Geothermal 2.0: how superhot rocks underground could help power Australia

Geothermal 2.0: how superhot rocks underground could help power Australia

Gretar Ívarsson/Wikimedia

Long before sunlight sustained life on the surface, Earth’s internal heat powered the deep-sea vents where scientists believe life began.

The immense reservoir of heat inside Earth keeps the planet geologically active. But it can also be very useful to humans. Geothermal energy represents a huge and largely untapped source of clean electricity available around the clock. The concept is simple: drill wells down to the heat and use heated water to drive turbines to make electricity.

As the world grapples with a major fossil-fuel energy crisis, governments and companies are looking for alternatives for a more secure future. After decades of development, geothermal is now ready for prime time.

Until recently, geothermal was limited to areas where heat was close to the surface – think geysers and volcanoes. But new deep drilling techniques are revolutionising the sector, opening up access to superhot rocks at temperatures above 350°C.

Our collaborative research with the Clean Air Task Force, a research nonprofit organisation, provides the first global overview of superhot rock geothermal potential, showing how much of this energy is available – even in regions with little or no volcanic activity such as Australia.

Why look to geothermal?

Unlike wind or solar, geothermal can produce power steadily, unaffected by weather or day-night cycles. It can also be built much faster and more cheaply than nuclear power. For countries looking to build cleaner energy systems, this combination is hard to ignore.

Conventional geothermal plants produce power in more than 40 countries. Iceland gets almost a third of its electricity from geothermal, while the United States and Indonesia have the largest installed geothermal capacity.

But geothermal is a minor player globally, providing only around 1% of renewable electricity generation.

That’s likely to change rapidly. Next-generation geothermal removes many earlier limitations. The International Energy Agency forecasts that it could rapidly become a major source of clean power, provided the industry can cut costs as solar, wind and batteries have done.

US researchers estimate geothermal could supply up to three times as much power as nuclear within 25 years.

More than two dozen countries are working to build more next-generation geothermal power. This is likely to accelerate. Superhot geothermal pioneers include Iceland, New Zealand, the US, Japan, China and several European Union nations.

What does next generation geothermal look like?

Older drilling techniques required months to drill the wells. The new technologies make this much faster, at up to 30 metres an hour.

New geothermal technologies make it possible to drill into much deeper and hotter parts of the crust than ever before.

Drillers can now reach depths of 5 kilometres to target superhot rocks, whose temperatures can exceed 350°C. Still newer methods could reach depths of 10km.

Under extreme heat and pressure, water at these depths changes into a supercritical fluid. In this form, it can carry up to ten times more energy than either steam or liquid water.

If every litre of water carries much more energy, geothermal becomes much more powerful – and scalable. Researchers estimate tapping 1% of the world’s superhot rocks could meet global electricity demand eight times over.

Better drilling technologies have another benefit – access to these superhot rocks in a far wider variety of settings. You don’t need to drill near active volcanoes any more.

But superhot geothermal also has challenges. If not carefully managed, wells can lose flow, pressure or temperature over time. But if well-managed, superhot systems could operate for 30–50 years at costs comparable to wind-generated electricity.

Where could it work in Australia?

The technology isn’t totally new to Australia. Small geothermal power plants have been trialled, and underground heat is used to heat pools.

Large areas of Australia have strong potential for geothermal heating and electricity generation, according to assessments by the Australian Renewable Energy Agency, the Australian Geothermal Association and Geoscience Australia.

Preliminary estimates by the Clean Air Task Force indicate tapping 1% of Australia’s superhot rocks would provide the equivalent energy of 3 billion barrels of oil or 20 times the nation’s electricity use as of 2021.

Across parts of Victoria, Tasmania, Queensland, New South Wales and Western Australia, superhot rocks are likely to be at depths of 4–8km, meaning they should be reachable with new technologies.

As a major mining nation, Australia has vast experience in subsurface exploration, world-leading geoscience research and strong engineering and technical capabilities.

The clear overlap between geothermal and Australia’s existing capabilities means scaling up the industry could also provide jobs for workers leaving fossil fuel industries.

Why hasn’t it happened yet? Upfront costs and uncertainty.

Deep drilling is still relatively expensive, and predicting target temperatures at depth remains difficult. To date, there hasn’t been enough private investment to kickstart large-scale geothermal. Some promising resources in remote areas such as the Great Artesian Basin would require new transmission infrastructure.

Recent progress in countries such as the US, China and Germany show these challenges can be overcome.

Tapping Australia’s deep geothermal resources could unlock new sources of net-zero-emissions electricity for homes, industry and transport, as well as hydrogen production, data centres and critical minerals processing.

What would need to happen?

If Australia is serious about a cleaner and more secure energy future, it’s worth looking at the advances in deep geothermal.

The first step would be to create a new Australian roadmap for deep geothermal energy. This would bring together recent advances in drilling and subsurface exploration, support pilot projects, and encourage collaboration with global leaders.

If this succeeds, the heat that has powered Earth for billions of years could help protect its future.

The Conversation

Juan Carlos Afonso received funding from Geoscience Australia (for a project not related to geothermal energy) and the Clean Air Task Force.

