billions off Australia’s gas. It’s time that changed

bugto/Getty

Is Australia giving away its gas resources, virtually for free?

That question is at the centre of this week’s parliamentary inquiry into the taxation of gas resources.

Over the last decade, Australia has become one of the world’s largest exporters of liquefied natural gas.

But while the gas is extracted from beneath Australian soils, the profits go almost entirely to large multinational companies. Research suggests gas companies have made roughly $A149 billion from exports in just four years. Only a small percentage of this profit has been taxed.

That’s why some politicians, think tanks and environmental groups are pushing for a 25% tax on gas exports.

Modelling by the Australia Institute suggests this tax could raise up to $17 billion a year and potentially lower domestic fuel prices by incentivising producers to sell more gas into the Australian market.

How is gas currently taxed?

Currently, Australia’s main tax on gas exports is the Petroleum Resource Rent Tax.

Profits made by companies running oil and gas projects are taxed at up to 40%. At present, this tax mainly applies to offshore producers.

While this sounds good, the tax is less effective in practice. Energy companies have access to generous tax deductions as well as “uplifts”, which allow companies to use the losses from one year to offset the amount of tax they pay the next year. The rationale for allowing uplifts was to incentivise companies to invest in Australian oil and gas projects by letting them recover costs.

The problem is this system allows oil and gas companies to pay little, if any, tax on their profits. As a result, economists and policy analysts have argued this tax is no longer fit for purpose, particularly given how much gas we export.


Read more: Is there really untold oil wealth in Queensland’s Taroom Trough? Here’s why scepticism is warranted


Onshore liquefied natural gas producers in Queensland are exempt, but are still required to pay the standard 30% company tax rate.

But oil and gas companies are often able to reduce how much they pay here too, using various deductions and accounting practices. This is because the money they spend on construction, drilling and infrastructure is immediately deductible.

The governments of states where onshore gas companies are active can also impose royalties. These are payments which mining companies must make to the owner of the natural resources – the state government in most cases – for the right to extract them.


Read more: Heading north: how the export boom is shaking up Australia’s gas market


Royalties are different from taxes in that they are payments for the right to exploit a public resource. The royalty rate is based on the raw value of the oil and gas produced, rather than profit. Companies must pay royalties even if a project is losing money. In Queensland, gas producers pay between 5% and 10% of their revenue in tax. This can generate significant income, but nowhere near as much as a profit-based tax designed with fewer loopholes. That’s because royalties do not scale with profitability.

Australia’s gas export industry has long been under-regulated, particularly on the east coast. For many years producers have simply exported as much gas as possible.

But this is gradually changing. In 2023, the government introduced a mandatory gas code requiring producers to first offer gas domestically on fair, transparent terms. From 2027, the government will require producers to reserve some gas for the domestic market.

Looking overseas

Nations such as Norway tax their natural resource exports much more robustly.

The Norwegian government applies two taxes to petroleum profits – a 22% company tax and a 56% special petroleum tax – which mean companies are taxed on roughly 78% of their profits. Its taxation rules are stricter and more standardised, meaning companies have less scope to carry forward large deductions. The funds raised go to the Government Pension Fund Global, previously known as the Petroleum Fund of Norway, now worth more than $3 trillion. The fund was established in 1990 to shield the economy from oil industry volatility.

Gas giant Qatar also has a high-taxation system giving it a large share of oil and gas profits. Qatar uses these funds to subsidise health care, education and public infrastructure.

Even countries with limited domestic energy resources use these taxes. In 1978, Japan introduced a tax on oil and gas imports. This tax generates significant revenue, raising roughly $8 billion in 2025 alone.

In March, a proposal to introduce a 25% gas tax was defeated in the Australian Senate. But advocates aren’t giving up. They point to high public support amid soaring energy prices.


Read more: More Australian LNG to Singapore flagged as Albanese looks to strengthen oil supply chain


Why tax gas exports?

A 25% tax on gas exports would be applied as a flat tax on the value of gas exports, rather than the profits gas companies make from those exports. It’s similar to a royalty, but instead would be calculated as a percentage of the exported product.

This approach would simplify the tax system and could not be minimised in the same way as the Petroleum Resource Rent Tax and company tax.

An exports tax would also raise significant public revenue, estimated at $17 billion annually. That’s enough to provide free childcare or tertiary education for Australians. The revenue could also help reduce government debt, which reached a record $1.6 trillion in 2025.

Backers argue the tax would boost domestic gas supply, as it would encourage producers to avoid the tax by selling more gas locally. This could help lower domestic energy prices, an urgent concern for many businesses and households.


Read more: Why Middle East gas field attacks could send energy prices soaring


What are the downsides?

Critics argue the tax would discourage companies from investing in new gas projects, which could reduce gas availability and affect regional jobs.

Opponents also claim the tax would undermine Australia’s reputation as a stable and predictable country to invest in.

Another concern is a 25% tax could make Australia less competitive in global energy markets, particularly compared to lower-cost producers such as Qatar. It may also cause legal issues if applied to existing export agreements.

The bottom line

For decades, we’ve allowed foreign companies to earn billions of dollars from our gas sector, and to be taxed very little.

So despite concerns it may affect gas industry employment and investment, introducing a 25% gas exports tax would ensure all Australians benefit from these public, state-owned resources.


