Farage’s Clacton-on-Sea constituency worst ‘tree desert’ in England, research shows

Woodland Trust also finds significant north-south divide in tree cover, leaving many people at risk of poor health

Nigel Farage’s constituency of Clacton-on-Sea is a “tree desert”, leaving people more exposed to air pollution, poorer health, lower life expectancy and the impact of rising temperatures, according to a new report.

The Essex town is rated the worst-performing for equal access to trees in England, with the highest proportion of urban residents – 98.2% – living in neighbourhoods with critically low access to trees.

Continue reading…

Changing climate law to prevent civil cases removes a key protection for NZ citizens

Changing climate law to prevent civil cases removes a key protection for NZ citizens

Ben McKay/AAP, Mark Baker/AP, The Conversation

The government’s plan to change the law to bar claims for harms from greenhouse gas emissions shuts down New Zealand’s most important climate tort case, meaning it will never be decided on its merits.

The move overrides a unanimous Supreme Court decision that Smith v Fonterra, a case against some of New Zealand’s major corporate emitters, should go to trial.

It also guts the future capacity of tort law – a branch of civil law allowing people to seek damages for harm caused by wrongful actions by others – to curb climate harms.

Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith justified it by saying climate change is best managed by the government at a national level, not through torts claims, and that shutting down these cases will “provide businesses with certainty around their obligations”.

As we explain, this argument is questionable on a number of fronts.

What the courts do that politics can’t

In New Zealand and elsewhere, tort law is being used to hold greenhouse gas emitters to account.

Tort claimants are also targeting governments for not doing enough to protect current and future generations. Leaving climate change regulation entirely to the government, then, is a little like putting the fox in charge of the hen house.

The minister is right to say the fight against climate change needs robust government action. But removing the role of the courts is the wrong way to go about it.

Courts do things governments cannot. They cannot be lobbied. They decide on evidence and law. They name specific actors and test their conduct against legal standards.

No one denies the complexities of fighting climate change. But tort law has always confronted new challenges.

It has been part of the fight against factory pollution, defective products, unsafe workplaces and corporate fraud. In the past year, tort law helped in the fight against online harm. Climate change is next in that sequence.

Courts overseas are already doing this work. In 2021, a Dutch court ordered a multinational company to align its activities with the Paris Agreement, the main international treaty combating climate change. However, this decision was appealed in 2024.

Last year, a German court held that major emitters can be liable for climate harm, even when the harm occurs abroad.

In Australia, torts claimants have attempted to hold the government to account for inadequate climate regulation. Some claims have been rejected, but one is ongoing.

The courts confirmed the climate science and increased public awareness. With the Smith v Fonterra case, we were about to see how New Zealand tort law can contribute to these efforts.

Why the government’s argument is wrong

We also call the government’s “certainty for business” argument into question.

Uncertainty is not effectively managed by extinguishing risks. Investors need risks to be priced. Legislating away tort liability does not eliminate the cost – it transfers it to others, just as lax regulation of flood risk has imposed severe costs on councils, insurers and households.

Under the government’s law change proposal, those who profit most from lax climate policy would be insulated from paying their share.

There is already a big gap in New Zealand’s current climate regulations. They do not allocate responsibility for damage. Tort law would do this.

The point the Supreme Court was making in its decision to allow Smith v Fonterra to go to trial was that even though there is regulation in an area, tort claims also have an important role.

Rule of law concerns

New Zealand’s parliament can legislate retrospectively, but the question is whether it should.

The traditions of the rule of law say it should not, unless there is compelling justification otherwise. The justification offered here is thin.

The government points to certainty for business investment and the integrity of its legislative regime. Neither comes close to a sufficient reason to bar an entire field of tort claims.

But the proposal fits a broader pattern. It follows a weakened methane target despite the Climate Change Commission’s recommendation it should have been strengthened, the return of offshore fossil fuel exploration, and the decoupling of New Zealand’s Emissions Trading Scheme from its commitments under the Paris Agreement.

Against that backdrop, preventing climate-focused tort claims is not an outlier. We argue it is the next layer of a deliberate dismantling of a system of climate accountability.

This conflicts with constitutional and international legal recognition that governments have a duty to protect citizens from climate change.

Last year, the International Court of Justice issued an advisory opinion which unanimously affirmed that states have legal obligations to protect the climate system, and that failing to prevent significant harm creates responsibility under international law.

The German Federal Constitutional Court also said Germany’s constitution requires the government to safeguard future generations from worsening impacts of climate change.

New Zealand’s current political process is not holding major emitters to account, and the regulatory framework is straining. The courts were the one part of the system still doing the work – until now.

The Conversation

Bjørn-Oliver Magsig is a board member of Lawyers for Climate Action New Zealand Incorporated (LCANZI), but has no involvement in the litigation itself and no financial stake in its outcome.

Graeme Austin is member of Lawyers for Climate Action New Zealand Incorporated but has no involvement in its work.