Heather Handley is a member of the International Association of Volcanology and Chemistry of the Earth's Interior, the Geological Society of Australia, and the Mineralogical Society of Victoria.

Indigenous Australians were the world’s first astronomers. But their knowledge is now at risk

Indigenous Australians were the world’s first astronomers. But their knowledge is now at risk

Oliver Strewe/Getty

I’m a proud Yorta Yorta and Barapa Barapa man, an Indigenous astronomer and a trainee ecologist.

When I look at the night sky, I don’t just see stars. Instead, I see an ancient knowledge system that has guided people, culture and Country for tens of thousands of years.

But that knowledge is now at risk. In many of our towns and cities, the stars are increasingly hidden behind a haze of artificial light. And that light pollution is threatening a unique way of understanding the world.

A ‘living classroom’

The night sky is a living classroom, at once a calendar, map, lore book and weather forecast.

Indigenous Elders share this knowledge with younger people – often outdoors, on Country, beneath the stars.

They may start by talking about constellations, which have helped guide Indigenous Australians for millenia.

One example is the Wangel or “long-necked turtle” constellation. Various Indigenous communities looked to this constellation, based on the bright orange star Pollux, to know when it was time to travel and gather for different ceremonies. This may be because the bright orange star reflects the turtle’s orange colouring.

Stars with a turtle traced over them
The Wangel (long-necked turtle) constellation. Habitat Warriors, CC BY

Another is the Djurt or “red-rumped parrot” constellation. This constellation is based on the Antares star which appears bright red with a blue halo, resembling the parrot’s red and blue feathers. This constellation guided communities to spots where food was abundant, such as grasslands that were full of seeds.

Constellations also hold lore, or rules, that guide sustainable practices. For example, when the Otchocut or “Murray cod” constellation appears in the night sky, we do not hunt Murray Cod. This is because it becomes visible when the rivers are warm and the fish are breeding, typically between October to November. Similarly, when the red-rumped parrot constellation appears, that means the parrot is breeding and therefore cannot be hunted.

The stars may also provide weather forecasts, but only if you have the knowledge and observation skills to understand them. For example, a star that twinkles and appears bright blue suggests a storm is coming. And if a cluster of stars twinkle quickly, it may mean the wind will become stronger.

Stars with a fish traced over them
The Otchocut (Murray cod) constellation. Habitat Warriors, CC BY

Stars and songlines

The routes laid out by the stars are often connected to songlines. Songlines, sometimes known as dreaming tracks, are cultural pathways that connect traditional sites. Songlines also act as “drop pins” that indicate where important resources, such as waterholes and food, may be.

A well-known example is the Seven Sisters dreamtime story, which recounts the journey of seven sisters that ultimately become part of the Taurus constellation. For some Indigenous communities in central Australia, the Seven Sisters serve as a kind of celestial map. This is because the seven stars roughly mirror the location of seven waterholes.

The threat of light

As our cities grow, light pollution from streetlights, floodlights and buildings is spreading. As a result, it’s increasingly rare to see dark nights and starry skies near urban areas.

For Indigenous communities, this has a direct cultural impact.

Light pollution makes it near impossible to connect with the stars, and therefore share Indigenous sky knowledge with younger generations.

A small furry dark brown bat clinging to a branch
Microbats are an important Barapa Barapa men’s totem. Chris Lindorff /iNaturalist, CC BY

Light pollution also affects culturally important species. In Barapa Barapa culture, the microbat is a men’s totem and the nightjar is a women’s totem. Both are nocturnal animals that rely on darkness, so artificial light makes it harder for them to survive.

Beyond culture, light pollution has widespread ecological impacts, affecting how animals grow, behave and breed. Research suggests light pollution can stop clownfish eggs from hatching, shrink the brains of spiders and disorient threatened seabirds such as petrels and shearwaters.

It can also negatively affect human health. Research shows artificial light – particularly from LED lights and electronic devices – may trigger sleep and mood disorders and certain cardiovascular problems.

The nocturnal Nightjar is an important Barapa Barapa women’s totem. DH Fischer/iNaturalist, CC BY

So, what can we do?

The good news is, we can each help reduce light pollution by making simple lifestyle changes. Here are some ideas:

  • turn off outdoor lights whenever you’re not using them
  • use lightbulbs with a lower brightness and warmer colouring
  • choose light designs that direct light only where its needed
  • close curtains and blinds at night to stop indoor light from spilling out
  • during festive times such as Christmas, opt for daytime decorations instead of outdoor lights.

We can also better regulate the use of artificial light outdoors. Currently, Australia does not have any regulations around light pollution. But countries such as France have substantially reduced their light pollution levels by regulating what kind of lighting people can use and install.

Together, stronger regulation and simple lifestyle tweaks could help us tackle light pollution. And that’s key to keeping Indigenous sky knowledge alive.

Kai Lane talks about Indigenous astronomy and the harm caused by light pollution.

The Conversation

Kai Lane works for Ecology Restoration Australia and also co-leads the Habitat Warriors program.