Read more: The Iran war has triggered a fuel price rise. What does this mean for Australian consumers?


The Conversation

Samantha Hepburn does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Green tram tracks cut heat and beautify cities. Why isn’t Australia doing it?

Green tram tracks cut heat and beautify cities. Why isn’t Australia doing it?

A tram on green tracks in Strasbourg, France Prasit photo/Getty

Cities are hotter than the surrounding countryside. Paved surfaces such as asphalt and concrete trap heat and release it at night. But as climate change worsens, this is becoming a real risk for residents.

Researchers are racing to find ways to protect urban residents from rising temperatures and pollution. As recent research shows, there’s no single fix for urban heat. Different places need different solutions, from tree canopies to cool roofs to reflective pavements.

Taming urban heat doesn’t necessarily require extravagant ideas such as air-conditioned footpaths. Some of the most effective tools are simple adjustments to infrastructure we already have, using nature to cool cities down with vegetation, soil and water.

One promising solution is hiding in plain sight: our tram tracks (particularly the many sections that run on their own corridors, separated from traffic). Cities around the world have been greening their tram corridors by replacing concrete with grass or low vegetation.

The idea is not new – grass-covered tram tracks date back to Berlin in 1905 – but has seen a resurgence since the 1980s. And the results are surprisingly effective.

tram passing through city street.
Australia’s tram network almost entirely runs along concrete. Cesar G/Pexels, CC BY-NC-ND

How does this work?

A green tram track replaces the usual concrete around tram rails with a layer of healthy vegetation. Many cities use grasses or species of sedum, a genus of drought-resistant succulents able to survive in extreme conditions such as heat, low water and constant vibration.

The plants sit on a thin substrate designed to hold moisture and drain excess water, essentially turning part of the tram corridor into green infrastructure.

These systems are typically used on sections where trams run in their own corridor, rather than in lanes shared with general traffic.

Once in place, this simple system delivers multiple benefits:

  • Better stormwater management: Green tracks absorb and slow rainfall instead of letting it run straight into drains. Studies show these systems can increase water storage by 50–70%, easing pressure during intense storms and supporting “sponge city” goals, even in relatively dense areas with limited open space.

  • Lower surface and air temperatures: Plants don’t trap heat like concrete does. Thermal scans of green tracks show surface temperatures are roughly 10°C lower during summer peaks.

  • Less noise and vibration: The plants dampen sound and vibrations from passing trams, though this effect is modest.

Plantings along tram tracks can help trap dust and fine particles on busy corridors, and provide a small boost to local air quality.

Even these narrow strips of green tracks help biodiversity by creating continuous habitat for insects and acting as ecological connectors between parks, nature strips and street trees.

Then there are the aesthetic benefits. In many cities, residents have reported that they prefer the softer, greener look of these tracks.

a tram running along green tram tracks
This tram line in the Netherlands has been greened. Joshua Nomso

Where are these tracks?

Green tram tracks are now found in dozens of cities across Europe and beyond.

Greening is popular. A study of Warsaw residents found more than 90% viewed their city’s green tracks positively, rating them around five times more favourably than conventional paved track.

A Swedish study found a similar pattern. Residents described the grassed tram track as beautiful, calming and a clear improvement over a hard, traffic-dominated corridor.

Municipal staff, however, were more cautious. They acknowledged the visual and environmental benefits but worried about long-term maintenance costs and whether the model could be scaled across the network.

How much does it cost?

Installing a green track usually costs more than a bare concrete slab. But there are ways to keep costs down.

Grass needs mowing, watering and occasional replanting, which makes councils understandably nervous about ongoing budgets.

Sedum succulents have much lower maintenance needs and can need little or no irrigation once established. This reduces lifecycle costs even if the initial planting is more expensive.

Studies comparing grass and sedum tracks have found the long-term maintenance burden is much lower for sedum, while the main visual and environmental benefits are largely preserved.

Can this work in Australia?

Australia experimented with the idea of green tram tracks well before many other countries. Almost 20 years ago, Adelaide installed a small-scale grassed track as part of the Glenelg tram extension. While small, it is now considered an early example of using a nature-based solution in railways.

Sydney now boasts a much more substantial example. The Parramatta Light Rail has more than a kilometre of green track, using sedum plantings. This makes Australia’s largest and most modern installation.

It’s a good start. But there’s much more that could be done. Australia has about 339km of tram and light rail. Melbourne has more than 250km, making it the largest network in the world. And more tracks are being built.

Green tram tracks can’t be installed everywhere. They can’t be planted where tracks are built into the road and where cars, trucks and buses would run over them. They need a protected, stable track bed with no heavy traffic.

Much of Melbourne’s tram network runs along long medians and dedicated corridors, such as St Kilda Road, where tracks are already separated from traffic and could easily support green tracks.

In recent years, Sydney has expanded its light rail network through the CBD and out to the east and west. Canberra and the Gold Coast run modern systems designed with separated trackbeds, exactly the conditions where green tracks thrive.

Green tram tracks are not a silver bullet for urban heat. But they offer something rare in transport infrastructure: a visible, popular, nature-based upgrade able to cool streets, manage water, relax neighbourhoods and improve how a city looks and feels.

As Australia invests billions in new tram and light rail lines, the benefits of green tracks are too significant to ignore.

The Conversation

The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.