New revelations show WA is putting Australia’s climate targets at risk. Will Anthony Albanese do anything about it? | Clear Air

Premier Roger Cook has the prime minister’s implicit support but he’s making it harder for federal Labor to meet its much-vaunted climate targets

Western Australia has blazing sun, stunning Indian Ocean beaches, wide open roads and, for the first time in a while, a potentially successful AFL team. It also has an occasional separatist urge. That tendency may partly explain why its government thinks it shouldn’t be expected to act on the climate crisis in the same way as the population on the east coast.

Anthony Albanese and members of his cabinet have given implicit support to its climate position. The prime minister has fallen in behind the WA Labor government as the premier, Roger Cook, has backed fossil fuel expansions and argued that an increase in the state’s emissions would be good for the climate because its gas exports reduce coal burning in Asia.

Sign up to get climate and environment editor Adam Morton’s Clear Air column as a free newsletter

Continue reading…

Electric transport is no longer niche. This year’s budget shows it’s the future

Electric transport is no longer niche. This year’s budget shows it’s the future

sinology/Getty

Last night’s federal budget suggests an important step in Australia’s transition to cleaner energy and electric transport may be underway.

Spiking prices and geopolitical uncertainty in global oil markets show transport policy is no longer just about mobility or environmental issues. It’s also about energy.

Australia’s overwhelming dependence on imported fuels has left it vulnerable to the worst energy crisis on record. Leaders have scrambled to shore up scarce supplies of diesel while EV sales soared across Australia.

The 2026 budget has important investments in freight rail, walking and cycling and fuel supplies.

But there were big gaps too. There was little to boost the EV charger network or begin electrifying heavy vehicles. There was also no clear plan for how governments will replace fuel excise revenue as transport electrifies.

Overall, the budget continues the cautious and incremental shift towards electric transport, rather than hitting the accelerator.

EV transition and market maturity

If the government backs EVs, why is it dialling back tax incentives such as the Electric Car Discount, which helped accelerate their early uptake?

It’s because policymakers believe the EV market is maturing. Many more models have entered the market, cheaper models are available, ranges are longer and the secondhand market is growing. In April, sales of new battery EVs hit 16%. As markets mature, fewer incentives are needed.

Gaps around EV infrastructure

The budget included boosts for kerbside EV chargers and fleet electrification. These are welcome. But Australia will need significantly more infrastructure to support the mass uptake of electric transport.

Confidence in public chargers has to be higher. Millions of renters and apartment residents can’t charge at home. Drivers and companies have to be confident of stable policies to keep investing in EVs. In this respect, the budget was a missed opportunity.

Road funding and long-term reform

While the budget included support for the EV transition, it postponed the more difficult but vital conversations around how Australia will replace fuel excise revenue.

Next financial year, the government will get an estimated $28 billion from these taxes on liquid fuels. As more EVs appear, this revenue source will dwindle. This budget stops short of outlining a comprehensive long-term pathway.

The fairest replacement for fuel excise is to charge road users based on usage. This approach is highly sensitive, given cost-of-living pressures. But policymakers will not be able to avoid the question for too much longer.

Fuel security and resilience

Energy resilience was a key theme in this year’s budget, evident in the focus on securing fuel supplies and building more reliable supply chains.

There’s another welcome shift towards sustainable transport beyond EVs. This was clear in finding ways to send more freight by rail and ships through a $55 million pilot program.

The government announced $500 million for active transport such as walking and cycling. This is very significant.

The budget funded several big road and rail upgrades across Queensland, Western Australia and New South Wales. These include freight rail improvements, upgrades to industrial corridors and better connections to urban areas.

At the same time, the government’s decision to axe the Inland Rail project points to a continuing tension between long-term goals to boost rail freight and concerns around project costs.

Billions for city railways

One surprise announcement was $3.8 billion more for Melbourne’s Suburban Rail Loop. The funding will further embed the Commonwealth in one of the nation’s most ambitious – and controversial – transport projects. It’s now estimated to cost $34.5 billion.

The Victorian government wants the large new railway to boost connection between suburbs and increase urban development around the stations.

It’s reasonable to debate whether smaller-scale investments could deliver broader network benefits more quickly and at lower cost. But transformational projects such as this one are also intended to reshape land use, housing growth and make cities better connected. In practice, transport systems often require both incremental optimisation and selective long-term megaproject investment.

The road ahead

Transport is no longer simply about moving people and goods. This year’s budget makes clear transport is tied to economic resilience, energy security, productivity and long-term national sustainability.

The transition to electric transport is no longer a niche topic for environmentalists. It’s becoming a broader economic and strategic transition that will shape how Australians live, move, work and connect in the decades ahead.

The challenge for policymakers is to keep the transport transition moving – and to ensure it remains affordable, equitable and reliable. The public have to be confident in both transport infrastructure and government policy.

The Conversation

Hussein Dia receives funding from the Australian Research Council, the iMOVE Australia Cooperative Research Centre, Transport for New South Wales, Queensland Department of Transport and Main Roads, Victorian Department of Transport and Planning, and Department of Infrastructure, Transport, Regional Development, Communications, Sport and the Arts.