Jaana Dielenberg is an Ambassador for the Australasian Dark Sky Alliance, Science Communication Director of the Biodiversity Council, Honorary Fellow at The University of Melbourne and University Fellow (Biodiversity) at Charles Darwin University. She was previously employed under a grant funded by the Australian government's National Environmental Science Program Threatened Species Recovery Hub.

Kaori Yokochi is a lecturer at Deakin University. She receives funding from various organisations for her ecological research. She is also a member of the Network for Ecological Research on Artificial Light and the Australasian Dark Sky Alliance.

How to get more local sardines on Australian plates – a win for nutrition, local fishers and the environment

How to get more local sardines on Australian plates – a win for nutrition, local fishers and the environment

Most sardines served in Australia are imported. Anna Farmery

Australians should be eating more healthy and nutritious foods – but that likely won’t happen unless they’re also cheap, easy to transport and store, and simple to prepare.

Sardines fit the bill – they’re packed with healthy oils and calcium and have less mercury than bigger fish – and they’re increasingly appearing on menus at bars and restaurants (often served still in the can).

But while Australian sardines (Sardinops sagax) make up more than 25% of Australia’s total fisheries production, most of the sardines served in Australia are imported. Almost all Australian sardines are fed to tuna sold for export, used as fishing bait or in processed aquaculture feed and pet food.

This is a problem because it is depriving Australians of a nutritious, cheap and local food source.

My new paper, published in the journal Frontiers – Aquatic Food Systems, outlines a different vision that would see more local sardines on Australian plates, while also reducing emissions and boosting small, local fisheries.

Drawing on public consultations on the management of a proposed sardine fishery in Tasmania, I found strong support for local sardines to be used for food (for humans, not fish). Achieving this, however, will require overcoming several food system challenges – including boosting demand.

But what if I don’t like sardines?

That’s OK!

Everyone has different tastes, and this isn’t about forcing people to eat sardines.

But it’s worth noting the foods we like are determined by a range of factors including culture, marketing and experiences.

For example, Atlantic salmon was not popular in Japan until Norway launched its “Project Japan” strategy in the 1980s and ‘90s to create a new market for its surplus farmed fish. In Japan, Atlantic salmon went from a food to avoid to a sushi staple.

Closer to home, lobsters were once considered a “poor man’s food” until their relatively recent rebranding as a luxury product.

Clever rebranding and marketing could help boost demand for local sardines among Australians. But to really make a difference, several other challenges also need to be overcome.

Policy change

For the companies that harvest seafood, and governments that design management plans and policies, the most important things about fisheries are long-term biological sustainability and maximising economic returns.

Unfortunately, whether or not the product is boosting nutrition for Australians is currently considered “out of scope”.

So even though local sardines are super nutritious, they won’t end up on Australian dinner tables if it’s not profitable.

Changes in policy could help, though.

For example, small and medium-scale fishers need secure and stable fishing rights to ensure they can get loans to buy boats, fishing gear and processing equipment.

Large-scale enterprises don’t face the same financial constraints. At present, though, the larger enterprises interested in the sardine fishery would likely process sardines as aquaculture feed rather than human food.

So, one way to help get more local sardines onto Australian dinner tables is to consider how government agencies that manage fishing rights can provide longer-term, secure and consistent fishing rights to smaller fishers.

Establish clear and reliable markets

Fishers won’t fish for local sardines on any meaningful scale unless clear and reliable markets have been established.

Government could help small fishers explore new local markets for Australian sardines, such as public institutions.

Increasing the availability of sardines in residential aged care, for example, would support the recommendations of the recent aged care royal commission, which highlighted the need to improve food and nutrition given that 40% of aged care residents in Australia are malnourished.

Supporting fishers to supply residential aged care would help create new markets and certainty. It would also reduce the amount of imported seafood supplied to residential care food service kitchens. Governments could, for instance, act as a broker to connect aged care providers with fishers to develop contracts.

Supplying more local seafood, such as sustainably managed sardines, would be a climate-positive choice too. They have much lower greenhouse gas emissions, compared with other marine or terrestrial protein sources, and fewer food-miles than imported products.

Despite their value, fisheries are also often not recognised in key food policies and strategies.

People tend not to think of fishers as food producers and they don’t get the same levels of support as other food producers.

For example, the harvesting of wild fishery resources is not eligible for Tasmania’s AgriGrowth Loan Scheme. Under this scheme, the Tasmanian government provides low-interest loans to Tasmanian farm businesses and agri-food businesses.

It would help if state government departments – such as health and natural resource departments – took a joint approach to finding ways to get more local sardines on Australian plates.

A triple win

Developing a fishery that aims to meet demand for food, alongside ecological and economic targets, will also help ensure the fishery remains small.

This will reduce pressure on natural resources, as the volume of catch needed to meet that demand will likely be smaller than a larger fishery developed to meet demand for fish feed.

Sardines will probably never be as popular in Australia as they are in Portugal or Morocco.

However, replacing even some ultraprocessed foods in Australian diets with sardines would be a big win for health, small-scale fishers and the environment.

The Conversation

Anna Farmery receives funding from the Australian Research Council and the Australian Centre for International Agriculture. She is also paid by the National Health and Medical Research Council as a member of the Dietary Guidelines Sustainability Working Group.